2 ms·
Without reading the article, but as someone who has a condition where lots of clinical trials are done, I will offer this opionion: Clinical trials can be pret
by Mz 16y ago
Without reading the article, but as someone who has a condition where lots of clinical trials are done, I will offer this opionion:
Clinical trials can be pretty idiotic because a) they don't control for enough factors and b) the act of qualifying for the trial can confound the results, something that seems to be completely ignored.
On a cystic fibrosis forum I belong to, one member wanted to participate in a clinical trial. A precondition was that she not be on a particular drug that she was on. So she goes to the forum and asks for non-drug alternatives so she can get off this drug and qualify for the study. If she does better during the study: Is it because of the drug being studied? Is it because she stopped taking this other drug to qualify for the study? Is it because of the non-drug alternatives she began using as a substitute? Is it two or more of those reasons and how much of the change can be attributed to each factor?
If she qualified, I seriously doubt the people making the study would ask any of the above questions. If they did, I have no clue how you could determine meaningful answers. It looks like junk data to me.
- bigfudge 16y ago>he act of qualifying for the trial can confound the results The example you give doesn't confound the result of the trial (provided it's properly randomised) but it does make it hard to generalise the result to the general population. What you describe is actually common — antidepressant trials typically exclude people with comorbid medical or psychological conditions, despite the fact that the rate of comorbitity in depression runs at >60%.