3 ms·
Are you saying it's impossible to shut off the car while not in park? I find that odd, and will certainly have to try it on my mother's Toyota when I get the ch
by mrguyorama 9y ago
Are you saying it's impossible to shut off the car while not in park? I find that odd, and will certainly have to try it on my mother's Toyota when I get the chance
- singingboyo 9y agoYeah, that seems odd to me. I drive a Nissan, not a Toyota, but it will shut off if I hit the button before going into park, then beep like there's no tomorrow until it's in park. Though it occurs to me that the old Dodge Caravan I drove before may have required being in park to turn off, though it used the key for ignition, so that made sense.
- schiffern 9y ago>Are you saying it's impossible to shut off the car while not in park? Yes! The vehicle faithfully ignores you when you press the Start button, beeps softly, and displays a message: "SHIFT TO P POSITION."[2] As I said, in my experience there's a ~1s delay between shifting to Park and being permitted to turn the car off. You get the same error message, but it's already in Park. The result? Performing the same sequence of actions at a different speed results in a very different outcome. And the Park button (yes I know) is very close to the Start button, so it's easy to perform the two actions in quick succession. Classic race condition. Btw, you can't just press Start again. Even though it's now "in Park." It's in some strange, poorly defined, in-between state, not Park but not Not-Park. To recover, you have to press the Park button again, and then press the Start button again. From a software perspective, this makes me uneasy. It would be easy to miss such the subtle cues indicating an error (soft beep/message/IC doesn't down). Especially for older people who are hard of hearing, and just pulled into the garage from a sunny drive (bright pupil adaptation takes longer to dilate for older people). From the Prius GenIII manual[1], pp549 > * Stopping the hybrid system >Set the parking brake, shift the shift position to P and press the “POWER” switch as you normally do when stopping the hybrid system. Setting the parking brake is optional, but shifting to Park is not. There's also a confusing chart with all the warning messages that should explain this behavior, but doesn't. It's on pp525, and it seems to have evidence of incomplete revision: >The driver’s door has been opened with the shift position in a position other than P and without first turning the “POWER” switch is OFF. There is no power switch, just a button, and the grammar is wrong. Hmmm... Curiouser and curiouser. [1] https://priuschat.com/threads/2012-2015-prius-owners-manual-combined-pdf.149300/ https://priuschat.com/threads/2012-2015-prius-owners-manual-... [2] Btw, googling for "shift to P position" indicates that both Hyundai and Kia have this interlock. Whether they're subject to the same race condition is unknown.
- mrguyorama 9y agoIs this possibly a Prius only flaw?