3 ms·
This argument always strikes me as kind of odd. As far as I can tell, it boils down to "other countries like Canada are better negotiators than us, and our comp
by danShumway 9y ago
This argument always strikes me as kind of odd. As far as I can tell, it boils down to "other countries like Canada are better negotiators than us, and our companies give them better prices."
But if that's the case, it just seems like really good evidence that squeezing drug companies and making aggressive demands drives down drug costs and encourages them to move R&D costs out of the country. Why wouldn't the US be all over that?
I dunno, I just always feel like I'm missing something when I see this. Other countries have better health care than us, but we can't use their tactics, even though they seem to be working really well, because... we're nice, and we don't want their drugs to cost more?
If we accept that having R&D based out of the US is a bad thing, then why are we fighting to keep it here? Shouldn't we increase regulation until all the pharmaceuticals move to Canada?
- dasil003 9y agoI think the argument is that the drugs would simply not be developed at all. Personally I'm inclined to call the bluff as it's not clear that the profit motive has led to the most effective drug development—there's a huge sales culture in pharmaceuticals that incentivizes prescription drugs beyond the balance that doctors and patients would naturally arrive at.
- SilasX 9y agoWhat if you framed it in terms of the damage Walmart (arguably) does to markets? I mean, they force suppliers to take losses “because of their negotiating power”, right? So maybe every retailer should band together with them and force all supplier profit margins to the same bare minimum for all products. Otherwise you’re leaving money “on the table”, right?
- d0lph 9y agoWouldn't this cause the US to just end up subsidizing medicines for other countries?