10 ms·
> the last numbers I saw, 2015, showed marketing budgets for medicine to be often times twice what was being spent on R&D in the US. The marketing expense isn'
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> the last numbers I saw, 2015, showed marketing budgets for medicine to be often times twice what was being spent on R&D in the US.
The marketing expense isn't necessarily avoidable.
Suppose it costs $50M to research a drug and patients will pay $1000 for a course of treatment. If you do no marketing then you get forty thousand customers and can't recover your R&D. If you spend $100M on marketing then you get two hundred thousand customers and more than recover both your R&D and your marketing expense.
Spending more on marketing can allow them to do R&D they otherwise couldn't by providing more customers to spread the R&D costs over.
- peterashford 9y ago...except, at least in NZ where they do some of that marketing, the drugs are purchased via the state body Pharmac, which will not pay the inflated prices that the drug companies charge in the US.
- disordinary 9y agoThe reason for the advertising in NZ is that Pharmac will often fully fund generics, if you want to buy the brand name drug you have to pay extra on top. For instance, I just got a new prescription for inhalers, the pharmacy told me if I wanted ventolin it would be $5 but the generic was fully subsidised.
- peterashford 9y agosure, my point (which I probably was not very clear about) was more that the cost of marketing in NZ still isn't going to ratchet up profitability to the level of the US with their higher prices
- disordinary 9y agoSurely though the best marketing is the effectiveness of the product, if it's a good product then doctors will prescribe it. I don't know if it's true or not, but looking at US movies/tv shows it seems like everyones taking medication which I doubt they actually need. Here I don't know very many people who actively take regular medication, I know that people who move here complain at how doctors are stingy with prescriptions, yet life expectancy is longer than the US.
- refurb 9y agoSurely though the best marketing is the effectiveness of the product, if it's a good product then doctors will prescribe it. That's true for very few physicians. The ones that are leaders in their field and do research know the ins and outs of new drugs, but your average doctor knows very little.
- disordinary 9y agoBut, they all have access to knowledge bases and information and guidelines provided by the government.
- refurb 9y agoThat is true, but setting aside time to do research is a much bigger hurdle than taking 10-15 min to listen to someone give you the highlights. And in case anyone was wondering, doctors are very skeptical of drug reps and always verify anything they say before believing it. But it gives them a starting point.
- stinkbug 9y ago"always verify". Well that's obviously not a true statement but (not singling you out) I wonder why there is such a compulsion to defend the honor, as it were, of medical doctors. It's not exactly the same as pharma, but in the medical device field salespeople are commonly in operating theatres. Clearly the surgeons doing this do not have time to "verify" what they are being told. https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/why-is-that-salesperson-in-the-operating-room-for-your-knee-replacement/2016/11/14/ab8172fa-78e6-11e6-beac-57a4a412e93a_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/why-i... Americans would do well to stop idolizing doctors and realize that huge numbers of them are lazy, incompetent shills who routinely do a lot of preventable damage.
- AnthonyMouse 9y ago> Surely though the best marketing is the effectiveness of the product, if it's a good product then doctors will prescribe it. Let's take this from the other side. Suppose we prohibit the marketing. Now you have to amortize $50M in R&D over 40,000 patients instead of 200,000. So a course of treatment can't cost $1000, it has to be more than that. Cutting out the marketing expense makes the price per patient go up.