4 ms·
I couldn't imagine getting so caught up in one piece of work. I'd like to imagine I would have just immediately turned around and told everyone I was the guy wh
by legitster 9y ago
I couldn't imagine getting so caught up in one piece of work. I'd like to imagine I would have just immediately turned around and told everyone I was the guy who made the cover for Aqualung and focus my energy on the next project.
Also, it's very presumptive to assume I deserve a cut of your project just because it is successful. Not only do I claim my artwork had something to do with it (I doubt many people cared much about the album cover), but I can't give you one price and then extort you later because you actually have money now.
- mrleinad 9y agoThat's the point: Artists at that time weren't protected enough to retain copyright over their work. They are now. It's not whether "you actually have money now", it's that "you're making money with something I created and I deserve a piece of that too"
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- talltimtom 9y agoSo If you make a lot of money On Uber with your Tesla, they “deserve” a piece of that too? A deal is a deal, he sold the art up front without any royalty, that is in him and he was in no way cheated, had he done the same deal with 20 other covers of bands that disn’t make it big he would not be complaining.
- toyg 9y agoThe difference is that you cannot sell litographical copies of a Tesla with your autograph, as Ian Anderson is doing with that image now. The "copy" part of copyright exists precisely because these works are not simple manufactured goods, they can be easily copied.
- pvaldes 9y agoImage based in the photos taken previously from the wife of Ian Anderson, it seems. What the artist could have done is paint as many new versions of the image as he wants and sell them.
- talltimtom 9y agoHe bought the art for the exact reason it was used. Eg copying the art on covers. Like buying a Tesla for driving and Selling a service with that driving. I agree duly that if he has sold them just one image for one cover of one LP he would have a moral claim to having been cheated. However if that was the case his pricing would be an insane ripoff. And obviously that is not what transpired.
- toyg 9y agoThe original contract was for three paintings for album artwork, which he delivered and was paid for - I don't think there is any issue with that. The album could be reprinted billions of time and he wouldn't have a case. The problem he has is with all the collateral reproductions: t-shirts, litographies, and so on. You cannot do that with a manufactured good: if you buy a Tesla, you cannot magically reproduce it identical out of thin air and then sell it bundled with a truck. So please let's stop with the silly imagery that simply does not suit a copyright debate.
- djsumdog 9y agoIf you sell a man or women a piece of artwork, yes they can put it up in their home and people can see it. If people take photos in front of it, well the photo is of the people and the art could be fair use context. If they take that piece of art and copy it and put it on a book cover .. now that's not right. I've never actually bought art at an art fair, but I was with a friend who bought a ballet drawing once. I don't remember her signing anything to indicate use. She used her debit card and bought a painting which later hung up on her wall. I feel like if this happened today, this wouldn't be acceptable. If I sell you a piece of art, you don't get the copyright for that art. You can sell the art like you sell socks, and the person who buys that art can resell it later. But you can't make copies and sell them as your own. Or stand in front of it, take a photo, and use it as a book cover claiming fair use. If there is no contract, you haven't signed over your rights, and we should default on the side artists rights side of it.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> If you sell a man or women a piece of artwork, yes they can put it up in their home and people can see it. > If they take that piece of art and copy it and put it on a book cover .. now that's not right. ...where exactly do you think book covers come from? > If I sell you a piece of art, you don't get the copyright for that art. If you sell me art that I'm going to use for a book cover, I will in fact get the copyright for that art. There's no other way for me to handle that.
- ygra 9y agoIsn't copyright non-transferrable? You'd get certain usage rights, but copyright will always remain with the original artist.
- thaumasiotes 9y agoI have no idea what you're talking about. Obviously, the historical facts are that copyright was transferable at the time. It's certainly transferable right now. Why is your sentence set in the past tense, and what are you thinking of?
- laumars 9y agoOthers have already echoed my thoughts on copyright, so I won't repeat that, but I do want to raise one other point you touched upon: > I doubt many people cared much about the album cover Back in the old days of 12 inch records, people did care about album covers. I mean yeah, the music obviously matters more but album artwork was actually pretty important as well. One of the things I feel we've lost with digital music is the entire presentation of a record. That's not to say things are worse now because we've gained stuff in return (eg music has never been so widely available as it is now). But album artwork (not just the front covers) did actually matter to a great many people.
- srean 9y ago... and the liner notes.
- samastur 9y agoWe did but at least I, personally, have never bought or not bought a record because of its cover.
- thaumasiotes 9y agohttps://books.google.com/books?id=o0sti65JskUC&pg=PA64&lpg=PA64&dq=foxtrot+what%27s+with+all+the+reverb&source=bl&ots=R6HzsNBLZE&sig=kTZtHS8AP-nA1oA1O_i-uxDithM&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwja28uw0f_aAhUmrlQKHbtbCOwQ6AEIWDAO#v=onepage&q=foxtrot%20what's%20with%20all%20the%20reverb&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=o0sti65JskUC&pg=PA64&lpg=P...
- laumars 9y agoMaybe not exclusively because of the cover but I'd be lying if I said it's never influenced me to buy a record I was otherwise undecided about.
- Griffinsauce 9y agoYou can't honestly know what subconscious effects seeing that cover had. To say it had zero effect is pretty disingenuous when you take into account what we know about human decision making and a massive global ad industry.
- bfuller 9y agoAqualung was an old vinyl record my dad gave me, and I distinctly remember the cover.
- pjc50 9y agoThe real distinction is between "paid upfront a specific price", known as "work for hire", versus a royalty-based system. It's all about risk and option value. Most creative works never make a profit, so how much is a profit share worth? Most people need cashflow; if you need to pay rent at the end of the month, how much is a payout worth that's distributed over your life plus 70 years afterwards?