2 ms·
It's mathematics. Not physics. You're mixing things on a very bad level. Mathematics exists in the mind, so to speak. There is no requirement of consistency wi
by andrepd 9y ago
It's mathematics. Not physics. You're mixing things on a very bad level.
Mathematics exists in the mind, so to speak. There is no requirement of consistency with the physical world, even though some mathematics may be a useful language for modelling our physical theories of reality.
Euclidean geometry is self-consistent, and so is non-euclidean geometry. The point I think they were trying to make is that the parallel postulate is independent of the other 4, something that quite flustered mathematicians for millennia, until it was discovered that changing the parallel postulate led to different geometries, also very rich and interesting. So the parallel postulate is an example of an unprovable proposition in geometry with the other 4 axioms.
- LolWolf 9y agoDepending on what you mean, non-euclidean geometry may not be self-consistent (or it may! We don't know, unless we appeal to stronger axioms). In a large number of cases, the set of axioms which produce the geometries in question are powerful enough to embed natural-number-like structures, which would imply that the consistency of the systems cannot be proven from within the systems, themselves.
- andrepd 9y agoGodel's theorem doesn't apply to Euclidean geometry. Tarski proved it is complete, consistent, and decidable.
- LolWolf 9y agoYes, that's fine. That Tarski's axioms for Euclidean geometry are consistent is independent of that claim—the above is a statement about the "usual" non-euclidean geometries (i.e., Riemannian).