3 ms·
The Boring Company is a sign of someone who doesn't understand the problem. Hyperloop and Loop both suffer from the same basic problem: high fixed infrastructu
by jcranmer 9y ago
The Boring Company is a sign of someone who doesn't understand the problem.
Hyperloop and Loop both suffer from the same basic problem: high fixed infrastructure costs with very low throughputs. Higher speed naturally comes with a penalty to capacity [1], but since capacity (at high speeds) is generally invariant with respect to the size of the train and the number of people per car, you can recuperate a lot of capacity by stuffing as many people as you can. Except Hyperloop and Loop are envisioned with single-digit loading, which is basically PRT-level--trash tier in terms of capacity, particularly with regards to price of infrastructure.
Okay, let's move to boring. The only suggestions for lowering prices are a) making tunnels smaller (i.e., make it incompatible with repurposing for other infrastructure, particularly if the venture turns out to be a white elephant) and b) maybe making the actual boring costs be lower. But boring the tunnels isn't the predominant cost of a tunnel--it only costs about $50 million or so to bore a mile of tunnel. That's about a third the cost of actually building a subway [2]. The big cost is the large underground stations. Okay, you say, you need smaller stations, so those would cost less--but because your capacity is so bad that you're going to need many more stations to make up for the throughput. Having run the numbers for single-occupant vehicles, you need about 100× the number of stations to match the capacity of a regular subway line, and the rounding there is flattering to Loop.
If The Boring Company were serious about making tunneling cheaper, they should be bidding for the tunneling subcontracts of current public infrastructure projects. The fact that they're pitching a different transit system instead suggests a form of bait-and-switch.
[1] Essentially, your problems grow with the square of velocity, so multiplied by the linear improvement with velocity, you end up with total throughput running proportional to O(1 / v).
[2] The cost of building a subway is generally only about $300 million a mile. Some subways (cough MTA cough) cost up to $1 billion a mile, but making better TBMs isn't going to make a meaningful dent in those high prices.
- inopinatus 9y ago> The Boring Company is a sign of someone who doesn't understand the problem. That rather depends what problem you expect it to tackle. I reframe everything Elon Musk does as testing/developing technologies for interplanetary colonization, which don't forget is SpaceX's very specific vision statement (http://www.spacex.com/about http://www.spacex.com/about). Back in 2017 he specifically said "I do think getting good at digging tunnels could be really helpful for Mars" and went on to discuss the value of underground colonies in terms of access to ice, radiation protection etc.
- jcranmer 9y agoWe're already quite good at digging tunnels.
- inopinatus 9y agoYes - quite good.
- mandeepj 9y ago> if Boring co were serious... Did you miss this one? https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.cnbc.com/amp/2018/04/16/boring-company-raises-113-million-to-dig-tunnels-for-loop-hyperloop.html https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.cnbc.com/amp/2018/04/16/bor...
- jcranmer 9y agoThose are basically pitches for Loop/Hyperloop, not contracting tunneling for roads, rails, sewers, aqueducts, or other tunnel projects.