5 ms·
Cute, but I think there is a substantial difference between not born and dead.
by taeric 9y ago
Cute, but I think there is a substantial difference between not born and dead.
- trgv 9y agoI don't know why you think that. I think the safest assumption is that being dead will be exactly like not being born.
- wrcwill 9y agoone state is indefinite and the other is not.
- Koshkin 9y agoIt's like saying that the future is exactly like the past. (Which is true when applied to the question of non-existence, because what did not exist will cease to exist or continue to be non-existent.)
- taeric 9y agoBut that is only true of things which do not come into existence, no? I can safely say I did not exist a thousand years ago, nor will I exist in a thousand years. Further, I can say that from my point of death on, I am non-existent. Similarly, before my birth, I was non-existent. However, my state of non-existence ended at my birth. Just as my state of existence will end at my death. In this regard, the future is not exactly like the past. In the past, there was never a time in which I came into existence. In the future, there was a time where I came into existence. Neither of those statements transfer between past and future.
- Koshkin 9y ago> In the future, there was a time This is "memory", or "trace". Their existence take away from your non-existence, making it incomplete (imperfect), which indeed makes one's future different from one's past.
- komali2 9y ago>I can safely say I did not exist a thousand years ago... I'm not sure of that, yet. We haven't managed to pin down what "I" is or even what "existence" is. I'm thinking in the "we virtualized a copy of your brain" sense - just what is consciousness?
- Koshkin 9y ago> what "existence" is Indeed, the very existence (and non-existence) could be relative - just like time and space. For example, in one frame of reference there may exist a magnetic field while in the other there may be none.
- gowld 9y agoBeing dead, like not being born, are both not being at all.
- Karolus 9y ago> I think the safest assumption is that being dead will be exactly like not being born. From a purely entropic and information theoretic standpoint, these are very different states and certainly not a safe assumption.
- Koshkin 9y agoIn this Philosophia Non Existentiae you also have to make a distinction between "not born (yet)" and "not born (ever)".
- taeric 9y agoIsn't that implicit, though? By virtue of being able to state that at some point you were not born, you were necessarily at some point born.
- Koshkin 9y agoNon-existence is complicated. In an obvious (and trivial) sense future itself does not exist, so one cannot tell whether someone in particular (e.g. another Einstein) is not born "yet" or "ever". On the other hand, one might argue that (for example) wasted sperm and eggs should count as "not born". But even that can be seen as too limiting, because - perhaps, somewhat paradoxically - to be completely objective one should be considering statistical parameters rather than a physical measure.
- taeric 9y agoFirst, I'll agree that my not existing after death would be similar to my not existing before death. In that, it helps make this a cute saying. However, that still says nothing of the difference between dying and not being born. Just because things have a large similarity does not mean they are equal, after all. Your odd argument that "wasted" sperm and such should somehow count towards "born/not born" just seems a non-sequitor. That is quite literally unrelated. The sperm/egg are merely mechanisms and say nothing of the person unless we plan on presupposing a conscious person exists before they exist.
- Koshkin 9y agoWell, clearly, non-existence after death is different from both types of non-existence mentioned above. (Incidentally, there are many more types of non-existence than just these.)
- StanislavPetrov 9y agoWhat is that difference exactly?
- taeric 9y agoDo you need it exactly, to know that it exists? What is the difference between two stars in the sky? Must you know the physical differences exactly to say they are different?
- wu-ikkyu 9y agoWhat is the "substantial difference"?
- taeric 9y agoAgain, why would I have to be explicit/exact on it? Two stars in the sky have an obvious substantial difference between their existences. Even if I couldn't readily express what those differences are. I mean, I get that these are fun discussions to have. Likely even meaningful. But the odd friction this is adding to enter the conversation seems overblown.
- wu-ikkyu 9y ago>Again, why would I have to be explicit/exact on it Did I ask you to be "explicit/exact"? I'm just curious for you to describe, at all, the supposed "substantial difference" that you apparently know of between being "not yet born" and being "dead". >Two stars in the sky have an obvious substantial difference between their existences. In what way are two stars analogous at all to being not yet born and being dead?