4 ms·
Digression: I'm suspicious of philosophy because it throws around absolutes with nothing to back them. Like 'The mind is not capable of understanding blah blah'
by JoeAltmaier 9y ago
Digression: I'm suspicious of philosophy because it throws around absolutes with nothing to back them. Like 'The mind is not capable of understanding blah blah'. Really? What is this supposition based upon? Its like saying there's a highest number we can understand - but what if we add 1 to that?
- meric 9y agoBy your definition once 1 is added it’s not a number we can understand.
- Retra 9y agoYes, but the claim is that there is such a number, not that it can be defined.
- chrisvalleybay 9y agoA number is simply a state; a concept held by a state machine, such as a human. Numbers do not exist, but to the enumerator.
- Retra 9y agoThen it will be especially hard to argue that an inconceivable number exists.
- baldfat 9y agoWelcome to philosophy and why we are still in this mess academically in the 21st Century. Welcome to philosophy's number one question. What can we base anything on? To Spinoza it is rationalism. Soren Kierkegaard (My son is named after him) there is nothing but faith that we must leap upon when we have no faith.
- billybatson 9y agoDo you think that there is no limit to human understanding?
- whatshisface 9y agoWhatever it is, it's a psychological question. The only hope of answering it would be to go around measuring how much people could understand - and if that wasn't possible (due to understanding not being defined, i.e. not really meaning anything specific, or due to it just being really difficult to measure), then you'd have no chance of ever knowing.
- benjohnson 9y ago>>I'm suspicious of philosophy because it throws around absolutes with nothing to back Bertrand Russel had a definition of Philosophy that fits your suspicion - in that he said that Philosophy is the contested no-mans land between Theology and Science. Hence - you're probably not going to find absolutes.
- rhizome 9y agobut what if we add 1 to that? He's talking about the name of that number.