2 ms·
I think the part that people have trouble with is the idea of not having control over their own hardware. Not that I agree with this, but the reasoning is somet
by jacobolus 16y ago
I think the part that people have trouble with is the idea of not having control over their own hardware. Not that I agree with this, but the reasoning is something like: if you buy a physical device, you own it, and should be able to do anything you want with it, including using its full capabilities.
The conflicting moral intuitions here are about ownership of an object vs. payment in exchange for a set of benefits. In terms of the latter, this is clearly a case where everyone wins, but that doesn’t prevent it from seeming “wrong” in terms of the former.
This is really quite similar to the “wrongness” people feel about, say, region-locked DVDs.
- sjs 16y ago> if you buy a physical device, you own it, and should be able to do anything you want with it, including using its full capabilities. Previously there was no official way to enable disabled cache or cores, though some motherboards provided such functionality. Now there is an official way but you have to pay for it. Intel is giving you more control over the hardware they sell you. I guess we could debate whether or not it's fair to charge for that capability, but considering that till now the general consensus is that low-end CPUs are ridiculously cheap for the given performance I don't feel like there's much to debate. 2 years after buying a low-end CPU you can pay $50 and unlock some extra cache or cores for even more performance, instead of upgrading to a new CPU (and possibly motherboard and RAM). Sounds like a win to me.
- crystalis 16y ago> Intel is selling you more control over the hardware they sell you
- zokier 16y agoIn any way is it worse than not having that control at all (ie the current status quo)?
- jacobolus 16y agoI don’t disagree with you; I’m just trying to explain the possible logic behind people’s discomfort.