11 ms·
Rhetoric around the blockchain hints at problems with techno-utopian ideologies
- zitterbewegung 9y agoAlso, this article's title isn't as radical as they want it to be because they are conflating distributed ledger technologies with blockchain.
- mi100hael 9y agoThe biggest issue I see right now is with organizations trying to jump on the blockchain bandwagon but controlling all nodes. If control of your blockchain is centralized, it's no better than an ordinary database. The benefits come when control is decentralized because you can still trust the data hasn't been tampered with.
- fiatjaf 9y agoI don't think that has ever happened in serious cases, but for all enterprise people who ever thought about it, Plasma is the solution.
- zik 9y agoExactly. Blockchain is genuinely radical - but its primary benefit is trustless decentralisation. When a single entity controls all the nodes then you don't have decentralisation any more and you might as well just use a conventional database. The real problem here is organisations jumping on the bandwagon without really understanding what they're doing.
- st26 9y agoWhich is my biggest issue with most mainline coins, I believe they will ultimately incentivize centralization.
- quickthrower2 9y agoYou'd probably implement something "blockchain-like" in the database to get the same benefits, such as not being able to go back and delete old transactions.
- thespirit 9y agoAs someone presented with a startup that needs an "append-only" transaction database with consensus across 2-N servers (depending on scale), and an inherent incentive to exploit any potential "double-spend" issue, an internal blockchain with a single node acting as an authoritative "miner" (aka, controller) seems pretty cheap to roll out considering I can just modify existing bitcoin/blockchain software. Is there any software out there that I could readily adapt to provide the same properties and guarantees without incurring hundreds of hours of development and testing?
- jakeinspace 9y agoMaybe look into datomic
- kybernetikos 9y agoThis is the right way to look at it I think. I've been looking at a blockchain based solution recently, and there has been an awful lot of negativity, and people wondering if it would have been possible to implement the same solution with an oracle database. Well, yes, it would have been possible. There are a couple of minor things the blockchain does better and a couple of things it does worse for this use case, but fundamentally, I believe the blockchain based solution was cheaper to build and will be cheaper to maintain. People need to consider these solutions in the context of whether or not they solve business problems effectively, and put aside knee jerk reactions based on technological prejudices.
- icebraining 9y agoWhy was the blockchain cheaper to build and maintain compared to a traditional RDBMS? I agree that avoiding knee-jerk reactions is good, but I frankly have yet to see a case where it was actually the best solution, except for the case of Bitcoin and other public cryptocurrencies.
- wpietri 9y agoI keep talking to people who don't seem to understand this, and I am having a hard time giving polite responses. It's not only no better than an ordinary database, it's worse in a number of ways, including not being boring enough. [1] Even if one needs trust that there's lack of tampering, publishing a real-time transaction log is in many cases sufficient, just as long as you're willing to trust that the central point is ordering transactions fairly. Which is fine in the case where there's a legal relationship between the entities involved. [1] http://mcfunley.com/choose-boring-technology http://mcfunley.com/choose-boring-technology
- komali2 9y agoDefinitely fine where legal relationships exist, but the whole concept of law as trust is being challenged right now, as our own countries break the very laws they exist to enforce. Edit: help me understand why you disagree
- whatshisface 9y agoThen the discussion revolves back to how insane it is that the central authorities in these schemes control the nodes. Either you can trust them (in which case they should use a normal database) or you can't (in which case you can use a coin that they don't control).
- komali2 9y agoI agree, that is insane, and defeats the purpose of using block chain at all.
- whatshisface 9y agoI think the issue people are taking is that they think you are overestimating exactly how much society has declined. The ABCs have special authorizations to essentially break the law, but that practice has not yet trickled down to the local politburo. It is not quite the time to call the stability of US-style contract law in to question. (Even though the attitude behind the special authorizations, namely "I don't care what happens just do something," will be what undermines it if ever anything does.)
- bigger_cheese 9y agoThe radical organizations I'm familiar with (Socialist parties) are big on centralization the whole aim of that current of thought is the centralization of power within the state controlled by the workers ('Dictatorship of the proletariat' to use the Marxist term for it). So from that perspective I don't think a centrally controlled blockchain is a big impediment - may even be desirable.
- panarky 9y ago> If control of your blockchain is centralized, it's no better than an ordinary database Sure, when Maersk uses a private blockchain to track shipments, it's hard to see how it improves on an ordinary database. But let's say you want to build a prediction market for official corruption. The minute you start taking bets on which government officials are taking bribes, you'll have a powerful people trying to take you offline. It's extremely difficult to build a completely anonymous and decentralized application to do this, but decentralized nodes with anonymous validators that you control is a potential hybrid that's resistant to censorship.
- Scarblac 9y agoI'd be much more afraid of powerful people trying to frame non-corrupt government officials for the betting money.
- slfnflctd 9y agoAgreed, the problem with any anonymized system which attracts lots of users is, it creates incentives for bad actors to game the system. Feel free to think up all the rules you want to prevent this, but a motivated entity can always simply pay large numbers of people to act on their behalf. If they're good at it, you won't know until it's too late. Past a certain point, involving people's actual identities in the nitty gritty real world becomes increasingly necessary to establish trust. There are exceptions, but AFAICT they mostly rely on being uninteresting to would-be attackers.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- danmaz74 9y ago> If control of your blockchain is centralized, it's no better than an ordinary database Actually, it's much worse from an efficiency point of view. Which means that all those applications are fad-driven. I'm sure there can be genuinely useful applications for blockchain tech, but for now the only truly compelling one I'm aware of is to execute unlawful transactions (I don't count speculating on the price - something I've done too a bit - as genuinely useful).
- nfin 9y agobecause of the yet still lack of privacy I am not sure that right now it is most compelling for unlawful transactions. There are many use cases (like you mentioned) and most are used only by a handfull of people, but growing by the day the more stuff getting developed (lightning, ...)
- grk 9y agoI think there are usecases where you control the whole chain and have nodes within your organisation. The blockchain becomes a specialised database that's optimised to be a ledger, something like https://chain.com https://chain.com and https://chain.com/sequence/ https://chain.com/sequence/.
- ballenf 9y agoThere's no compelling argument on those pages that addresses benefits over a traditional DB. It's the same circular arguments that completely ignore the tremendous cost of implementation and added complexity. Or did I miss something?
- mi100hael 9y ago> Or did I miss something? I've found myself asking that frequently with the blockchain/cryptocurrency mania. The answer has always been no.
- mike_hearn 9y agoI agree that at first this appears to make no sense. But there are actually good reasons for it, when you dig in. I work on a DLT/blockchain platform that has customers going live like this, so I'm closer to it than most people are. This is a little like how I used to not understand why banks or other large firms cared about blockchains at all - isn't the point to get rid of them? Then it became clear that the problem of individuals trying to sync views of balances over the internet without powerful middlemen is a scaled down (or up) instance of a more general problem that lots of firms have between themselves, trying to sync data between organisations. And that this is a legitimate problem to want to solve with peer to peer technologies. The main reasons you see companies deploying "blockchain but we control all the nodes" - an apparently nonsensical setup - are twofold: 1. They do want the ability for other orgs to run nodes in their blockchain network, or rather, some of their customers want the ability to run their own nodes and rely on the centralised firm less. But many customers don't care. They prefer to trust a centralised authority, at least given the current state of technology. Therefore, firms want the ability to decentralise selectively in response to demand. 2. They're doing a tech refresh. The world is full of financial middlemen who have platforms decades old that have been incrementally patched and upgraded over time, often with lots of customers. They decide it's time to do a rebuild onto more modern tech, but they can't justify a from-scratch rewrite unless there is a significant difference that can't just be bolted on to the existing architecture. Decentralisation is an example of such a change. By betting on blockchain tech now, they open up the possibility of totally new business arrangements in future that would have been blocked by centralisation/lock-in fears today. If you decide to make your existing business app selectively decentralisable - perhaps in order to unlock new features or products in an environment where customers are concerned about data sharing - then it makes sense that you'd maintain one platform, run all the nodes yourself and migrate users to it in bulk. You've opened up new options for yourself and if later the business winds change and you don't want to allow this anymore, OK, you have a slightly more complex architecture than a plain old SQL DB but modern DLT systems like Corda (the one I work on) map blockchain data through to relational databases anyway so you can still use a lot of the same tools and processes that you're used to. It's not quite such a huge leap as it'd have once have been. Why might some customers not want to be decentralised? A situation we see a lot is where a business or industry group wants to allow people to run their own nodes, but isn't sure the usability of taking part in a P2P network is high enough for everyone (or are sure it isn't). Remember that many businesses have very small or sclerotic IT departments, or no IT department at all, and peer to peer networks are historically associated with piracy, viruses, spam etc. So that + the prevalence of the web means that setting up anything that isn't HTTP to port 80, like a business P2P node, is considered to be a bit novel and exotic. Again, because Corda is designed for large firms it has features that help with this, in particular for really large and paranoid firms like banks where the internal IT departments don't always trust each other :) But ultimately if you're trying to pull off a major platform migration, you don't want it to hit the rocks if some users reject the idea of running local infrastructure and just want an ordinary web app. This exact problem is prevalent in the Bitcoin and Ethereum communities too. Many users don't run nodes or even SPV wallets. They just dump all their coins on an exchange and trust a centralised service completely. They could go full P2P but that involves small sacrifices like having to back up your private keys, so they choose centralised trust instead. The nice thing about cryptocurrencies is users can choose their own configuration. As a consequence of all this, a popular feature request for Corda and something we're spending a lot of time thinking about is how to split a node up, so parts of a node run in some cloud somewhere, and other parts run locally on e.g. a mobile or desktop app. For instance private keys and transaction signing could be done locally, with everything else run remotely - this is "share the my data but not my authority". In more advanced setups you allow people to migrate from hosted nodes to local nodes and back again in smooth automated ways.
- Scarblac 9y agoOne point I've heard is that some large organizations don't necessarily trust themselves (or all their employees). Then a bunch of nodes with a chain inside the organization might be harder to tamper with than a database.
- icebraining 9y agoIn that case, the blockchain actually makes it easier to tamper with, since the nodes will trust whoever mines the longest chain. If you just want to avoid tampering, you're better off with servers publishing (signed) messages and clients storing those in an append-only log; a good example are the CT logs: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Certificate_Transparency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Certificate_Transparency
- aidaman 9y agoCrypto will end up being used as a tool for governments to control monetary flow. Congratulations.
- sidko 9y agoCan you explain how you see that happening?
- miscreanity 9y agoEach consensus method (Proof-of-Work, Proof-of-Stake, Directed-Acyclic-Graph, etc) has weaknesses that can be exploited by a large or influential enough entity - there are no exceptions. All it takes is time. By the time the system has reached mass adoption, we will probably come to find that there is a central entity with majority influence over it but the utility and infrastructure integration will have such momentum that changing will be effectively impossible. Fringe communities may be able to operate relatively independently, but the core will be subject to the most dystopian control and tracking system ever devised - Huxley and Orwell could not have imagined worse. That isn't to say that life won't be improved in general - there will be major positives. However, an undercurrent of entrapment will pervade even if it isn't at the forefront of attention.
- AlexCoventry 9y agoIt seems likely that Proof-of-Stake can require an economic commitment which will be extremely hard to expropriate, and can at least start out with a fairly diverse group of validators. If the chain is valuable enough, it's going to be expensive to buy up enough to pervert its consensus, and doing so will result in the stake being slashed. On the other hand, a currency which people are forced to use by law (legal tender for tax payments) will always have a huge advantage. So if governments decide to move to most transactions in the national currency taking place via cryptographically signed attestations involving government-provided keys, that will be a major move towards the kind of dystopia you're imagining.
- 9y ago
- tomglynch 9y agoA lot has happened in the space since August 2017 when this article was written. Having said that, it's still quite relevant.
- finebalance 9y agoNever understood how as a customer I can 'trust' a niche blockchain deployment considering that a majority of the computing power in that network would likely lie within the organization deploying the niche blockchain in the first place.
- amorphid 9y ago> Instead, local publicans stepped in and extended credit to their customers; the debtors were well-known to the publicans, who were in a good position to make an assessment on their credit worthiness. I didn't know what a publican was, so I googled it... pub·li·can noun. 1. (British) a person who owns or manages a pub. 2.(in ancient Roman and biblical times) a collector of taxes. I assume the author is referring the first definition.
- robk 9y agoStill widely used today (the former definition)
- thisisit 9y agoOne of the bigger problems with blockchain is that there aren't many field experts working in the space. For example if you look at a voting blockchain you will be hard pressed to find an experienced psephologist working with the team. Without experience most of the team is made of people who might have read up on the topic and thought - "Well! This can be changed via blockchain". What they don't realize is academic exhortations are vastly different from practical implementations. For example, if everyone could implement that amazing trading system from that trading book, everyone would be millionaire. But that is never true. Another good example of this is the mistaken understanding of banking and especially Visa: https://www.forbes.com/sites/francescoppola/2018/04/21/bitcoin-banks-and-a-whole-lot-of-fud/#2b2335bd21f1 https://www.forbes.com/sites/francescoppola/2018/04/21/bitco... What this means blockchain solutions either run into issues during build or work in a very specific circumstances. For example, the building block of most cryptocurrency is game theory - if someone takes over 51% then rational economical thing to do is continue the chain. But what if we have an irrational actor who doesn't care? Or what if people can manipulate the change even below 51%. A good example is the F2Pool's manipulation of Status ICO with 25% hash rate: https://themerkle.com/f2pool-allegedly-prevented-users-from-investing-in-status-ico/ https://themerkle.com/f2pool-allegedly-prevented-users-from-...
- asasidh 9y ago- getting to 51% is no easy task. - if an irrational actor can get to 51% and decide to wreck havoc, the current transactions are impacted. The community will come together to hardfork away. The last transactions preserved in the blockchain are not. - if the above happens, then the particular blockchain does not deserve the position it holds and deserves to go down. It is no longer censorship resistant.
- walterstucco 9y agoAnd that's the problem Everything is still theoretically working, but in practice they are not There are a lot of FIAT currencies out there that are based on an irrational actor controlling all the nodes and still people owning those currencies can use them for their needs, even if they suffer some loss, without having to go through an hard fork that voids the last transactions Blockchain should be about trust without trust, but their main drawback is being unreliable
- apo 9y agoBitcoin caused excitement when it proposed a technical solution to a problem that previously required a trusted intermediary—money, or, more specifically, the problem of guaranteeing and controlling money supply and monitoring the repartition of funds on a global scale. It did this by developing a distributed database that is cryptographically verified by an entire network of peers and by linking the production of new money with the individual incentive to maintain this public repository. The problem was much more narrow than this: double spending prevention by an incentivized network of peers. The basics of cryptographically secure electronic cash had been worked out long before Bitcoin came along in 2008. What was new was the idea of replacing the mint (a trusted entity through which all transactions must flow) with an open P2P network secured by monetary incentives and probabilistic settlement. With no controlling entity at the center of the system, no valid transaction can be censored. This is the new force that Bitcoin unleashed on the world: censorship-resistant electronic commerce. The fact that Bitcoin's main value proposition is censorship resistance leads many in the affluent minority to miss the point of Bitcoin entirely. They don't have a money censorship problem (at least none they care to face), and they view everyone who does as morally inferior.
- facetube 9y agoA "money censorship problem" is the funniest unintentional euphemism for money laundering I've seen in a while, congrats.
- retrogradeorbit 9y agoSo credit card companies cutting off people trying to donate their own money to wikileaks is now preventing 'money laundering'. Good one.
- facetube 9y agoWikileaks? Yeah, it actually is. Try picking an organization that didn't participate in criminal activity in 2016 and isn't holed up in an Embassy trying to evade arrest.
- badestrand 9y agoWell, the blockchain hype is easy to criticize. Tech people refer to its inefficiencies and how it is just a decentralized database. Political people point out that the real world is much more complex than what a blockchain can represent. I would argue that its strength lies in another area: It gets people excited. It makes people start thousands of new projects and companies, millions read all the news articles and a huge crowd invests a lot of money into the space. And, of course, it gets people excited because it hits a nerve. It promises a change of power structure in the world. Away from monolithic, opaque, political structures to democratic, transparent, border-less systems. Changing the role of everyone from a helpless observer to an actice participant. Obviously the build-up is messy and over-promising but it may very well change the core infrastructures of how the whole world currently operates - economically, politically and socially.
- losteric 9y agoBitcoin gets people as excited as tulip fanatics in 1636. Blockchains aren't widely exciting. There are some interesting applications, yes... but there are not millions of people following blockchains, there are not "thousands" of new projects. It's a quiet back-end evolution, not a revolution in the public-facing world.
- vkou 9y agoI thought that it gets people excited because there is a lot of dumb money to be made in it, regardless of whether or not your work will result in any added value to the world.
- iforgotemailpwd 9y agoExactly. If it was something conventional it would not get the attention of a full blog post saying why it is bad or the general mob-hatred at HN.
- IkmoIkmo 9y agoThe ratio of people who's nerves are hit because crypto can change the power structure, to those who're interested in it because it has the potential to turn a young person's $10k creditcard borrowings into $1m, is probably pretty close to 1:100. I mean, name the 10 biggest use cases. Bitcoin is 10 years old, it is a household name, it's been in every newspaper, every developer in the world has heard of it, it captured orders of magnitude more angel and venture investment than say a google or facebook did. It should have some genuine users who are using it not because it's a volatile asset class with an average annual return of >10x. It's virtually impossible to find any usergroup of significance anymore. Outside of course the asset class, which so far hasn't changed the power structure so much as it has made a few techies and rich people (paper) rich.
- EGreg 9y ago“There’s zero evidence that features such as decentralization or structurelessness pose any kind of threat to capitalism.” Disagree. Desktop publishing disrupted the idea of Copyright as Intellectual Property. The Internet obliterated it. Open Source is a superior alternative to Capitalism. People cooperate on a project instead of capitalist organizations competing and trying to extract rents. In both cases, quality goes up but in the open source case, costs stay near zero the whole time. Once again this became possible because of information dissemination. When Newton said he stood on the shoulders of giants, those giants didn’t charge rent! Next will be open source drugs. I would like to see a new system emerge. One where people GIVE AWAY their inventions because if they don’t, someone else will beat them to it, and control for a time the direction. In this world, people are more free and Basic Income lets them choose what to do with their lives. Robots do more and more work while people contribute here and there to a growing snowball. It is the world of OpenAI, Wikipedia, WikiNews and citizens uploading videos etc. and not this lamenting about how the newspaper industry will make money. The alternatives to Capitalism aren’t “socialism” only. They are Collaboration. Science! Open source! A society may be “free” by anarcho capitalist standards but each individual person may fear losing their paycheck. This is not sustainable in the face of technological unemployment. What kind of freedom is it that you are coerced by the system into committing to working on things you don’t like in a constant state of food insecurity and pne month away from homelessness? This is the situation for millions of people. It doesn’t have to be like that. We have enough resources to feed and house everyone ten times over.
- olavk 9y agoAll the big open source projects are financed by capitalist businesses which support OS strategically to "commoditize the complement". This is just capitalism working. The software may be free to the user, but they still have a cost to develop.
- miles 9y agoJames Hogan describes a similar vision in Voyage from Yesteryear: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/849484.Voyage_from_Yesteryear https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/849484.Voyage_from_Yeste... .
- 9y ago
- grosjona 9y agoThe markets that cryptocurrencies are potentially going to replace include NASDAQ, NYSE, LSE, TSE and all the other national centralized stock exchanges. Cryptocurrencies are a superior way to represent stocks, especially software company stocks where the service can be tightly coupled to the currency itself. There are multiple reasons why cryptocurrencies are better at representing company ownership shares: - There is no need to trust a middleman or government to maintain your holdings. There is no room for bad actors. - Transparency regarding who owns what (assuming that the ledger is public). - It can never go bankrupt unless all users of the network abandon it - But they all have a strong financial incentive to keep it running. - It doesn't need government regulation to function properly; in fact, it transcends government boundaries. Loose government regulation makes it extremely liquid. Imagine if you could buy your lunch using company stocks directly instead of cash.
- pjc50 9y agoI find it hard to see why people would go for a system where the transaction times are comparatively huge - you can't HFT on the blockchain, for example. And it's revealing that the cryptocurrency infrastructure has basically replicated the exchange system, complete with central counterparties and broker-dealers. > Imagine if you could buy your lunch using company stocks directly instead of cash. This sounds like an excellent way to complicate your tax return.
- zerostar07 9y ago> Fostering and scaling cooperation is really difficult. It all depends on incentive. BitTorrent was so popular that it had to be outlawed and heavily persecuted > It doesn’t stand in for all the slow and messy bureaucracy and debate and human processes that go into building cooperation, and it never will. Blockchains didn't want to go there anyway. But they replace the implied trust in statespersons that lies behind any bureaucracy with machines. thats quite radical, even if you layer a huge trust-based bureaucracy on top of that. > there is no linear-causal relationship between decentralization in technical systems and egalitarian or equitable practices socially There is a causal relationship between centralization of the internet and monopolies/inequality and everything that people hate
- arisAlexis 9y agoI have a problem with biased titles such as "X isn't as you want it to be" or "No, X is not Y". This makes the whole article biased and me more biased about reading it. Any valid points inside are clearly from the perspective of the writer having formed a very concrete opinion over the subject and trying to convince you. The title is like "either you are with us or against us" and trying to either make me relate to the people that are disillusioned (so offending me) or unite me against "them".
- thedancollins 9y agoGreat article derailed by the final paragraph. So, the author is disappointed that we want to ignore differences rather than focus on them. Inefficient and unnecessary. I find the author's point about blockchain trying to replace politics with economics to be something worthy of more study and thought.