4 ms·
That's a good question, I don't know if it's valid to offer discounts and such in exchange for consent. It goes against the EU principles ("personal information
by icebraining 9y ago
That's a good question, I don't know if it's valid to offer discounts and such in exchange for consent. It goes against the EU principles ("personal information cannot be conceived as a mere economic asset"), but I'm not sure if the law actually prevents it.
- zerostar07 9y ago> personal information cannot be conceived as a mere economic asset I wonder why not? Personal information is useless for most people, they give it away for free to the state institutions and the police wont even ask your consent. Some websites and services have found a way to make money off it, in exchange for free services etc. Why is this an ethically unacceptable proposition?
- TeMPOraL 9y agoBecause it ends up abused by marketers, and frequently ends up facilitating crime as well. GDPR as a law came out directly from the last decade of mass surveillance economy.
- zerostar07 9y agoSo what? It was part of the agreement when you consented. The same way that when you go to a club, a strip club, or a casino you know you 'll be exploited in a way. Sounds like advocating for overreaching laws that "save you from yourself" and keep you away from harm / drugs etc. It's a bit ironic that you brought up mass surveillance because GDPR explicitly exempts the police and security services from its reach. Edit (i can't post a reply): - consent should always be required, but if you don't consent i shouldn't be legally required to service you. GDPR is more than just consent hence the overreach - The NSA has more data than any single actor on the internet, we can't possibly claim that private surveillance is worse. The NSA may have a better profile of me than any private actor even though (and especially because) i m not american. And their profiling can harm something that businesses generally don't care to harm: my freedom
- TeMPOraL 9y ago> It was part of the agreement when you consented I didn't consent to shit. GDPR is the response to rampant abuse of personal data without obtaining proper consent. You're still allowed to use my data if I consent, you only have to obtain an actual, informed consent. > The same way that when you go to a club, a strip club, or a casino you know you 'll be exploited. What kind of clubs are you visiting? :o. Are you sure they're legal? > It's a bit ironic that you brought up mass surveillance because GDPR explicitly exempts the police and security services from its reach. It isn't, because adtech surveillance dwarfs government surveillance. Also, the police and security services are doing something valuable for me, even though they do it imperfectly. Advertising industry exists only to fuck me over. It's a cancer on society.
- distances 9y ago> It was part of the agreement when you consented. That's a big point in GDPR, I think -- there never was consent. It's the same as why terms and conditions aren't legally binding: nobody actually considers there to be a valid agreement when they click next. In a sense GDPR is just enforcement of people's expectations, and ending predatory practices that were misusing them.
- chrononaut 9y agoLegitimate question; if you're not American, why do you think the NSA would be impacting your individual freedom, or perhaps the freedom made available by the state(s) of your citizenship(s)? Or were you more referencing that it is violating your privacy?
- zerostar07 9y agothere is international law which allows the US to affect me and my freedom even in my home country. It would be up to the local courts to decide. And of course when i visit the US, as well as my freedom to do business with US companies. Also, in this case the tracking is both without my consent , and without the protections that american law provides to americans.
- kalleboo 9y ago
- PeterisP 9y agoOne of the criteria for freely given consent is that the customer must be able to revoke it at any time without detriment. If revoking consent causes a detriment, then it's not freely given, and so that "consent" isn't sufficient to grant the data controller a legal permission to use that data. Quoting recital 42 from https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-42/ https://gdpr-info.eu/recitals/no-42/ "[...] Consent should not be regarded as freely given if the data subject has no genuine or free choice or is unable to refuse or withdraw consent without detriment.", so it's quite explicit.
- zaarn 9y agoI think a minor discount would probably fly (under 15% or so) or atleast defendable to the regulatory bodies. Bigger discounts would be a problem since that would be more of a detriment.
- icebraining 9y agoThanks, I missed that recital. It's confusing that the phrase you cited isn't in recital 43.