2 ms·
> Lightning: mechanically it's the best connector I've ever seen. Sorry, that’s only true because you mostly see the male end of connectors. Lightning has mul
by amluto 9y ago
> Lightning: mechanically it's the best connector I've ever seen.
Sorry, that’s only true because you mostly see the male end of connectors. Lightning has multiple severe design problems:
- Cables that plug into things have moving parts. There are springy electrical contacts and springy mechanical bits that hold the connector in. These parts wear out. A good design puts all the moving parts on the cable’s end, which may be less attractive but means that, when they inevitably wear out, replacing the cable solves the problem. With Lightning, the parts that wear out are in the socket, where they’re out of sight but can’t be easily replaced.
- There’s something wrong with the electrical contact design. Even on the Apple store, all the male Lightning connectors that aren’t very, very new look a bit scorched on one of the center pins. I don’t know whether this is due to arcing when the connection is made or broken or due to insufficient contact area or pressure.
To add insult to injury, when the socket fails, Apple will not replace it. Either you get a third-party replacement or you replace the whole phone.
Sorry, but even disregarding compatibility, Lightning is attractive but is otherwise shitty.
- tim333 9y ago> A good design puts all the moving parts on the cable’s end Are there any of those? I think every cable I can think of or have owned in my life is the other way around with the moving parts in the box part not the cable. I guess there's more space for moving parts in the box bit. It's true I had a lighting socket pack up and replaced - the repair shop said it was quite common. Also I'm on an Anker lighting cable as the plastic Apple uses is rubbish, cracks, gets patched with sellotape, dies in the end. PowerLine II is good - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dLiSwyknmks https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dLiSwyknmks.
- boulos 9y agoEthernet cables come to mind. The bit that makes it clip in, is definitely on the cable.
- amluto 9y ago> Are there any of those? I think every cable I can think of or have owned in my life is the other way around with the moving parts in the box part not the cable. I guess there's more space for moving parts in the box bit. USB Type C and Micro USB come to mind. On Micro USB, there are very visible springy clips on the outside of the plug. I'm not entirely sure what's going on with USB Type A, but I think the springy part of the contact is in the plug and the leaf spring that holds the plug in may be in the socket.