3 ms·
Luddites are just people disempowered by automation and capitalism: if its cheaper to use machines than people, automation makes people effectively jobless - a
by FrozenVoid 8y ago
Luddites are just people disempowered by automation and capitalism: if its cheaper to use machines than people, automation makes people effectively jobless - and if automation touches multiple sectors of economy it multiplies the effect by squeezing out people from multiple sides, reducing the labor demand significantly.
If there are no alternative sources of income(welfare, UBI) that correct this, expect many more "Neo-Luddites" to emerge; specifically in areas targeted for automation.
Its not that these people would be "against progress", they would be against more concrete things(such as the article describes) like automated trucks/delivery and start attacking/robbing/sabotaging the machines to discourage their use instead of people.
Just like some abuse automated cashiers(cash registers) to steal products and earlier trends of vending machine abuse: it doesn't register to people they are criminals because the target of crime isn't human, therefore justifying their impulse and intention. That means NeoLuddites don't lose their own 'moral high ground' and will be able to easily spread their ideologies as automation carries bigger and bigger chunk of the economy.
- gaius 8y agomore "Neo-Luddites" to emerge; specifically in areas targeted for automation The difference being that the automation you want to smash is actually thousands of miles away in China; there are no local factories anymore for the neo-Luddites to target.
- emodendroket 8y agoThe automated trucks and cash registers his post refers to cannot be "thousands of miles away in China" and serve their intended purpose.
- Spooky23 8y agoI think this is where the moral issue pops up. Is handing out bread and circus a meaningful response to taking away people’s agency?
- mmirate 8y agoIt is, if the goal is to be the next Roman Empire. That goal, of course, is quite dubious, since it involves illiberality, authoritarianism, etc.