4 ms·
the land that is now the United States of America, started in fractured parts by many, very different, groups of people. Please do not throw the entire USA into
by mistrial9 9y ago
the land that is now the United States of America, started in fractured parts by many, very different, groups of people. Please do not throw the entire USA into the history of slavery -- many abhorred the practice at every stage, while others did not, and used it to varying extents. A whitewash of history is unfair, but to tar all peoples with the stain of slavery is, as well.
- clay_the_ripper 9y agoWhat exactly is your point? To me, statements like this are like “all lives matter”. Yes. We know. But we don’t need to point this out, because it’s just an undercover way of diminishing the point being made.
- travmatt 9y ago>don’t need to point this out, because it’s just an undercover way of diminishing the point being mad That’s the feature though, not a bug.
- MadSudaca 9y agoWhat about a statement such as "whites are responsible for slavery". It's true, but not all "whites" were responsible. I think a lot of people wouldn't bat an eye at this comment. However, at an individual level it seems unfair to me, since obviously not everyone that was qualified by the label "white" during slavery is responsible.
- krapp 9y ago>However, at an individual level it seems unfair to me, since obviously not everyone that was qualified by the label "white" during slavery is responsible. All white people as individuals were not responsible for slavery, and some even opposed it, but all still benefited from slavery by virtue of being born into the race, society and class that the slave system was designed to benefit. That is unfair, but nonetheless true.
- MadSudaca 9y ago> but all still benefited from slavery by virtue of being born into the race, society and class that the slave system was designed to benefit. This is false. Many benefited, true, but not all. And even if it was true, I don't see why people should be made responsible for the actions of others that under some definition are from their same "group", even if they benefited from them. This is collectivism/racism at its finest, it bothers me tremendously and I'm not even white.
- krapp 9y ago>This is false. Many benefited, true, but not all. There are indirect benefits and direct benefits to an unjust system - implicit as well as explicit power that comes from membership in a privileged class. Having legal rights and protections that other classes don't enjoy is a benefit. Being allowed to read, having autonomy over your own children, being able to walk freely, being allowed to maintain a connection to one's ancestors, religion and emigrant homeland... these are all benefits granted to white people as a group during slavery. > I don't see why people should be made responsible for the actions of others that under some definition are from their same "group", even if they benefited from them. Well... I did concede that they shouldn't, and weren't. But if one group of people are considered property, and another group of people are legally capable of owning the first, then the latter group benefits from that system if only because they aren't the former. It just happens that, at that time and place, the necessary selector for privilege was "whiteness." In another time, it might have been religion, or ethnicity or culture or following the wrong King. There were plenty of societies that practiced slavery that discriminated along many lines.
- aaron-lebo 9y agoBut these rights were not granted to entire groups of people during slavery. See how the Irish were treated both by the British and as immigrants to the US. They were seen as lesser. Irish Catholics and many other groups had no special place as immigrants, they didn't get positive points for not being African. That's the unfortunate truth with all forms of discrimination, it's hardly something limited by class, race or time.
- vhudud 9y agoWho is attacking white people here? Nobody is blaming all white people for slavery. At least not in this article or in the comments here. Maybe "whites are responsible for slavery" is a deceptive statement for all i know. But nobodys saying that.
- MadSudaca 9y agoTo me this is basically what the original commenter is saying, for which he was heavily downvoted.
- jm__87 9y agoWhile I understand the reason for the name of the Black Lives Matter movement, I can also understand why this phrase would annoy some people. When you say something as obviously true as "black lives matter", it invites people to ask the question of who must be disagreeing with this statement that we have to keep repeating it. Clearly this statement was intended for American law enforcement and I think it is very unfair to assume that any law enforcement officer would disagree with this statement unless there is no other explanation for their behavior. Do some law enforcement officers feel more threatened by black men than white men: this seems very likely given the number of innocent and unarmed black men who have been shot by police in recent years. While this means some police officers have a racial bias, it does not mean they think black lives don't matter. These officers who have shot unarmed black men think they are in a threatening situation and use way more force than is warranted, for which I agree they should still be prosecuted. While there are seemingly two issues here (racial bias and overuse of force), neither of these issues have to have anything to do with anyone believing black lives don't matter. Edit: of course I realize that another way to interpret the statement "black lives matter" is to see it as more of a slogan and a constant reminder to address the issue as opposed to an accusation that someone or some group of people thinks otherwise. The fact that this statement is open to alternative interpretations is a problem for this movement, though.
- vhudud 9y ago>Please do not throw the entire USA into the history of slavery Ummm... Are you serious? The economy of the early usa was heavily dependent on slavery. It has had a far reaching impact on our demography, our culture, and our politics to this day. Every american, even today, feels that impact.(black people are still facing discrimination, unequal treatment by police, generational poverty, and the lingering effects of white flight and urban decay) The existence of abolitionists alone does not erase the stain of slavery, as you say. You can't tell the story of America without slavery. And if youre american, its part of your history.
- patrickg_zill 9y agoCitation please, or at least a numeric definition of "heavily dependant".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- macintux 9y agohttp://www.wbur.org/hereandnow/2014/11/19/slavery-economy-baptist http://www.wbur.org/hereandnow/2014/11/19/slavery-economy-ba... https://www.gilderlehrman.org/content/historical-context-was-slavery-engine-american-economic-growth https://www.gilderlehrman.org/content/historical-context-was... Just a couple of references I found with a quick search.
- patrickg_zill 9y agoYour first link has exactly zero value in determining the economic value of contributions. Your second link has this paragraph "The answer is "0"; slavery did not create a major share of the capital that financed the European industrial revolution. The combined profits of the slave trade and West Indian plantations did not add up to five percent of Britain's national income at the time of the industrial revolution." So I am confused about what I am supposed to take away from the links you gave.