4 ms·
Essentially this is an extension of DCC principals. Where the state has power to regulate, but actively chooses not so to do, another government cannot usurp.
by sandworm101 9y ago
Essentially this is an extension of DCC principals. Where the state has power to regulate, but actively chooses not so to do, another government cannot usurp.
This is SCOTUS throwing down a gauntlet. Sports gambling, virtually all of which being online, is ripe for commerce clause regulation. Congress knows how it can take the reigns if it wants to. SCOTUS is saying it isn't going to accept half-hearted attempts to regulate in this area... in full knowledge that a serious legislative effort in this area is near-impossible in the current climate. This is the supreme court asserting itself, showing that with the legislature so weakened it can exercise control over national policies. imho.
- jessriedel 9y ago> This is SCOTUS throwing down a gauntlet....This is the supreme court asserting itself, In general, I don't find unified personifications of groups of disagreeing humans to be very illuminating. Do you have any evidence this particular ruling is a coordinated action by the justices of the Supreme Court to communicate anything beyond their explicit decision to anyone? Or are you just speculating?
- sandworm101 9y agoYou seriously think that the various branches of the US government aren't in a constant power struggle? Such conflict underpins the very American concept of checks and balances. As I said in another post: This isn't about allowing people to gamble or not. This is isn't even about deciding who has the power to regulate gambling as both levels of government can if they want. This is the court reminding everyone who gets to referee in this game.
- jessriedel 9y agoFoxes (as a species) and hawks (as a species) are in a power struggle for who gets to eat the rabbits, but this does not mean that hawks are coordinating with each other to do anything, nor that the hawks are trying to communicate anything to the foxes even though information flows between them.
- brownbat 9y agoYou can always interpret any SCOTUS decision in terms of the specific and immediate outcomes, but it takes you to somewhat odd conclusions. Like that a group of people who spent their entire academic and professional careers studying how subtle shifts in texts adjust balance of power, and how ambiguous rulemaking leads to unintended consequences have a deep and overwhelming interest in how people entertain themselves online. If your business is making rules about rules, then you're going to see everything else as parochial, you're playing a game with slightly higher stakes. It's like someone proposing a change in an instruction set and everyone's focused on possible impacts on UX for a handful of websites.
- sandworm101 9y agoThis isn't such a case. The court is not basing its opinion on immediate outcomes. This isn't like them declaring something constitutionally protected so that people can begin doing it the next day. This is them saying that governments are able to regulate, but only via means dictated by the court. This isn't about returning power to the people. This is about shifting power between various branches of government. Some of those branches are more hamstrung than others. By moving power to a branch that is unable to use it (ie a legislature chronically unable to pass laws) the court asserts its own power as kingmaker.
- brownbat 9y ago> with the legislature so weakened it can exercise control over national policies > You can always interpret any SCOTUS decision in terms of ... immediate outcomes [but generally shouldn't] > This isn't such a case. The court is not basing its opinion on immediate outcomes. I think we agree? I must have completely misread your original post, where I thought you said that SCOTUS was making a policy decision.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Like that a group of people who spent their entire academic and professional careers studying how subtle shifts in texts adjust balance of power Uh, that's mostly not what judges spend their professional careers doing or what lawyers spend their academic careers doing. It's what academic political scientists focussing on judicial and regulatory politics do, but that's not a background that tends to get you nominated for the Supreme Court.