4 ms·
What I find amazing is that there are still people on this planet who oppose anything a government does, so they end up at the perils of corporations. I guess,
by Fnoord 9y ago
What I find amazing is that there are still people on this planet who oppose anything a government does, so they end up at the perils of corporations. I guess, according to you, GDPR is also a Bad Thing (tm)? Hint: it is a response to an industry which failed to regulate itself.
When corporations cannot manage themselves, the government must interact by rule of law. An example of that is the sale of frequencies such as 4G. Or the prohibition of usage of certain frequencies because the government uses them for military purposes. You may agree or disagree with some of these, but they serve a purpose which in the end can be deducted to being useful for the people (ie. the military, in the end, serves the purpose to protect the people).
If the government protects the interest of the [all] the people, equally, which they do in the case of net neutrality then the government uses its vast power to keep the corporations on a leash so that [all] the people can benefit. That is not anarchism, true, because the government uses its authority against very powerful monopolies/duopolies or other power vacuums with commercial interests. It is akin to the old GPL vs BSDL debate. And if you had that debate on Usenet or Slashdot there was no consensus precisely because there's the camp who believes in an authority and the anarchistic one.
- RaleyField 9y ago> Hint: it is a response to an industry which failed to regulate itself. Hint: maybe stop being condescending. Also, I'm from EU and I'm split on GDPR. On one side I acknowledge its benefits and where it's coming from (the industry is known for highly morally dubious practices), on the other hand I don't agree on principle with the implication that users don't/can't have free will to enter into (however unfair) contracts these companies wish to use.
- Fnoord 9y ago> on the other hand I don't agree on principle with the implication that users don't/can't have free will to enter into (however unfair) contracts these companies wish to use. In a capitalist society such apathy leads to a survival of the fittest. I can give many examples of contracts which would be unfair. For example, a minor cannot consent to a contract because they're a minor. That is fair to protect minors (at age of ~20 a person is physically an adult and around ~25 the brain is fully grown). I can apply your logic "on principle" there as well. Principles like these lack nuance which realistic situations demand because they are not black and white.
- AsyncAwait 9y ago> I don't agree on principle with the implication that users don't/can't have free will to enter into (however unfair) contracts these companies wish to use. These companies have lawyers who spend 40+ hours a week crafting contracts from which it's impossible to determine what are your rights for the average person. Good for you for not having a bad experience yet, but once you do you'll want a recourse that's more than just 'tough luck'. I know where this thinking comes from - is this absolutist "I should be free to do whatever" mentality, which ignores the fact that you rely on the fact of people not being able to do that daily. Are you of the opinion, for example, that simply leaving your house gives anyone who dares a free pass to enter it? I mean, you're technically free to take it back from them once you get back and if they're stronger, better equipped so you don't manage to? Well, tough luck, I guess.
- ttoinou 9y agoit is a response to an industry which failed to regulate itself Pretty much everything websites do with your data are from voluntary exchange. We decide to subscribe to a website a visit it regularly and give to it your data. We decide to surf some website without ad blockers / web trackers extensions, and we don't want to pay for social medias and some of us actually like well targeted ads. I fail to see what the corps should have done to regulate themselves
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Network_effect
- ttoinou 9y agoYou need to make a sentence to make a point
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoI am not making a point, I am simply providing a reference for you to read up on the basics of the stuff that you so confidently speak about.
- ttoinou 9y agoSo if all my friends and family are on facebook, I am ~forced~ to use facebook ? All my friends and family live in my state so I guess I don't have a choice and have to live my whole life in my motherland
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoIf you want to productively engage in a conversation, it isn't helpful if you use the weakest possible example for the other side's position to then dismiss it. That is just a slightly less obvious version of straw-manning. Also, your definition of "voluntary" as "the victim could conceivably have done something to prevent it but didn't" is very unusual and completely useless. By that definition, if someone poisons your food with a poison that is detectable with a test known in the literature, and you then eat it without testing it first, you have voluntarily let yourself be poisoned. If you get shot because you didn't wear bullet-proof clothing, then you voluntarily let yourself be shot. That's neither what "voluntary" normally means, nor would it in any way be a useful definition, as essentially everything that happens to you would have to be considered voluntary.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> What I find amazing is that there are still people on this planet who oppose anything a government does, so they end up at the perils of corporations. Well, no, because if they oppose everything government does, they'd oppose corporations, too, since they are a thing government does.
- AsyncAwait 9y agoIf you want to be this pedantic over it, it's that they oppose every piece of government regulation, regardless of merits, so basically everything the government does that isn't unchecked capitalism.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> If you want to be this pedantic over it I don't think it's pedantic to point out that many (but not all) people who voice “anti-government” attitudes are fine with particular government interventions. > it's that they oppose every piece of government regulation, regardless of merits That doesn't really change the issue; corporations (and even more the only motivation to form them) are products of government regulation. > so basically everything the government does that isn't unchecked capitalism. This, on the other hand, is spot on; it's just the idea they it somehow corresponds to the absence of government activity (or even particularly regulatory activity) that is wrong: the service of capitalism is an active, regulatory pursuit of government.