36 ms·
It seems to me that the modern concept of race is one of the most ingrained illusions in our culture. Discussions of whether some person or some group is "whit
by colordrops 9y ago
It seems to me that the modern concept of race is one of the most ingrained illusions in our culture. Discussions of whether some person or some group is "white" or "black" or whatever have no more rigor than asking whether someone is a "jock" or a "nerd". First, there is no clear definition of "white" and "black" or anything else, and even if we take the most common conception of it, most people don't fit neatly into either category. For instance, by US census standards, both a Norwegian and a Yemeni are "white". What about the racial gradient in the region of the Isthmus of Suez? Where do people stop being white and start being black?
Furthermore, most racial conceptions obsess with superficial features that may not correlate with large differences in DNA. There may be two people that look more similar but have wider differences in their DNA than two people that look different.
- s4vi0r 9y agoThe funniest thing about this whole ethnostate crap you see being pushed by the alt right is that a lot of these people don't even realize Europeans don't see themselves as one big ethnic group of "white people" - and they literally never have. Hell, they even spend some time in grade school teaching kids about the discrimination early Irish and Italian immigrants faced in America where they weren't considered white or white enough by WASPs.
- aangoBi5 9y agoYou're giving them a bit too little credit. At least the alt-rights that I occasionally chat with certainly do not see the europeans as a monolithic block. Only central european and nordics are considered "true aryans" while eastern and southern europe are considered second class at best and you'll find slurs like "olive niggers" too. There even are neat infographics about various genetic markers associated with different populations. They do study their own propaganda.
- Radim 9y agoWhile technically true, this way of looking at the world feels a little pedantic. Yes, all words and objects and categories are only leaky abstractions. Our universe is a shimmering swirl of unique patterns, all boundaries ultimately fuzzy. At the same time, there is observable structure. Words and categories emerge and are judged by their usefulness, how they help us in everyday life -- despite being leaky abstractions. They're never bulletproof descriptions of reality, or you wouldn't be able to say much. "Jock" vs "nerd", "white" vs "black", "tiger" vs "rock"… Among the infinite axes of how to slice and conceptualize reality, which ones are worth giving a name to? Who decides?
- colordrops 9y agoMaybe it's pedantic for you, but it's not pedantic for me and others that are precisely the ones who are stuck in the middle of these vague definitions. I'm called both white and colored in different contexts. It often feels like I get many of the disadvantages of being "colored" while also losing out on opportunities due to my supposed "white privilege".
- Radim 9y agoNo doubt. Being uncomfortably stuck in the middle propels action, which is the only thing able to bring about change. What I was trying to say is that uncomfortable, leaky abstractions are absolutely standard. Is a virus alive or inanimate? Are physics and chemistry distinct disciplines? When does an embryo become a human being? I wasn't being snarky with my "who decides?". If your actions to change established concepts and words manage to overcome the perceived utility of these concepts and words for others, people will change their vocabulary and the way they view the world. It's happened before. It is an elaborate dance of utility, so keep fighting.