3 ms·

For those wondering what a finite element model is: > FE models are computational tools developed by breaking an object down into simpler parts (finite element

by jitl 8y ago

For those wondering what a finite element model is: > FE models are computational tools developed by breaking an object down into simpler parts (finite elements) and assembling them into a larger system of equations to model an entire structure—this facilitates the efficient analysis of design changes to that structure. FE models have been used to improve designs in many engineered products, including those in the aeronautics and automotive industries.

Fenrisulfr 8y ago
So they used mechanical engineering techniques you would learn junior year or earlier. I'm sure they used FEA on earlier helmets as well. This just sounds fancier. The next version is probably going to be called the DiffEq models. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finite_element_method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finite_element_method
- Zanta 8y ago
  This is a very dismissive comment. Many of my peers in grad school were developing finite element techniques - it's a huge area of active ongoing research. Getting realistic results is very tough in an application with non-linear materials (probably looking at anisotropic composites) and possibly fractures like this.
- jwagenet 8y ago
  These FE models are almost certainly much more complicated than those tested in a junior year course. Anyone rig up a simulation and get some sort of result, but to get an accurate simulation result for a complex system like this requires thoughtful constraints, assumptions, and, as others mentioned, accurate material representations, among other things. FEA is a powerful tool, but much more complicated than providing a mesh and hitting go.
8note 8y ago
having a mechanical background: it's a way to define objects so you can throw more hardware at the problem to get better approximations on how they deform and break.

3 ms·

For those wondering what a finite element model is: > FE models are computational tools developed by breaking an object down into simpler parts (finite element

by jitl 8y ago

Fenrisulfr 8y ago
So they used mechanical engineering techniques you would learn junior year or earlier. I'm sure they used FEA on earlier helmets as well. This just sounds fancier. The next version is probably going to be called the DiffEq models. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finite_element_method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finite_element_method
- Zanta 8y ago
  This is a very dismissive comment. Many of my peers in grad school were developing finite element techniques - it's a huge area of active ongoing research. Getting realistic results is very tough in an application with non-linear materials (probably looking at anisotropic composites) and possibly fractures like this.
- jwagenet 8y ago
  These FE models are almost certainly much more complicated than those tested in a junior year course. Anyone rig up a simulation and get some sort of result, but to get an accurate simulation result for a complex system like this requires thoughtful constraints, assumptions, and, as others mentioned, accurate material representations, among other things. FEA is a powerful tool, but much more complicated than providing a mesh and hitting go.
8note 8y ago
having a mechanical background: it's a way to define objects so you can throw more hardware at the problem to get better approximations on how they deform and break.