5 ms·
I had a kid a year ago, and another one three years ago. Both had this test. Their mom probably wouldn't remember if you asked her. She's not really a good per
by jedberg 9y ago
I had a kid a year ago, and another one three years ago. Both had this test.
Their mom probably wouldn't remember if you asked her. She's not really a good person to ask. You should be asking the partner who was there for the birth, since we're the one that actually sees it happen (they were still stitching up my wife when the test was done).
For the second kid (because I was just in a daze for the first kid), being the paranoid security person that I am, I asked what happens to the sample and what kind of controls are placed on the sample. I also asked if I could opt out. I was told that I could not opt out and that the sample becomes the property of the State and there is nothing I could do about it.
This article was the first I learned that I could request it be destroyed. It is also the first time I'm learning it could be used for research (but I kind of assumed that was why they kept it in the first place, other than to add to a database for matching with potential criminal activity).
So thanks for posting this, now I have to figure out how to request the samples. I'm going to see if I can actually the spots back.
- dlg 9y agoWould anyone here be interested in a lawsuit and/or campaign to get this changed?
- NHern031 9y agoNot being able to opt your child out of DNA collections seems like what could be a slippery slope to a Brave New World. What's even worse is the level of misinformation surrounding the situation. Even if the samples are held under the assumption that they will be used for research, one should be entitled to opt-in, opt-out, and know what is happening with their/their child's DNA. A lawsuit here seems reasonable if not to stop this, to atleast shed light on the situation.
- gcb0 9y agoopting out of proven good health measures sound like anti-vaxer, but ensuring the state have apropriate privacy safeguards is paramont
- jjeaff 9y agoThere's nothing antivax about requiring opt in before the state can store your samples indefinitely.
- gcb0 9y agoplease, it was a one line comment, how could you have misread it? the antivaxer comment is about opting out for something that is immediately beneficial (disease screening) and long term (research) in lieu of paranoia (in case of a working government) or privacy (in case of a broken government as it is now, according to the article). the right course of action is not to deny your children of the proven benefits, but to force the government to respect the individual and its own processes/institutions.
- eeZah7Ux 9y ago> Not being able to opt your child out [...] slippery slope to a Brave New World. Having to opt out instead of in is already bad enough. Not being able to opt out is way beyond "slippery slope".
- jjeaff 9y agoLooks to me like a good angle would be the state's apparent failure to notify parents that their child's dna will be stored. Since that is a provision of the law.
- thankthunk 9y ago> I was told that I could not opt out and that the sample becomes the property of the State and there is nothing I could do about it. That is so disgusting. For all the talk about individuality and liberalism, it's amazing how liberal societies are so authoritarian and controlling. If you don't own your DNA, then what do you own? But I guess big brother knows what's best for us.
- burntrelish1273 9y agoIt's not really classical liberalism or socialism, but corporate, neoliberal, infantile fascism driven by the silence and pussification of the majority of people. In the Netherlands, gym membership require drug tests and many rental properties require, either formally or informally, occupants to be of Dutch nationality. Another example is what happens in Berkeley with regard to hierarchy of victimhood SJW closing campus of anyone white and male, instead of promoting tolerance and equity (means equal fairness tailored to needs, while "equality" means essentially a duplicate of everything for everyone, at the cost of waste, not based on need). Free speech means debate, not shouting each other down, instant blocking nor banning from speaking... if a book is worth banning it's probably worth reading, so why not be consistent with public speech?
- eeZah7Ux 9y ago> corporate, neoliberal, infantile fascism Not so infantile anymore. > "pussification" ... "SJW" Please keep this words limited to 4chan.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]