3 ms·
> The author of a creative work doesn't have the right to force me to delete something from my laptop if I obtained it lawfully. A valid point - the rights onl
by alkonaut 9y ago
> The author of a creative work doesn't have the right to force me to delete something from my laptop if I obtained it lawfully.
A valid point - the rights only address the USE of the photos. You can use them privately all you want and would not have to delete them (unless ordered by a court for whatever odd legal reason such as if they were stolen not uploaded).
The difference with personal info is that the lawmakers saw two choices: prevent the use or the keeping of the data. They chose to outlaw the keeping of the data - which is why this law is huge, invasive and clumsy. But it’s also the only reason it makes a difference at all imho. I don’t trust anyone to keep the personal data of millions of people safe.
- FooBarWidget 9y ago> They chose to outlaw the keeping of the data Which is not true. Under the GDPR, you are not allowed to "process" any data unless you have a legal ground for doing it. One such legal ground is consent, but it can be withdrawn and so at that point you need to "stop processing". The thing is, "processing" is a broad term and includes not just storage but basically anything that happens to the data. So even use is not allowed.
- PeterisP 9y agoGDPR is focused a lot on regulating the use of the data. In particular, one of the key aspects is the limitation of processing to a particular use - very often business will have a reasonable GDPR-approved reason to get and have the data, but (since this was often used to circumvent earlier privacy legislation) now they'll be limited to using that data only for that reason. For example, if I order pizza, the business (obviously) needs to have my delivery address; however, that obvious reason only applies for the actual delivery, and if they want to use that same address also for, say, direct marketing, then that's a separate use that's not covered and would (generally) need additional opt-in consent.