2 ms·
It's hard to know of course, but I'm guessing Tolkien would be turning in his grave about all the Peter Jackson movies. Personally, I can't get over the fact t
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
It's hard to know of course, but I'm guessing Tolkien would be turning in his grave about all the Peter Jackson movies.
Personally, I can't get over the fact they cut out Tom Bombadil. This was discussed before on HN and someone said Jackson had a good reason to do that, but it just rips the heart out of the whole thing. It's exactly what Tolkien was complaining about: here is a good old fairy story that has been "adapted" for the large screen by taking out everything that makes it a fairy story- the whimsical, otherworldly magic of the fair folk. What we're left with is epic battles, action ballet (I'm thinking of that scene where Legolas kills the oliphant) and just generally fantasy porn. Great sets and costumes, but there's nobody in there.
- cm2012 9y agoFellowship of the Ring is the closest to Tolkien's vision for sure, with some notable exceptions. I think he would have enjoyed seeing rivendell designed.
- ekianjo 9y agoYes, Fellowship of the Ring is the best. They were probably too afraid to stray away from the book, and because of its huge success they felt comfortable rewriting the whole story consequently. What I liked about FOTR is that even the stuff they added were pretty much consistent with the thinking behind the book - they grasped it. I can't fathom what went so wrong afterwards.