3 ms·
These are fine counterexamples. The existence of instances of borrowing that nobody objects to doesn't mean that the problem of cultural appropriation doesn't e
by theoh 8y ago
These are fine counterexamples. The existence of instances of borrowing that nobody objects to doesn't mean that the problem of cultural appropriation doesn't exist.
It's a question of nuance, on a case-by-case basis. It's not about something "fitting the definition" of cultural appropriation, it's about whether someone is hurt by it e.g. by having their voice or agency denied. It's a subjective thing.
Showing me a piece of software with no bugs doesn't disprove the existence of other, buggy, software...
- mcphage 8y ago> It's a question of nuance, on a case-by-case basis. I agree, although I don't think "nuance" or "case-by-case basis" have ever been used in accusations of appropriation.
- theoh 8y agoWell, a Google search finds a number of articles/posts on the topic which make the observation that more nuance is needed in the conversation. So you are probably right that it is typically lacking, though the word nuance isn't totally absent from the discussion.