7 ms·
In my opinion: - designing your resume - EQ - having a deep, enthusiastic, and genuine interest in some aspect of the company - Think of your resume like a
by falcolas 9y ago
In my opinion:
- designing your resume
- EQ
- having a deep, enthusiastic, and genuine interest in some aspect of the company
- Think of your resume like a poem
- visual representation of their experience/resume
These are great criteria for hiring a designer or marketing personnel, but these are TERRIBLE criteria for hiring a technical person.
In my fantasy world, a technical resume is in a monospaced font and is eminently readable; I would expect the resume to look good in a code editor.
My fantasy applicant would be very precise in the tech they list, and when asked questions, they would gripe about that technology all day long; if they can't complain about its shortcomings and pitfalls, they didn't use it.
They would not match the job criteria on the posting exactly, because the criteria on the job posting is for some fantasy developer that doesn't actually exist. I would instead expect them to have figured out the core of the actual stack and list it instead.
Sadly, my fantasy world doesn't exist, and we have to pretend we're designers to work around people like this who have no idea how to hire actual technical people.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoA good balance between highly technical and creatively designed is to write your resume with TeX.
- dabockster 9y agoIs that more of a recommendation or a hard requirement? I've been using a bland resume that I thought would check all the boxes inside an ATS.
- danaliv 9y agoI used to think this was a good idea, but I see so many resumes done in TeX that they cease to stand out.
- Sir_Cmpwn 9y agoOf course, just throwing TeX at your resume isn't enough. However, TeX gives you tools at an engineer's level which can be used to make your resume stand out.
- iteriteratedone 9y agoWhat is up with this bs... cant you guys read the content and decipher if the candidate is intervewable*. Whats up with american psycho business card routine I have education , and job history ... im succinct with tech info and explain any management responsibilities. What does it matter if that is monospaced or in tex?
- enervate 9y agoI took a resume like this to the career center at my university and got out of that appointment with a lot of disappointment.
- claytonjy 9y agoI had a similar experience, and at an engineering university no less. The career center was very good if you were a mech/civil/elec engineer wanting to work for a big co, which was maybe 70-80% of undergrads, but that wasn't me. Very glad I turned down almost all their advice and stuck to my LaTeX resume.
- emidln 9y agoI've received a fair number of job offers over the years with a resume that I forward to people as emidln_at_gmail_dot_com_Brandon_Adams_resume.txt. I do work in various development/programming/sysadmin roles. If someone requests html, word, or pdf I just convert it for them.
- Consultant32452 9y agoMost of us aren't on the cutting edge of technology. I've personally never worked on a team whose biggest problem was a lack of technical prowess, the problems are always social/cultural.
- falcolas 9y agoIf I'm being frank, then you need to be up front about that in the job posting. "Cultural fit" and other PC BS won't cut it - be honest about what you need. "We need someone who can design and implement frontends alongside our product marketing group." Not, "Looking for a JavaScript, Typescript, Angular, React, Node.js, Mongo, and BerkleyDB rockstar." Because I've personally watched several people who were cultural fits and great talkers be PIPed and fired purely for the lack of an ability to execute technical tasks.
- majormajor 9y agoI'm confused by which side you're comparing to the bit in your last sentence to. All they did was fit in and talk? That's not enough. You have to be able to navigate the work environment and find a way to get stuff delivered. Which your "design and implement" part captures, but "cultural fit and great talker" doesn't.
- Consultant32452 9y agoI've written and deleted this message a dozen times trying to get it right without it coming off as an attack. I hope you won't take it that way because I'm genuinely trying to be helpful. The way you parse "Looking for a JavaScript, Typescript, Angular, React, Node.js, Mongo, and BerkleyDB rockstar." sounds like the way I would expect an autistic person to parse it, too literally. Every job everywhere has an implied requirement that you will be able to communicate and work effectively alongside other humans. Since it's a requirement everywhere, hardly anyone will list it explicitly. When I read: >"Looking for a JavaScript, Typescript, Angular, React, Node.js, Mongo, and BerkleyDB rockstar." I parse it as: "We need someone who can design and implement frontends alongside our product marketing group. Our technology stack is JavaScript, Typescript, Angular, React, Node.js, Mongo, and BerkleyDB."
- rb808 9y ago> they would gripe about that technology all day long; if they can't complain about its shortcomings and pitfalls, they didn't use it. Lol that is gold. I have to add that section to my interviewing questions.
- sanderjd 9y agoI disagree. I used to be this gripe-y person, but the more experience I gained, the more I realized that everything is just the result of its trade-offs and started finding the griping both boring - who wants to complain constantly for years and years? - and less productive than maintaining more of an anthropologist's mindset. So to me, constant griping is more of a not-that-much-experience signal.
- rb808 9y agoAgreed, I wouldn't want continual moaning, I'd like to hear about the problems they experienced, and have the knowledge that on a different platform/framework that would be better, but you'd give up something.
- BigJono 9y agoThis is the most important question I ask in every interview. The goal isn't to get someone to piss and moan about every little thing, it's to see if they can identify any downsides to the tech they use. IME >80% of candidates have never even thought about it, treat every tool/dependency as free, and whatever tech they happen to use was written by the second coming of tech Jesus and contains no faults.
- s73v3r_ 9y ago"and we have to pretend we're designers to work around people like this who have no idea how to hire actual technical people." I honestly don't know what you mean by this.
- falcolas 9y agoMy current resume has approximately 6 different fonts, left and right justified fields, bullet points, and tables just so it looks just good enough to get past the HR drones (many of whom are wonderful people despite being a resume gatekeeper). It was an agonizing process, but the end result is something that recruiters recognize as being well designed. I hate having to maintain it. That's what I mean by pretending.
- commandlinefan 9y ago> 6 different fonts Dear God, is that really what they're looking for? Tech hiring gets more ridiculous every day.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoDon't believe 6 different fonts in a piece is considered good design.
- falcolas 9y agoIt's what was needed. And my use of the word fonts is a bit incorrect, it was a total of 6 different font faces (bold, italics, different sizes, different fonts). Sorry about that. - Name - largest on the page, picked a font that looked good at that size - Email address - monospaced font, colored to appear as a link (which seems silly, but helps pull attention to it since it's the primary contact method for me) - Physical address - Small font, so it, my phone number, and email address occupy roughly the same visual space as my name. Also, a different font to fit the reduced size without impacting readability Per job: - Company name and title - Larger than the description - Dates - Small so they can exist on the same line as the company name, but a different font to be legible. - Descriptions and duties (also used for summary) - The baseline for font and size. A quick glance at my resume won't show the design choices made; it's supposed to be subtle while retaining legibility through a fax machine (you wouldn't believe the lack of quality of some of the resumes which I've been handed over the years). That subtlty/readability is what took the longest.
- alkonaut 9y ago> they would gripe about that technology all day long; if they can't complain about its shortcomings and pitfalls, they didn't use it. I have literally baited people I interview with this type of thing. Asked about things I know everyone who has come in contact with has cut themselves on and been upset about.
- tashi 9y agoSome candidates, depending on their backgrounds, may be wary of being thought of as complainers or being "difficult." Something to look out for.
- daveslash 9y agoA question that I've been using lately is to ask a candidate to pick some technology (anything) that they have strong feelings about - positive or negative. I'll then throw out a couple of examples: "I really like A about B thing" and "In language X I really dislike Y because Z" -- I'm looking to see that they've really thought critically about some technology. Anything.
- Jemmeh 9y agoThis seems better, it's more about tradeoffs. I don't really feel the need to complain about languages. I just find the workaround and implement it and move on. All languages have trade offs. I can tell you that this one lends more to scaling projects or this one is easier to maintain, this one is easier to iterate, etc. But getting upset doesn't do anything. You just pick the best you can and work with it. I'm not going to get mad that my hammer isn't also a drill.
- alkonaut 9y agoEvery technology is designed through tradeoffs. Choosing a technology and the using it properly reqires understanding those tradeoffs. What they are, why they were made. I whine about the appetite for secret allocation that my C# program has. I whine about the mess that is writing the equivalent C++ or Go code, and the learning curve of doing it in Rust. It’s whining on the surface but it’s really 90% tradeoffs and 10% badness. Being able to critique design mistakes in eg. an API means you have a pretty deep knowledge on the domain (and/or API design in general). Being able to argue the downsides of a certain technological tradeoff (such as GC vs not, dynamic vs static) is also important. No one will be able to win an argument on tabs/spaces or dynamic vs static but everyone should be able to point out some drawbacks and benefits. Describing the merits of a technology is just as good as describing the drawbacks. I chose drawbacks/whine because (unfortunately) I am myself much more enthusiastic when describing flaws than positive sides - itself a flaw, but a very common one.
- rohan_ 9y agoHad to nitpick on the monospaced font line. Proportional type preserves the shape of words which is a huge part of readability. I don't think I'd take a resume that looks like it was written in a code editor as a positive signal. https://www.quora.com/Typography-Monospaced-fonts-what-are-the-pros-and-cons-for-the-reader https://www.quora.com/Typography-Monospaced-fonts-what-are-t...
- carlmr 9y agoI'm glad Apple brought fonts to the computer world as well.
- rejschaap 9y agoIt's his fantasy world, so who are we to judge. As a gimmick I could appreciate and would definitely notice a resume printed with a dot matrix printer on pinfeed paper using Courier. But I would recommend everyone to just stick with a nice serif typeface.
- carapace 9y agoThere's this one recruiter company that calls me up every six months or so. We always do the same dance: First they ask me for my most recent updated resume. I send it to them. It's a text file. No fancy formatting, no fonts, not even any Unicode, just ASCII. They always ask me to reformat it, and they always send me the same example resume, and they always explain to me very nicely that they want my resume to make a good impression. I never do it. Mostly because I'm lazy, but also because I don't care. That resume gets me jobs. I've never posted it to Craigslist and not gotten responses and a job. Sometimes they nag me once or twice and sometimes I just don't hear back from them. Now the thing that puzzles me about this the most is, why, for goodness' sake, don't they have somebody on staff to do the reformatting for me? My hourly rate is not low, y'know? I know they have an office full of people 'cause I've been there. If it's such a crucial step, why not provide it as a value-add service? Oh well. Not really my problem. Just a weird recruiter thought I wanted to share. :-)
- whack 9y agoProbably because recruiting is a crapshoot numbers game. Emailing massive numbers of people is easy. They have pre-written templates, so the marginal time spent is minimal. Forwarding resumes along is easy as heck too. But customizing someone's entire resume? That doesn't scale. They would have to... you know... actually value you.
- teachrdan 9y agoBecause you're not compliant, and a compliant candidate is easier for them to place. If you won't reformat your resume to look like pretty much everyone else's, how can they count on you to take a bunch of pointless phone calls for positions that may only vaguely match your skillset in the hopes that one is a match and they get their blood money?
- jtmcmc 9y agoI think EQ is incredibly important to engineers or to anyone who is working in a team and "EQ" or put more casually, is this person a self aware, nice person that can work well with other people, is absolutely something I care about in hiring.