2 ms·
This isn't such a case. The court is not basing its opinion on immediate outcomes. This isn't like them declaring something constitutionally protected so that
by sandworm101 9y ago
This isn't such a case. The court is not basing its opinion on immediate outcomes. This isn't like them declaring something constitutionally protected so that people can begin doing it the next day. This is them saying that governments are able to regulate, but only via means dictated by the court. This isn't about returning power to the people. This is about shifting power between various branches of government. Some of those branches are more hamstrung than others. By moving power to a branch that is unable to use it (ie a legislature chronically unable to pass laws) the court asserts its own power as kingmaker.
- brownbat 9y ago> with the legislature so weakened it can exercise control over national policies > You can always interpret any SCOTUS decision in terms of ... immediate outcomes [but generally shouldn't] > This isn't such a case. The court is not basing its opinion on immediate outcomes. I think we agree? I must have completely misread your original post, where I thought you said that SCOTUS was making a policy decision.