4 ms·
> There is no correlation between brilliance and altruism. That's not really relevant to what was being discussed above. The question isn't whether smart peopl
by danShumway 9y ago
> There is no correlation between brilliance and altruism.
That's not really relevant to what was being discussed above. The question isn't whether smart people are altruistic, it's whether there's a correlation between altruism and effectiveness. The question is whether charitable individuals are capable of building better products than profit-driven individuals.
And given that depending on who you ask anywhere from around 60-90% of modern businesses run Open Source software, it does appear that statistically (not just anecdotally) there are parts of the tech industry that are better served by non-commercial, charitable entities. If that wasn't the case, businesses would use closed source software instead.
When Heartbleed came out, nobody suggested "well, maybe we should just all switch to a proprietary for-profit solution instead of using SSL," because a good, proprietary, for-profit alternative doesn't exist and probably never will. It's just not the type of technology that Silicon Valley is good at building.
Note that this is something that seems obvious in hindsight, but it was up for debate early on in the software industry. Companies like Microsoft went so far as to compare Open Source to communism. There was a strong belief that people opening up licenses, giving away software for free, and even (the horror) requiring other licensees to give their software away for free would remove any incentive for businesses to innovate and that in the long run it would strangle new technologies.
- rayiner 9y agoMost open source development is done by for profit companies. Not through altruism, because software just happens to be an input into more profitable businsss activities. If Google licenses Android to smart phone manufacturers, maybe it gets $5-10 once every two years. But by giving it away for free and creating an Android user, Google makes that much every month.
- danShumway 9y agoThe fact that many companies incorporate Open Source into their profit models does not diminish or remove the enormous number of unpaid, volunteer hours that have gone into those projects. It's simplistic to the point of insulting to claim that the Free Software movement can be completely encapsulated by Capitalism. You have to ignore vast swaths of the history of the Internet, Linux, and the origins of Copyleft itself. You have to either ignore efforts by organizations like Mozilla or the Internet Archive, or claim that those efforts aren't important. Richard Stallman's original announcement of GNU included the following message: "I consider that the golden rule requires that if I like a program I must share it with other people who like it. I cannot in good conscience sign a nondisclosure agreement or a software license agreement. So that I can continue to use computers without violating my principles, I have decided to put together a sufficient body of free software so that I will be able to get along without any software that is not free. If I get donations of money, I may be able to hire a few people full or part time. The salary won't be high, but I'm looking for people for whom knowing they are helping humanity is as important as money." This is the environment that Linux came out of - people who decided they cared about something more than they cared about money. You don't have to be an absolutist like Stallman, but you also can't pretend that absolutists like Stallman haven't played important roles in building our modern computing world.