5 ms·
I'm not really qualified to comment on programmers per se. But I am reminded of a personal anecdote: In my mid-twenties, I had to have minor surgery on my fac
by Mz 16y ago
I'm not really qualified to comment on programmers per se. But I am reminded of a personal anecdote:
In my mid-twenties, I had to have minor surgery on my face. My looks were very important to me. I thought I was quite beautiful and this was upsetting to me. I was concerned I would be disfigured but I really had to have the surgery. Trying to make my peace with it, I commented "I guess I can always have cosmetic surgery later." The surgeon was quite affronted and said "You won't need cosmetic surgery when I am done." The scar is nearly invisible -- less visible than the cyst that was removed. Even people who knew me before the surgery and know I had my face cut on have difficulty finding the scar.
I concluded that if you can bring it, maybe you aren't actually arrogant. Maybe you are just stating the facts, regardless of how it might sound to other people.
- bedris 16y ago"If you done it, it ain’t bragging." -Walt Whitman
- gruseom 16y agoNo way did Whitman say that.
- itg 16y agoYou can state the same thing different ways depending on the words you use, tone of voice, etc. Just because you are brilliant in one field doesn't give you a pass to look down on everyone else.
- Mz 16y agoJust because you are brilliant in one field doesn't give you a pass to look down on everyone else. And just because you are brilliant at something in particular does not mean you also have equally brilliant diplomatic skills so as to be able to state the fact (that you are exceptionally competent at X) without sounding arrogant. I try to cut people some slack in that regard.
- tomjen3 16y agoI didn't read it as putting him down at all. This wasn't a competition between the patient and the surgeon about whose medical skills where the best, but about the surgeons skills against the reality of the cyst.
- Mz 16y agoI didn't think (s)he was calling me brilliant but unpolished. ;-) I took it as more of a general observation, which I agree with but I don't think it makes for some of kind of rebuttal to my conclusion, which basically amounts to: If you really are extremely good at something, asserting that you are that good is likely to sound arrogant to other people even if it is simply factual. I try to keep stuff like that in mind and not jump to conclusions about the size of a person's ego based on limited data. Other people seem to generally be very willing to jump to such conclusions on very limited data. I offer the anecdote to suggest that, if programmers are generally competent and intelligent, it won't much matter how humbly they present themselves. Their competence will rub plenty of people the wrong way, no matter how many sets of velvet gloves they have for all social occasions.
- j_baker 16y agoI agree with this. A lot of people probably consider me arrogant and stubborn. Honestly, I don't care though. Arrogance and stubborn are only flaws when you're wrong. On the other hand, being arrogant and stubborn about the truth is a virtue in my opinion.
- thaumaturgy 16y ago...depending on the presentation.
- j_baker 16y ago"If you're out to describe the truth, leave elegance to the tailor." -Albert Einstein A poorly-presented correct idea is still correct. A well-presented incorrect idea is still incorrect.
- omaranto 16y agoBeing stubborn about the truth sounds reasonable, but why is being arrogant about it a virtue?
- petercooper 16y agoI heard a line in a comedy the other night: "I never compromise. Because if you compromise, you're admitting you aren't right." On the other hand, being arrogant and stubborn about the truth is a virtue in my opinion. I take it you're not married. And if you are, please write a book about this policy and its effects if you use it frequently ;-) Also, an issue about being stubborn about the truth is that there can be as many versions of the "truth" as there are actors in the situation. Typically people don't deliberately argue positions they think are untrue. See crime witnesses or religious people for powerful examples.
- j_baker 16y agoWell, I'm about as married as any gay male can be. And my boyfriend has learned to put up with it. "Also, an issue about being stubborn about the truth is that there can be as many versions of the "truth" as there are actors in the situation." I'd strongly disagree. Different people may have different pieces of the truth (ie the truth could be "Either person x's approach or person y's approach will work"), they might have different perspectives on the truth (ie the truth could be "person x is right about a, b, c, and d but not e while person y is right about e, f, g, and h but not i"), or they might be arguing about a subject where there is no real truth (see religious people for powerful examples). But where the truth exists it is singular. When presented with conflicting ideas, the goal is to determine if one is correct or they both are correct. Throwing your hands in the air and saying "The truth is subjective" is a cop-out.
- dtf 16y agoArrogance born out of genius is more than tolerable. But arrogance born out of mediocrity, ignorance or insecurity is a more common and toxic blend.
- Mz 16y agoTwo thoughts: 1) Maybe you missed the "maybes" in my closing remarks. 2) Being exceptionally competent puts one in a social trap. It is generally not acceptable to state that you are that good. It is also not acceptable to lie, and downplaying your competence is a form of deception (aka "lying"). So if you are that good, there is no good answer when the topic comes up. I will also take this opportunity to note that the surgeon did not come across as arrogant until I inadvertently questioned his professional competence by trying to verbally reassure myself. And, in fact, his reaction was extremely reassuring to me. I went ahead with the surgery with much relief and trust in his ability, something I don't think I would have felt if he had instead tried to nicely address my emotional concerns about the whole thing.
- dtf 16y agoI hadn't missed your maybes. You're pondering the subtleties of this argument far more intelligently than my blunt comment does. But perhaps that's because you've had time to mature and reflect on your brush with arrogance, while I am still reeling from a recent encounter ;-)
- Mz 16y agoOh, actual asinine behavior is not anything I have any fondness for. I hope your social road rash heals up quickly.