2 ms·
There are a lot of problems blockchain technology solves. And I would disagree. Personal computers were thought of as mostly useless hobbyist technology until y
by chrisco255 9y ago
There are a lot of problems blockchain technology solves. And I would disagree. Personal computers were thought of as mostly useless hobbyist technology until years later when spreadsheets were introduced. Even then, home computers didn't exactly go mainstream until the 90s, when the internet began to take off and OS technology matured (Win 95). Cell phones suffered a similar skepticism up until the networks and pricing models matured in the late 90s. And no one needed text messaging when that first came out. You also couldn't convince most people that a data plan was worth it on the mostly useless browsers of the time.
- nickpsecurity 9y ago" Personal computers were thought of as mostly useless hobbyist technology until years later when spreadsheets were introduced." "Cell phones suffered a similar skepticism" The people that invented them could tell you what you might be able to do with them and you'd find that way better than your current situation. Whereas, the design of these cryptocurrencies are worse than our current situation in a lot of ways. The problems they allegedly solve appear to be fixable with better forms of existing technology, law, etc that's used in centralized systems. The people pushing cryptocurrencies never even try to do that. They're ideologically against it rather than looking for whatever solutions are most practical. So, the potential usefulness of the desktop vs the terminals connecting to shared mainframes/minicomputers or mobile phones vs fixed-location phones is nothing like banks, cards, Venmo, and contracts vs Bitcoin or Ethereum. Actually, the current system works so well at what it does that most people are happy with it. The gripes they have are usually on policies, fees, etc that a non-profit, centralized, customer-focused organization can solve. A series of them cooperating via a standard protocol (i.e. better SWIFT) across jurisdictions and currencies can reduce those risks, too. There's nothing about the problems of current system that makes most people think: let's ditch existing currencies, databases, and accounting practices for decentralized, blockchain-based, crypto algorithms. A solution in search of a problem is an apt phrase.
- canoebuilder 9y agoCell phones aren't the best example for you. As soon as economic and technical hurdles were cleared, cell phones became one of, if the most, rapidly and widely adopted technologies ever. Cell phones also provided something genuinely novel and useful for those who adopted them, in a package that was familiar and easy to use. Bitcoin, by comparison, okay I can pay for some things, well I could already do that. I have to adopt hard to understand security measures and my every action with my 'money' is fraught with peril if I'm not exceedingly careful. Well, that's new, but it's not something that appeals to most people.
- chrisco255 9y agoCell phones are a great example. They had absolutely dismal coverage in the early days and your bill would be hundreds if not thousands of dollars if you happened to roam in the wrong county. No one questions them today, but to many folks, they were a hard sell in the early days. Most folks thought they'd use a cell phone for emergencies only. I don't know how you can look at distributed blockchain technology and not see something genuinely novel there. A set of algorithms and code are capable of replacing the functions of a bank (and then some). That is, you can store, transfer, and program the behavior of money around the world without any third party telling you can or can't. Besides being open source money and all the awesome implications of that, crypto currencies are programmable. You can control the timing and flow of crypto according to scriptable logic. Please explain how you'd write a smart contract that escrows money and disburses according to preconfigured rules using USD. What would you have to do to achieve that with code, today?