6 ms·
I don't see how self-hosting has anything to do with it honestly. This is about tracking people without their consent. It's about preserving rights of individ
by mulmen 9y ago
I don't see how self-hosting has anything to do with it honestly. This is about tracking people without their consent. It's about preserving rights of individuals. Self hosting is no more or less acceptable than third party hosting. It's not a technical issue.
- jimktrains2 9y agoAre you also against access logs?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoOnly if you’re not scrubbing IP addresses and other PII within a reasonable window of time.
- jimktrains2 9y agoIP addresses are not pii. (Maybe personal data under the gdpr, but they are not pii.) Also, what pii is tracked (by default) by piwiki or ga or access logs? I certainly cannot think of anything.
- toomuchtodo 9y ago> Also, what pii is tracked (by default) by piwiki or ga or access logs? I certainly cannot think of anything. Cookies and other artifacts in the request headers or query parameters that can identify a unique user.
- jimktrains2 9y agoIdentify a unique user does not mean that it's pii if I cannot produce the real world identity of the user from the cookie.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoTrue! But some cookies are usually tied to a user account, with an email address, and/or other PII. How careful are you with tacking cookies to requests? Be mindful, and keep documentation.
- zaarn 9y agoUnder the GDPR that's PII. IP Addresses too. Personal Data is any data relating to a natural person, if you can uniquely identify them that falls under the monitoring/profiling definition of the regulation.
- TheForumTroll 9y ago"A much discussed topic is the IP address. The GDPR states that IP addresses should be considered personal data as it enters the scope of ‘online identifiers’. Of course, in the case of a dynamic IP address – which is changed every time a person connects to a network – there has been some legitimate debate going on as to whether it can truly lead to the identification of a person or not. The conclusion is that the GDPR does consider it as such. The logic behind this decision is relatively simple. The internet service provider (ISP) has a record of the temporary dynamic IP address and knows to whom it has been assigned. A website provider has a record of the web pages accessed by a dynamic IP address (but no other data that would lead to the identification of the person). If the two pieces information would be combined, the website provider could find the identity of the person behind a certain dynamic IP address. However, the chances of this happening are small, as the ISP has to meet certain legal obligations before it can hand the data to a website provider. The conclusion is, all IP addresses should be treated as personal data, in order to be GDPR compliant." https://eugdprcompliant.com/personal-data/ https://eugdprcompliant.com/personal-data/ PII or not PII it is still covered by GDPR.
- dbbk 9y agoSo is your position that website owners should have no visiblity at all on their visitors, and no way of knowing how many people are using it?
- enraged_camel 9y agoWebsite owners can have visibility on their visitors if those visitors explicitly consent to it. Not sure what is so difficult to understand about this.
- jamiequint 9y agoSo if I don't think that Walmart should be able to record me with security cameras while I'm in the store I should have the right to demand that they ask me to sign a waiver before entering the store? Shouldn't it be Walmart's right to do what they want on their property, and my right to decide not to visit Walmart if I don't agree with that. Isn't the converse an infringement of Walmart's rights?
- enraged_camel 9y agoI'm not 100% sure, but I believe the cameras at Walmart are for security only. I don't believe Walmart is using facial-recognition technology to identify visitors, track their behaviors (which aisles they visit, how long they look at specific products, etc.) and then using it to other retailers for them to then target those visitors with ads.
- isostatic 9y agoOK, it's the petrol station part of the supermarket, but "Tesco is set to install hi-tech screens that scan customers' faces in petrol stations so that advertisements can be tailored to suit them, it has been reported. The retailer will introduce the OptimEyes screen, developed by Lord Sugar's Amscreen, to all 450 of its UK petrol stations, in a five-year deal, according to The Grocer. The screen, positioned at the till, scans the eyes of customers to determine age and gender, and then runs tailored advertisements." https://www.theguardian.com/business/2013/nov/03/privacy-tesco-scan-customers-faces https://www.theguardian.com/business/2013/nov/03/privacy-tes...
- cft 9y agoAnd with application layer DDoS attacks and intrusions: surrender? Do not ban bad actors? Or outsource to Cloudflare that keeps an army of EU lawyers and is compliant?
- icebraining 9y agoNah, that's a legitimate interest (the example given in Recital 47 is preventing fraud, which is similar). You can process it as long as you only use it for that purpose and delete it as soon as possible.
- drewmol 9y ago> It's about preserving rights of individuals. I'm not sticking up for all the big data perverts, but what about an individuals right to speak freely and disclose information they have observed/recorded? The 'right to be forgotten' seems at odds with everyone else's right to remember and disclose occurances.
- FooBarWidget 9y agoThat is not the case. The "right to be forgotten" is not absolute. There are lawful bases for processing under which the right to be forgotten does not apply. Go read GDPR article 17.3, it's easy to read. A few things for which the right to forgotten does not apply: - exercising the right of freedom of expression and information - for compliance with a legal obligation (e.g. keeping records for tax reporting) - for public interest reasons related to health, science, historical research Seriously, there is too much FUD about the GDPR.
- beberlei 9y agoYes! The fud keeps increasing every time another gdpr related post pops up here.
- zaarn 9y agoI'm 60% sure it's people who read articles from Adtech Corporations about GDPR and not from people in the EU having to deal with it. The only bad thing that I've noticed about GDPR is that some niche sites that rely on ad revenue are getting fucked over by Google (if you turn off personalized tracking for your visitors you still need the consent to track, there is no difference) so their income might break down. That's quite sad but on the other hand they're exploring alternative methods of income and I'm certain adtech will adapt.
- FooBarWidget 9y agoI doubt it's only that. I think it's also the tendency of people nowadays to only read titles and not to investigate further. I think some people are triggered by the phrase "right to be forgotten" and they jump to conclusions without finding out what it's really about.