6 ms·
Why falling demand hasn't brought down college sticker prices
- larrik 9y ago"Many institutions boasted, in the admission season just ended, that they had received record numbers of applications. What most very carefully didn’t say was that record numbers of applicants are lining up to be accepted." I read this like 3 times, then the article, then again, but I can't parse it. What is it really saying here?
- lainga 9y agoI am guessing that total applications are up while total numbers of applicants are down (and thus there are more applications submitted per person)?
- barkingcat 9y agoProbably one student would apply to more schools? So even though they had a ton of applications (each school would have seen a rise in # of applications), these schools are chasing down a fewer number of actual people. When I was a student, I applied to 3 colleges (1 nearby, 2 far away), nowadays maybe students apply to 20 or 30?
- credit_guy 9y agoThis sounds like a reasonable explanation, but do colleges have transparency into who applied where nationwide? I would expect a college to know the absolute exact number of its own applicants/applications, but beyond that it should be only an educated guess, as long as the SAT is not in the business of selling everybody their data. But then, who knows, maybe the SAT is doing exactly that.
- jdeibele 9y agoYes. One of the things that's different is that there's now https://www.commonapp.org/ https://www.commonapp.org/ which says "you can apply to more than 700 colleges" using it. To some degree, application fees (paid per college) are still a deterrent but some people qualify for free application fees. There was an article about a young woman who was accepted at more than 100 colleges. http://www.ibtimes.com/teen-gets-accepted-more-100-colleges-2677734 http://www.ibtimes.com/teen-gets-accepted-more-100-colleges-... Applying to X more colleges at $50 or $75 each where one of them may offer 10% or 20% more in aid makes for an interesting decision.
- gowld 9y agoCommon App is at least 20 years old.
- pzh 9y agoIt says that a record number of applicants are applying to each institution but the number that are going to attend is lower.
- spike021 9y agoShotgun approach. Similar to how people apply for a bunch of software engineer positions at a plethora of companies, when they only would really want to work for maybe 1/5 of them. Back when I was a senior in high school there was a newer (at the time, I suppose) idea that college admission was a "crapshoot", so the common suggestion was to apply to a bunch of universities, even the ones you weren't very interested in as "backups" or whatever.
- killjoywashere 9y agoThis happened a long time ago in med school admissions. You can essentially calculate how many schools you need to apply to in order to get accepted. You will have to route d up or down given your demographics, but US News and World Reports will give you a really good guess.
- matte_black 9y agoLots of impressions, very few conversions.
- pg_bot 9y agoThe average person is applying to more colleges, but the total number of people attending college is decreasing. Therefore each college can promote that they received more applications than the previous year. People don't typically attend more than one college simultaneously. ex: 20 people applying to 3 colleges each, vs 10 people applying to 10 colleges each.
- robohoe 9y agoSo basically like a conversion rate of applicants to students.
- brdd 9y agoI only read the article (and not the podcast, if it's different) but I think their argument misrepresents how the economics of higher education work. > "Economics 101 suggests that declining demand results in lower prices." This isn't true for college sticker prices because colleges have perfect price discrimination. Most students don't pay the sticker price; they pay exactly what they "can". In no other industry do we have such perfect incentives aligned on the provider side to increase prices-- - People who can't afford the higher prices can pay less, through financial aid and scholarship programs. - To determine what is the "maximum" price you can pay, the student/parent voluntarily provides literally every data point possible. Every tax record, every loan, etc. - Because of this perfect price discrimination, an upward trend in college costs (that outpaces inflation) is not only reasonable but expected. It's in the interest of the institution to maximize its surplus/profit to the student's upper limit.
- squozzer 9y agoAlso, Econ 101 is essentially a naïve exercise in optimizing price-demand curves (find where f'(x) = 0), which assumes prices always converge on a supply-demand equilibrium point. Another model, found in utilities, fixes the cost point, so when demand falls, prices rise. Did you ever buy into your electric company's "conservation program" and cut your consumption, only to have your rates rise? Congrats, you just got rick-rolled by capitalism, comrade sucker.
- oflannabhra 9y agoThe point of the podcast, at least, is that despite all of your points, colleges are taking on enormous amounts of debt, while enrollment is shrinking. They are losing money.
- onlyrealcuzzo 9y agoFor established non-profit schools? Or new, mostly for-profit schools? I find it hard to believe any reputable, 20+ year-old, non-profit schools are losing money. They should own their assets outright, have extremely low interest rates on any outstanding debt, pay close to 0 taxes. Wages for non-executive staff are not keeping pace with inflation. How are they losing money?
- sp332 9y agoThe article doesn't mention that middle management exploded at colleges in the last few years, and those people are going to try to hold on to their jobs no matter how low enrollment gets. http://blogs.wgbh.org/on-campus/2014/2/6/growth-nonacademic-deanlets-outpaces-faculty-hires/ http://blogs.wgbh.org/on-campus/2014/2/6/growth-nonacademic-... Also I think the part about half of tuition at one school going to "discounts and financial aid for freshmen" is misleading. That's not really costing the college money, they're just charging less to begin with.
- moorhosj 9y agoIt’s costs the college revenue, just as tax cuts cost the government revenue.
- sp332 9y agoKinda, I mean they're not really spending half their tuition on breaks so much as overstating tuition by 100%.
- gowld 9y agoThat's like saying piracy costs $TICKET_PRICE * #viewings, or that the value of donated software is its sticker price, or that buying a department store shirt "on sale" costs the seller any money. It completely ignores the possibility of non-purchase, which is the dominant alternative among options. "Would have paid" is a tiny fraction.
- jfasi 9y agoI wonder how this drop in demand is distributed between American students who are eligible for financial aid and federally-backed student loans and foreign students who almost always pay full price. As an anecdote from my own engineering school experience, a staggeringly large proportion of my classes were populated by foreign, usually Chinese and Indian, students. My college has a pretty good brand, and I understand many of these students were willing to pay to have its cachet on their resume. Also, many of these students, especially the Chinese ones, seemed to be from very well-off families (at least if the number of Canada Goose coats and Supreme hoodies is any indication). This is an anecdote, so take it with a grain of salt, but it suggests a hypothesis: maybe the drop in demand is among American students who are mostly paying discounted prices anyway, while demand among foreign students who are willing and able to pay the staggering sticker price remains high.
- gowld 9y ago> (at least if the number of Canada Goose coats and Supreme hoodies is any indication). Why crane your neck to check the outfits, when you can glance at their cars? http://www.mlive.com/lansing-news/index.ssf/2014/04/michigan_state_chinese_student.html http://www.mlive.com/lansing-news/index.ssf/2014/04/michigan... "People who haven't visited Michigan State University's campus lately may be surprised to find Maseratis, Lamborghinis and Bentleys driving around. ...:
- lazyasciiart 9y agoIn most class environments it's a lot easier to look at someone's clothing than to follow them out to the parking lot and check their car.
- crb002 9y agoFederal Student Loan bubble sets a price floor screwing all the poor students with debt they otherwise could avoid in a free market.
- pessimizer 9y agoSadly, they would also avoid college in a free market. The problem is that the state should be setting a price floor of $0, which would limit the motivation to compete on debt to private schools.
- zamalek 9y agoThe first university I went to was probably suffering from all of the following: > the number of students is actually down by 2.6 million > they have struggled to reduce their costs > they’ve borrowed billions of dollars to build amenities they think will attract students After two years (2/3 of a degree in South Africa) I had been challenged by precisely one subject - all the while I was hemorrhaging money. The amenities were fantastic and I never once used them. Not realizing how the importance of a degree and anger from learning sweet nothing resulted in me leaving. It was an expensive degree printing press and nothing more. Ten years later I need a degree to help with my visa. The experience is night and day. In a course that I just completed, I had to submit an assignment, and the feedback my lecturer provided was incredible: I honestly don't know how she finds the time of day if she's working that hard for all of her students. I walked away feeling as though I had learned something valuable, even though it is one of those general courses that you usually question why you have to take. These people seem to really care about furthering and imparting knowledge. It shows. The entire experience is streamlined around learning. You can't send your kids there (as they require a professional background), but I hope this catches on by the time my kids have to go to college. If these behemoths want to reduce costs while attracting more students, it's all too easy; do less and focus on the product: learning. That approach saved IT/CS from ballooning costs and deadlines, and I have first-hand experience suggesting that it can also work in education.
- technologyvault 9y agoA few observations about this "will the traditional college survive" situation, which I've been following for a long time. The higher education market feels a bit like the healthcare market in that it's somewhat difficult for the consumer to tell what the actual cost will be prior to purchasing the product. Published tuition rates and other costs of attending school feel like they're abstracted until a long-term commitment has been made and it's too late to get a refund. It may seem strange that, with the increasing debt being amassed by universities, record-breaking new salaries are being offered by many of these schools to football and basketball coaches. The 25 salaries for college football coaches range from $3.5M to over $11M per year. I'd assume that in each of those cases, the value received from the coaching hire contributes overall to the school's bottom line. As much of the same information that is taught in college becomes more accessible for free on the internet, it's hard to see how colleges can compete with smaller, more agile competitors who don't have nearly the overhead that universities do. It feels a bit like retail stores trying to compete with Amazon.
- lordCarbonFiber 9y agoExcept that the raw "information" taught in colleges doesn't represent enough value to even show up as a line item in a cost breakdown. Anyone can read a book, or even watch a lecture; the value add is access to research, access to professors, and perhaps most importantly, access to a community of motivated(to a degree) students all in plus/minus the same point in their lives. MOOCs on the internet can't compete on any of these metrics.
- akgoel 9y agoThe only "value add" for colleges is the signaling provided by getting the degree, i.e. going through the application process and committing to finishing a 4 year degree. This is most easily measured in the income data for college-grads vs non-college-grads. This data is so easy to measure that you can measure the "value" of a college degree, currently something like $17K per year more for the graduates.
- 9y ago
- drblast 9y agoObviously they need larger football stadiums to bring in that TV money.
- clarkevans 9y agoPerhaps student loans should be co-signed by the universities they get their degree from? At least this way, there may be a reasonable alignment of incentives for the university to provide valuable, cost-effective education.