3 ms·
Power-density and energy-density. The "secret" to dense flywheel energy storage is in the equation: Energy = 1/2 * I * w^2 Where "w" is rotational speed in ra
by dragontamer 9y ago
Power-density and energy-density.
The "secret" to dense flywheel energy storage is in the equation: Energy = 1/2 * I * w^2
Where "w" is rotational speed in radians/sec, and I is rotational-inertia / rotational-mass. So you store the most energy by rotating it as fast as possible. 20,000 RPM stores 4x the energy of 10,000 RPM.
The issue with water, or really... anything outside of steel and other such incredibly strong materials... is that water doesn't hold itself together very well. As such, the RPM limit would be smaller than a steel-flywheel.
Indeed, steel is still not used in advanced flywheels, because some forms of plastic IIRC are superior at the kinds of stresses we're talking about. Thus, these plastic / composite material flywheels, while much lighter, can spin much faster.
Leading to more efficient energy storage.
-----------------
In effect, you need every part of the flywheel designed to hold itself together to reach maximum efficiency. Water is the exact opposite. Its a lot of mass but basically no ability to handle stresses. Solid Steel would be better and would spin faster.
- RobertRoberts 9y agoThat is really interesting, thanks for explaining it. I want to ask then, based on other comments, that size can greatly improve the amount stored. So wouldn't a larger safer flywheel work in many places? Also, my thought on the water as a solid, consider a steel wheel where instead of steel all the way through, put a liquid inside of a cavity. Since water doesn't compress, it would essentially be part of the same wheel, only safer in a collision? (arm-chair engineer) I enjoy reading comments like yours so I can move on/let go of my from my silly pet ideas. :)
- dragontamer 9y ago> Also, my thought on the water as a solid, consider a steel wheel where instead of steel all the way through, put a liquid inside of a cavity Well, consider that solid steel is considered too weak for a modern flywheel. So that questions why you'd be removing steel instead of adding more of it. Modern flywheels spin really, really, really fast. Again, fast enough that modern solid steel is too weak. Newer composite materials are superior, but still need to be designed for maximum structural integrity. Once a flywheel spins fast enough, it literally rips itself apart due to centrifugal forces. Any "cavity" weakens the structure and will break sooner.
- oneiric 9y agoCarbon fiber composite (not exactly plastic) is strong and light, which is what you want for a flywheel. There a few more relevant expressions for flywheels to express that you want them to be on the edge of breaking at maximum energy storage. http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2010/ph240/wheeler1/ http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2010/ph240/wheeler1/
- ams6110 9y agoYou don't want light in a flywheel. You want mass.
- King-Aaron 9y agoWell, in the context of storing energy, you want mass in the flywheel. Having a lightened flywheel is beneficial in, say, racing applications however... But that's not really important in this discussion.
- ridgeguy 9y agoNo - as the immediate prior post correctly stated, stored energy increases linearly with m (flywheel mass) and as the square of rotation rate (omega^2) So a flywheel having 0.1m rotor mass spinning at 10omega stores 10 times as much energy as a flywheel of 1.0m spinning at 1omega. 10% of the mass, 1000% of the stored energy of the heavier, slower rotor. Of course, the rotor has to be able to handle increased circumferential and radial stresses resulting from increased omega. Carbon fiber (like T1000 grade) has extremely high tensile strength (lets you spin a carbon fiber rotor very fast) but low density. T1000 rotors store more energy at lower mass than steel (or any other metal) because of the proportionality to omega^2 and their high tensile strength. But for commercial storage, it's really about the $/kWhr/mass in terms of the overall rotor economics. By that metric, it's hard to beat a composite rotor with E-glass as the major fiber. It's cheaper than carbon fiber by easily 100X and has about 30% to 50% of CF tensile strength. It's a bit denser than CF, but its cost metric is why most modern large energy storage flywheels use glass/CF hybrid composites and magnetic bearings (for high speed and zero wear). In the old days, they made flywheels out of solid steel, then switched to piano wire (higher tensile strength). Then fiberglass, aramids and carbon fiber happened.