6 ms·
The spectacular power of Big Lens
- bagrow 9y agoAny chance of 3D-printing lenses? Frames seem easy, but being able to automate lens creation may be able to bypass these big monopolies. Whatever happened to these water-filled lenses? https://gizmodo.com/5116969/eyeglasses-with-fluid-filled-sac-for-worlds-poor-are-instantly-adjustable https://gizmodo.com/5116969/eyeglasses-with-fluid-filled-sac... (2008)
- roywiggins 9y agoIt seems to me that approximately everyone on the planet sees mass media with people wearing ordinary glasses and will want to wear those instead of bulky silicone-filled lenses, even if it costs more. We're already willing to pay hundreds of dollars on name-brand frames- it's not because you can't find cheaper ones.
- inferiorhuman 9y agoThe article was talking about folks who are far too poor to afford a few hundred dollars to drop on glasses.
- roywiggins 9y agoI mean, people who can afford basic frames pay more for nicer ones. Quite poor people, if they get the chance, will probably pay for very-cheap real glasses even if there are even-cheaper silicone ones available. For people with no other choices, I can see the silicone ones being useful! But "hey, take these glasses we made for poor people" is not a great sales pitch.
- 21 9y agoThe article also says a cheap pair of glasses is $5.
- dharmab 9y agoYou can get perfectly fine, durable, non-dorky plastic frames for $10.
- Luc 9y agoIt's already being done, using very interesting technology. The printers are attached to multi-ton blocks of granite (IIRC) to counter vibrations. They're used to print out uncommon spectacle glasses. Several in use in North America. https://www.luxexcel.com/ophthalmic-technology https://www.luxexcel.com/ophthalmic-technology
- gaius 9y agoAny chance of 3D-printing lenses? Yes, it's called "grinding", it's how all lenses used to be made. For like, 500 years. Next up: can we make lenses on the blockchain?
- wlesieutre 9y agoSubtractive manufacturing is not the same as additive manufacturing. Formlabs has demoed a 3d printed camera lens, but it's a far cry from the optical quality of eyeglasses. https://formlabs.com/blog/creating-camera-lenses-with-stereolithography/ https://formlabs.com/blog/creating-camera-lenses-with-stereo...
- mmagin 9y agoI suspect a lot of the polymer lenses are cast to a rough shape and then ground/polished a relatively small amount to reach the final dimension.
- bagrow 9y agoWho does the grinding? How many people in third world countries have access to trained and equipped lensmakers? I’m sad about all your hate. I thought posters to HN were more insightful that this.
- crystaln 9y agoThere are so many cheap online manufacturers. I feel like this is more the last gasp of an overpriced overserviced industry, like if there was a consolidation of travel agents in 2003.
- chasil 9y agoThe two that I know of are: http://zennioptical.com http://zennioptical.com (which I've used for years) https://www.glassesshop.com/ https://www.glassesshop.com/ (which I learned of recently)
- epmaybe 9y agoIf we're sharing websites to obtain glasses, eyebuydirect has been my go to for the last few years. Warby Parker, while significantly more expensive, does have pretty high quality frames with flat rates on lenses.
- walterbell 9y agoIf your prescription is less than -5.00, Eyebuydirect provides free aspheric CR-39 lenses, which will be higher optical quality (especially for computer use - less chromatic aberration) than the polycarb lenses used by Warby Parker.
- ink_13 9y agoUnfortunately, for people with even moderately complicated prescriptions (e.g., even mild astigmatism), there's no substitute for in-person fitting, as the lens centre must be precisely located.
- dharmab 9y agoYou just have to measure your interpupillary distance with an accurate ruler. It's very easy with either a mirror or a friend's help.
- 9y ago
- gumby 9y agoThe mechanics of lens and frames aren’t yet within the reach of 3D printing, unfortunately. The current system is absurd and unsustainable. These guys look interesting (met them at a conference; haven’t tried the product though): they use your phone to scan your face, show you what various frames will look like on your face _as you move it_, make custom frames and lenses on demand, and ship them to you. https://www.topologyeyewear.com https://www.topologyeyewear.com The app seems to work pretty well, but as I said I haven’t tried the real product.
- rurban 9y agoBut the technical best frames are still made in Austria, Silhouette. Light and frameless titan, unbreakable. The Italians or Fielmann haven't figured out that yet.
- wsy 9y agoEschenbach Titanflex is similar, technology-wise.
- rurban 9y agoNope, that's one you can get in Germany or from this Italian cartel. Silhouette is frameless.
- walterbell 9y agoFrom Germany, IC Berlin and (spinoff) Mykita have well-engineered screwless metal frames. Modo (NY) has some lightweight frames made in Japan, including a screwless line, for 50% less. Eyebuydirect (owned by EssilorLuxottica) has a lightweight metal frame with grooved lens mounting, for 95% less.
- no_identd 9y agoAnd the aesthetically best frames are also still made in Austria - http://schau-schau.at/en/ http://schau-schau.at/en/
- rurban 9y agoOnly if you like Bulgarian style intellectuals. I heard this is modern in Vienna right now. I was talking about invisible frames and invisible glasses, as light as possible.
- ScottBurson 9y agoSlightly OT, but I can't resist mentioning a blog post of mine: http://scottlburson2.blogspot.com/2016/01/lcd-backlights-and-eyeglass-lenses.html http://scottlburson2.blogspot.com/2016/01/lcd-backlights-and... Anyone with a correction of more than 3 or 4 diopters in either direction, who uses a wide-gamut monitor, might want to take note of this. This includes anyone with a 2016 or newer MacBook Pro.
- no_identd 9y agoAssuming you have Anisometropia (difference in prescription strength between the two eyes), this is only half the deal. You'll additionally want so called /Iseikonic/ glasses, which equalize the magnification/minification between the two lenses, AND THUS also equalize the angles of prismatic diversion induced outside the center of vision by glasses. This SIGNIFICANTLY reduces eye strain.
- andperseand 9y agoBeing married to an optometrist and privy to some of the numbers of the business, I'm always a bit annoyed reading these articles. Yes, the margins on frames are high. Are the overall profits of the business high? Not particularly. The staffing costs are essentially subsidised by the products they sell. If you put 'reasonable' markups on the frames, then you have to make the costs of the eye tests a lot higher to pay for the time of your expensive staff and then fewer people are willing to get tested and their problems go unnoticed. Sometimes they are serious enough to be life-threatening or to cause total loss of vision. Your GP is not going to notice a bulging optic disc for example. So while I appreciate the consumer sentiment of 'This looks like I'm being ripped off', I think the current pricing model is actually in the best interest of public health. Even SpecSavers model of 30min appointments is a bit suspect really.
- walterbell 9y agoWhen you go to LensCrafters (owned by Luxottica), the doctor is not always employed by LensCrafters, they can be an independent. The price of eye exams is also influenced by the insurance industry.
- jschwartzi 9y agoYeah, if you consider the actual cost of visits, the end product has to subsidize the entire business. It took 3 visits for me to get contacts. The contacts were about $200 for a year's supply, and each visit was about $60.00. Each of the people involved has to make a part of that as their pay, and on top of that they have to rent an office, maintain stock, lease equipment, etc.. All to sell me some squishy bits of hydrogel for less than what a cell phone costs. I'm really surprised if they broke even on me.
- jpatokal 9y agoBut why did it take you three visits to get contacts? It's also interesting that hard (RGP) contacts, which last essentially forever, are now virtually impossible to buy from high-street opticians. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rigid_gas_permeable_lens https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rigid_gas_permeable_lens
- com2kid 9y agoBuying non-Luxottica frames is pretty easy. Go to any smaller eye glass shop and odds are they will have independently made frames, sometimes even locally made. As for cheap lens, you get what you pay for. Improvements in lens materials, such as Trivex, have made life quantifiable better, and lens coatings get better and better all the time. Anyone else remember the first generation of transition lens? Compared to today's coating, is a world of difference. But in regards to being accessible, head down to Costco (no membership card needed) and pick up a pair of quality polycarb lens. I also find it difficult to believe that England only has 4 frame makers, when I am pretty sure there are more than that in the Pacific Northwest alone!
- no_identd 9y ago1. That's a terrible pun in the article title that some Americans might miss 2. And here I had hoped this article might go into the details of the HORRENDOUS patent lockdown between Zeiss, Rodenstock, Hoya, Essilor, Shaw Lens, and numerous other vendors, who OF COURSE all refuse to license to each other which essentially forces consumers to use lenses built with a hodgepodge between completely outdated technology and cutting edge technology. Imagine running your modern GPU with an 486 as a CPU - or vice versa.