3 ms·
Too bad The Lord of the Rings movie got a Disney make over with the happy ending where the Shire was never destroyed. This is so Non-Tolkienish that he must hav
by ekianjo 9y ago
Too bad The Lord of the Rings movie got a Disney make over with the happy ending where the Shire was never destroyed. This is so Non-Tolkienish that he must have turned in his grave.
- xg15 9y agoTo be fair the Shire was on the brink of destruction in the books, but in the end got saved and restored to its old glory (with some additional elven magic to boot). If you wanted to, you could read it as a fantasy of a pre-industrialized country getting threatened by industrialization but rejecting it and continuing in their old ways (allegory, ha!). So personally, I'd say the Shire plot has a happy ending in the book. I'd see Frodo's fate and the general decline of the world as a bittersweet ending, but those elements have been kept in the movies relatively unchanged.
- olavk 9y agoWell the Shire is saved in the end, isn't it? I think it is more that is a smaller scale conflict playing out after the resolution of the larger conflict which simply does not work very well on film. Maybe in a tv series, it would work. Even then the movie is weighed down by several drawn-out "endings" after the resolution of the main conflict, which was one of the major criticisms. I do think the movie captures the bitter-sweetnes of the end of the book with the elves leaving middle-earth and so on. I don't think Tolkien would have liked the movies, but then again, he is dead.
- ekianjo 9y ago> I don't think Tolkien would have liked the movies, but then again, he is dead. Then they should clearly say this is not based on the books right from the start. The first movie was still somewhat acceptable as a book adaption, but the second and third go so far away from the actual characters and events it should be called something else.
- olavk 9y agoIt would be ridiculous to claim the movies were not based on the books. Of course they had to change a lot of things, the books were not written as movie scripts. The primary responsibility of a movie director is to make a great movie.
- ekianjo 9y ago> Of course they had to change a lot of things, the books were not written as movie scripts. The primary responsibility of a movie director is to make a great movie. It's OK to make cuts from a great book in order to fit the essentials. It's NOT OK to completely change the story, like making characters go to Osgiliath for no good reason, making Gimli a constant buffoon and transfiguring every motivation from protagonists, motivations well thought about as Tolkien revised its script during 14 years of writing. And the second and third movies of the trilogy were not even great movies if you forget about the books. Dialogs half taken from the book and half-written like modern American English, general lack of consistency, and a x-parts ending that did not make at all cinematic sense and was all fan service for book lovers. Except that the Scourging of the Shire was missing. What a mess, really.
- olavk 9y agoIt seems you just don't like the movies. That is OK!
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoIt's hard to know of course, but I'm guessing Tolkien would be turning in his grave about all the Peter Jackson movies. Personally, I can't get over the fact they cut out Tom Bombadil. This was discussed before on HN and someone said Jackson had a good reason to do that, but it just rips the heart out of the whole thing. It's exactly what Tolkien was complaining about: here is a good old fairy story that has been "adapted" for the large screen by taking out everything that makes it a fairy story- the whimsical, otherworldly magic of the fair folk. What we're left with is epic battles, action ballet (I'm thinking of that scene where Legolas kills the oliphant) and just generally fantasy porn. Great sets and costumes, but there's nobody in there.
- cm2012 9y agoFellowship of the Ring is the closest to Tolkien's vision for sure, with some notable exceptions. I think he would have enjoyed seeing rivendell designed.
- ekianjo 9y agoYes, Fellowship of the Ring is the best. They were probably too afraid to stray away from the book, and because of its huge success they felt comfortable rewriting the whole story consequently. What I liked about FOTR is that even the stuff they added were pretty much consistent with the thinking behind the book - they grasped it. I can't fathom what went so wrong afterwards.