2 ms·
They already are, by the ultimate opaque system, semi-random collections of human brains. Recall all the senses of the word "judge", after all; judges certainly
by jerf 16y ago
They already are, by the ultimate opaque system, semi-random collections of human brains. Recall all the senses of the word "judge", after all; judges certainly take that into account as part of their human decisions.
This is more transparent and more subject to validation and verification. Are you sure you think this is actually a step backward?
- Someone 16y agoI did not say so, but I do think this is a road to hell, paved with good intentions. 'Minority Report' is on that road. Judges may sometimes or often be biased, but, institutionalizing that is IMO a step too far. Having said that, I think there is gray area; for example, I do not believe in the British "if it's murder, it must be life in prison", and I do think that sentences like "follow this anger management course or go to prison for three months" can be based on statistics of repeat offending.
- anigbrowl 16y agoJudges' sentencing criteria are not opaque, because they're set out in the opinion and subject to appeal. Sentencing guidelines have been a mixed bag at the federal level as far as quality of results goes, and their original mandatory nature were ruled unconstitutional by the Supreme court in 2005, largely due to sustained opposition by Justice Scalia.