7 ms·
Why We Should Listen to Flat Earth Believers (Even Though They're Totally Wrong)
- marsrover 9y agoI like to entertain all ideas (I even gave the Finland conspiracy a chance) no matter how crazy they sound. You never really know, especially if you have never even look. When the day comes that there isn't a person around that will challenge their thoughts with something they find crazy, it will be a dark day. Edit: after reading the article I see that my comment is not related.
- FRex 9y agoThis sadly sounds like a rip off of the venerable Bielefeld Conspiracy[0], just reapplied to an entire country. I have once entertained starting a conspiracy theory saying that unix shell pipes were originally created to allow piping fortune to cowsay. [0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bielefeld_Conspiracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bielefeld_Conspiracy
- SubiculumCode 9y agoIt's fine and even fun to entertain a different counter idea, but that is not what these flat earthers and the like do. I know a man that subscribes to these kinds of ideas, although not flat eartherism, and it is definitely seems to stem from a need to find an alternative order to the world because the existing order and/or understanding provides little comfort, hope, and meaning, because they are driven by a need to be special and smarter . These ppl are often also frequently 'inventors' of 'free energy' motors, using mmethods they will say are 'obvious once you think about it but for some reason no one has'. In fact these ppl can be very clever and ingenuous, but have certain mental illnes (depression) and lack education, but perhaps the everyday flat earther prostlesthized on youtube are driven mostly by ignorance and poverty in a hard life needing something, anything, to not be as it seems.
- csydas 9y agoI would agree with this, as my interactions largely share the same results. It's not about being right so much as not being wrong. It's a position of arrogance and insolence that is being argued from, not really one of true educational purpose. It's dishonest discourse for the purpose of self-gratification, just like any other poster online looking just for kicks and giggles. There may be an honest belief behind flat-earthers and other such conspiracy theorists, but just observe the similarities between any bargain-bin message board troll and a flat-earth conspiracy theorist and it's easy to see the other motivations that drive the conspiracy theorists. The big thing with conspiracy theories is that everything is evidence of the theory, whether it seems good or bad for the theory. You find indisputable proof that it's wrong, and the truth is twisted to be another conspiracy in and of itself which proves the legitimacy of the original theory. There is some inconclusive data that is the result of a long term study, and that is proof of the theory because the theory can be neatly fitted to the available evidence, barring any scrutiny. It becomes a game of constant mental bouts, bringing in hoards of evidence against often unprepared targets, and truly the only real winning strategy is not to play. The entire point is to surprise and assault an unsuspecting person who is not prepared with the same amount of curated arguments and prepared answer cards. If you've ever caught the sales side of a major organization, you'll know that they often produce "battle cards" for competing products. These battle cards are often built with three points; Attack, Defend, Avoid. Attack tells you how to best attack the competition and their weakest points that can be overcome. Defend tells you how to shore up your own product's weak points, and Avoid tells you want points to absolutely dodge at any cost and how to use the point as a pivot to something better (in order to ignore the difficult point). I see this 100% repeated in conspiracy theory image spam, and you can see the same thing with the message board trolls and how they prep for engaging people. The strategy isn't about arguments based on merit or reason, but instead creating a compelling narrative for an audience to follow. And that's the real target here. Flat-earther conspiracy theorists and other such conspiracy theorists aren't looking to have a discourse and convince any specific person with an opposing view-point. They're looking to put on the greatest show possible to attract the largest audience, and maybe get a few converts along the way. You don't need to be hostile towards conspiracy theorists, but the idea of hearing them out and entertaining their thoughts beyond just a very limited and controlled dialogue is a bad idea, since the theory doesn't expand far beyond just having an alternative theory that bucks the current consensus. So sure, pay attention, and be polite, but also there's a need to be firm, because a lot of this is attention seeking behavior looking for a platform and for credulity, not for a discussion. The idea that they will dive deeper into more outrageous positions and theories is a bit silly, as they would do that anyways; as within any subculture, the desire to be "the most ____" will always drive participants to up the ante and act out in bigger and bigger ways. Whether or not one listens to them is irrelevant.
- twic 9y ago> the Finland conspiracy This, for those like me who had not heard of it, is the idea that Finland does not exist, and there is a conspiracy to make the world think that it does. When really, almost the opposite is true: not only does Finland exist, but it is the surviving part of the Roman Empire: https://imgur.com/gallery/eNuUdTd https://imgur.com/gallery/eNuUdTd
- rhapsodic 9y agoTL;DR: > Looking back at my weekend with Flat Earthers, it is striking how many > people who doubt the global model of the Earth also subscribe to all > manner of other beliefs, from Biblical literalism to occultist paranoia, > from anti-vaccination to quack cancer cues, from antisemitism to Aryanism. > But it was also just as striking how many people whose journey into > believing the Earth is flat included traumatic events or personal crises. > > This, perhaps, is why it is so important for us to listen to and talk > to Flat Earthers, and to approach them as much with understanding as > ridicule: if they can see no light in mainstream society, their rabbit > hole may only get deeper and darker.
- flavmartins 9y agoA great summary. Trauma is real. Our society doesn't place enough emphasis in recognizing mental health issues other than depression. There are many other events that cause trauma and people deal with it in many different ways. This is why you no matter the number of facts you present in online discussions will ever dissuade these individuals from their positions.
- JackCh 9y agoI have my own loony belief with little supporting evidence. My loony belief is that the overwhelming majority of "Flat Earthers" are joking, pulling your chain, and refuse to admit it because keeping a straight face is part of the joke for them. Their motivations are varied. Some of them do it to make some sort of epistemological point, others do it because arguing for something that isn't true requires a form of creativity they find rewarding. Others do it because they like to get people riled up (it's amazing how easily some people can get riled up over other people being wrong about the shape of the earth, even when the reality that the flat earther isn't being sincere is staring them right in the face). Others still probably have other motivations. Probably only a very small portion of them actually believe what they say.
- FRex 9y agoIt's even harder to take them seriously after they said this about flat Mars to Musk: https://twitter.com/FlatEarthOrg/status/935644892721762305 https://twitter.com/FlatEarthOrg/status/935644892721762305
- dahart 9y agoMaybe if you believe that any significant number of people truly think the earth is flat despite the photos, then you’re in the same fiction club. ;) I have to admit, the irony is funny.
- naasking 9y ago> My loony belief is that the overwhelming majority of "Flat Earthers" are joking, pulling your chain, and refuse to admit it because keeping a straight face is part of the joke for them. I'd almost lend some credence to that, if some of them weren't building their own rockets and launching themselves into the air to try to prove flat earth: https://www.popularmechanics.com/space/rockets/a19587128/self-taught-rocket-scientist-blasts-off/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/space/rockets/a19587128/sel...
- randoramax 9y agoThat guy is using the flat earthers to raise funds from them. He conveniently tied his desire to build a rocket for himself to prove some flat theory, but his motivation seems to be completely a few one.
- simonbarker87 9y agoThe thing I find most infuriating speaking to anyone who believes in a conspiracy theory is that no rational argument can win them round because their arguments are rarely rational or based on concrete evidence. Antivaccers are particularly difficult because they simply have no faith in science or doctors and believe that any evidence is fabricated. Has anyone found effective methods to counter the above traits? While not engaging is usually the best option it is sad and concerning when it is a family member so I don’t feel like ignoring it is the best approach.
- ihsw2 9y agoYou cannot reason someone out of something they weren't reasoned into to begin with.
- some_account 9y agoIf you truly want to understand, you need to be open to the possibility that they are right. Since you are not, I recommend not bringing it up. Some of the people who believe these things are not stupid at all, and while it may seem smart to you to just accept what you hear from the professionals, it actually doesn't require any intelligence to follow what they say. I've been working with professionals a lot, and I know they are just repeating what they are told. Every profession is like that. Experts even more so, since otherwise they lose credibility and are not experts anymore.
- mistermann 9y agoSo true. If one looks closely at actual (as opposed to the false caricature most people hold in their mind) "conspiracy theories", very often they are based on reasonable questions or the desire for more details & study, with a big percentage of actual idiots also participating in the discussion. And when you observe their detractors, say on here or reddit, you will usually see an unfortunate strawman or worst-possible-interpretation approach being taken to claims being discussed. The human mind is extremely susceptible to various fallacies such as confirmation bias. Usually this is beneficial, but often it can be very harmful.
- 9y ago
- insickness 9y agoWhile I don't believe it, I'm glad that flat earth theory exists. It's a fantastic caricature of scientific theory that seems to exist simply to shine a light on the fact that any theory has a nonzero chance of being true, albeit in the most ridiculous of realities.
- lighttower 9y agoI have young kids and spend a lot of time in playgrounds. When I push the swing a flat earth believer approaches me to tell me about chemtrails , flat earth and how vaccines cause autism. He brought pamphlets about vaccines a few times. Always citing some Harvard Prof who supports his theories and refers me to YouTube. He has a little girl that he pushes on the swing and talks to everyone he can about vaccines. That's a really damaging. I just want to politely stop this conversation, though I enjoyed the flat earth stuff. His talking to new moms about vaccines is potentially damaging.
- mrfusion 9y agoI’ve got a flat earth family member and I thought it would be easy to go out to the beach and get a photo of a ship appearing over the horizon to disprove them. But it just won’t seem to work out. They seem to get smaller and smaller and too small to see if the botttom is disappearing first. I’m going to have to try it with a telescope. It’s kind making me question my own beliefs. Also they made me watch some of those YouTube videos about the eclipse going in the wrong direction. I still haven’t been able to explain that. :-( I guess my point is don’t expect an easy debate if you engage them. Some of this stuff just isn’t as easy as you’d expect.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- naasking 9y ago> Also they made me watch some of those YouTube videos about the eclipse going in the wrong direction. You mean a video that's flipped or running backwards? Why would you question your whole worldview before questioning the reliability of the alleged evidence?
- mrfusion 9y agoI just mean the moon moves from east to west in the sky but the eclipse went from west to east. There are lots of videos and article with explanations but none of them clicked for me.
- sunw 9y agoHere's a clean explanation from NASA's eclipse site (https://eclipse2017.nasa.gov/why-do-eclipse-tracks-move-eastward-even-though-earth-rotates-west-east https://eclipse2017.nasa.gov/why-do-eclipse-tracks-move-east...). The moon actually moves much faster than the Earth spins -- it just seems to move westward to humans on the ground because it's so far away from Earth (takes 28 days to go around Earth). During a solar eclipse though, we see the effect of its true blisteringly fast orbital speed. "Because the Moon moves to the east in its orbit at about 3,400 km/hour. Earth rotates to the east at 1,670 km/hr at the equator, so the lunar shadow moves to the east at 3,400 – 1,670 = 1,730 km/hr near the equator. You cannot keep up with the shadow of the eclipse unless you traveled at Mach 1.5."
- mping 9y agoIf you ever want to explain what its like to fix bugs in a new language, just point them to this article; you basically guess how things work until you are proven otherwise, no matter how incredible and without proof the explanation my be.
- RobertRoberts 9y agoScience is hard. I watched a few minutes of a Youtube video from a "professor" at a university that believes the earth is flat, and he "sounded" very scientific. But despite the fact that I know the earth is round, beyond the boat-over-the-horizon experiment I would have a hard time actually demonstrating this fact to someone. On the other hand, I have quite a few disagreements with the established health industry. I cured a hole in my tooth in college in the late 90s on my own. I am still called a quack and a liar despite my wife knowing about this, and just this past year real scientific proof (and even medical products) coming out confirming it's true. But in the mean time, until it's widely accepted, I will be called a liar and/or quack/delusional. And this is has nothing to do with trauma, but simply ignorance, and a lack of interest in testing. (conspiracy would say that dentists don't want people healing their own teeth)
- sheepz 9y agoCould you elaborate on how you fixed your tooth?
- RobertRoberts 9y agoSure, I simply kept the large hole in the side of my tooth clean. Used a tooth pick and peroxide. And consistently and regularly swished spit around in my mouth over the tooth. Also, I don't eat any processed white sugar (including corn syrups and their ilk) and I suspect this helped.
- sanderjd 9y agoBut how did that fix it? It sounds like what you are doing is managing a cavity, not fixing it.
- RobertRoberts 9y ago>But how did that fix it? The tooth filled in on it's own. I just kept it cleaned out. I think the term I ran into recently that seems to describe my experience is "re-mineralization". Today is the first time I thought to look this term up on wikipedia. [0] >Saliva, being the watery substance that constantly circulates the oral cavity, is capable of impacting both the remineralisation and demineralisation processes. This quote from the Wikipedia article is sourced from a paper in The Journal of the American Dental Association. [1] >Remineralization occurs on a daily basis after an acidogenic challenge through the presence of saliva. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Remineralisation_of_teeth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Remineralisation_of_teeth [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0002817714638794 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000281771...
- dahart 9y ago> But it was also just as striking how many people whose journey into believing the Earth is flat included traumatic events or personal crises. This, perhaps, is why it is so important for us to listen to and talk to Flat Earthers That is certainly plausible, but there was almost no real evidence presented here. It seems like the author is jumping to conclusions. As far as we know, two of the three speakers covered in this story happened to mention the existence of non-specific personal issues in passing. How many people don’t have any personal issues? It could be that some people do need help. And it could also be incredibly insulting and patronizing to just assume that people with beliefs different than ours are in need of mental help, as opposed to simply having strange beliefs. After all, religion still exists despite a lack of evidence. Treating religious people as stuck in a dark “rabbit hole” is at best ostracizing. > Landucci points out that if we take the Spanish initials for the United Nations, ‘ONU’, and read it backwards, we get ‘Uno’ – which is Spanish for ‘One’. This, he explains, is proof that the UN is a tool of the One World Order. For the entire article, I couldn’t stop thinking of the Illuminati Confirmed videos on YouTube.
- everdev 9y ago> it could also be incredibly insulting and patronizing to just assume that people with beliefs different than ours are in need of mental help I agree with this in principle, but at what point do we have no other choice? Witches? Lizard people? Alien abductions?
- dahart 9y ago> I agree with this in principle, but at what point do we have no other choice? Witches? Lizard people? Alien abductions? I guess what I’m suggesting is that “listening” to crazy theories because you feel sorry for people under the assumption that they’re unstable or have trauma in their past is much worse than either 1) ignoring them, or 2) engaging in their debate on their terms (i.e. taking them seriously). If it looks crazy, then just ignore it, but don’t assume it’s because the person is crazy or has mental problems. They might, just don’t assume. The other half of my point is that literally everyone has crazy theories that aren’t supported by evidence. Religion covers half the world, but even scientists have bizarre beliefs, and all humans are subject to cognitive mistakes, and we are physiologically wired to hang on to our beliefs even when they’re wrong. I personally know a bunch of people with PhDs who stick to ideas that are wrong, like my doctor friend who doesn’t “believe” in counting calories for weight loss. I’m sure I have one or two myself, and I don’t know what they are. We need to recognize that you and I and all of us also have wacky beliefs and we wouldn’t want to be labeled as mental. Assuming that something is wrong with someone because of their beliefs is a deliberate form of “othering”. *edit: One way I like to think about this is like so: Make a list of all the thing you know that you’ve actually verified yourself. We know the earth is round, but have you actually proven it to yourself? I haven’t. I “know” that space exists because of other people’s stories, I’ve never been there myself. Pretty much everything I “know” about computers and politics and religion and psychology, and everything else, is things I’ve heard or read that other people verified, not me. The list of things I know 100% for a fact because I proved it myself is a very short list.
- ourmandave 9y agoI find it easy to be dismissive of Flat Earthers and Moon Landing Deniers as they tend to be Mostly Harmless. I worry about the guy who fired shots into a pizza restaurant with an AR-15 because he believed it was a front for a child sex ring. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pizzagate_conspiracy_theory https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pizzagate_conspiracy_theory Or when some random clown from Texas, who campaigned on disbanding the Dept of Energy, now runs it. Now you have my attention.
- specialist 9y agoFrom the article: "Looking back at my weekend with Flat Earthers, it is striking how many people who doubt the global model of the Earth also subscribe to all manner of other beliefs, from Biblical literalism to occultist paranoia, from anti-vaccination to quack cancer cues, from antisemitism to Aryanism. But it was also just as striking how many people whose journey into believing the Earth is flat included traumatic events or personal crises. This, perhaps, is why it is so important for us to listen to and talk to Flat Earthers, and to approach them as much with understanding as ridicule: if they can see no light in mainstream society, their rabbit hole may only get deeper and darker." This is one of the most humane, compassionate worldviews I've read in a while. I really want to be more like Michael Marshall (the author), but I just don't know how. Maybe I do, and just need to do it more. Last year I got involved with protecting wolves from one rogue rancher. During the public hearing, things got very heated. I found myself empathizing with the ranchers more than the enviros, two of whom acted very embarrassingly. One rancher (who was actually an ally of the enviros but still being attacked) had to leave the room, so I went out to check on him. I guess I'm still trying to figure out how we're supposed to engage with people we strongly disagree with.
- monktastic1 9y agoFwiw, meditation has been an amazing tool for me here.
- ComodoHacker 9y agoHad anyone tried to crowdfund and buy some flat-earther a ticket to orbit? Maybe a TV company could fund it and make a reality show?