4 ms·
>We live in an enlightened era. Our mental toolboxes are full to bursting with evidence-based reasoning, with precedent, with doubt, and with logic. We hold man
by andrepd 9y ago
>We live in an enlightened era. Our mental toolboxes are full to bursting with evidence-based reasoning, with precedent, with doubt, and with logic. We hold many truths to be self evident. We stand on the shoulders of intellectual giants and we think this plain of shoulders is ground level.
>If you want to think medieval, chuck your entire toolbox out the window and start from scratch. You need to un-learn rationality, un-learn concepts you've been steeped in since childhood.
This is one thing I've thought about before and that made quite an impression on me. We are physically identical to humans in the 14th century, or any period of history for that matter. Same brains, same "intelligence". But we would never dream of doing most things that were commonplace in the 14th century, we would never tolerate living in the way they did. Some things we know are elementary and almost childish in their simplicity, but took millenia. They looked at the world in a way that seems entirely silly to us. Aristotle was probably more intelligent than anybody in this thread, however he believed the most ridiculous things, same for, oh I don't know, Julius Caesar or St Thomas Aquinus.
We all are in a very real sense standing on the shoulders of billions, and their slow and tortuous progress.
- Clubber 9y agoThe thing that blows me away is homo sapiens have been around 300K years (latest evidence). Imagine living with a current brain psysiology 300K years ago. What the hell did we do for all that time? http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/06/world-s-oldest-homo-sapiens-fossils-found-morocco http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2017/06/world-s-oldest-homo-s...
- ItsMe000001 9y agoIt occurred to me some time ago that the big question is the opposite: What do we not do that humans thousands of years ago did with their brains? My thoughts went like this: Since the brain is quite expensive evolution would not have grown it so much if it had not been needed. But this means humans really used all that brain. That means if we now use it for so many very different things in a very - very! - recent technological world, with an equally recent extreme increase in population density worldwide (both movement top cities as well as the unprecedented total population size increase), what exactly did they do? I think that this indeed is a very interesting question, I'm not sure we can answer it. Medieval brains are one thing, but what about 20,000 years ago? The brain must already have been pretty much the same.
- kaybe 9y agoEmotions and relationships with other humans are still hard though.
- ItsMe000001 9y agoBut relationships have become a lot more complex with the huge increase in population density, plus a lot more flexibility and movement. We now have to deal with a lot more people than any of our ancient ancestors, and a lot of change. Our networks of work and cooperation are unprecedented by anything in history too.
- nsp 9y agoEnlightenment now by Steven pinker covers this in great detail (and is a fun read), if you’re interested in this sort of thing