6 ms·
This outcome is in a particularly distorted badly operated market, one where for no very good reasons regulatory power is not being applied, and distorted biddi
by ggm 9y ago
This outcome is in a particularly distorted badly operated market, one where for no very good reasons regulatory power is not being applied, and distorted bidding for FCAS and peak supply has been the norm. It's hugely politicised, and in the context of a rejection of carbon trading and an attempt by the ruling federal liberal-national government to wedge coal into the mix (it's basically uneconomic now, and won't get any better but the lib hats want it come what may)
The battery couldn't have come at a better time. It's an initiative of a state labor government, now tossed out, and it's signals how much could have been achieved with decent capital investment in alternative power sources. That said, it's role here is frequency stabilisation not power: it's a tiny percentage of the states power burden. The states solar and wind was (alas) not required to have any associated storage capacity or supply FCAS services, both things which alter the economics in favour of more traditional coal, and gas peaked power supply.
There are more batteries on the way. There are pumped hydro systems in design. Things are getting better.
- krl02 9y agoLife is hugely politicized We think we’re boxing it off from that but if you look closer, through the abstract nonsense people peddle, you’ll see it comes down to a political yes/no process You’re welcome to pretend otherwise. I’d rather just dispense with the notion life is anything but dialog back and forth, jockeying for acceptance and access into some clique or the “right” to build useful infra
- jgord 9y agoYou comment seems to suggest there is some rational decision making emerging from an open back-n-forth of facts and ideas. I wish that were the case, but the simplest explanation of political reality both in AUS and USA is that our leaders owe favors to a few very rich people, in fact work for them.
- ggm 9y agoCan you explain in this model, how any useful bipartisan investment happened, in the past wartime expediency aside? I think its true this has always been a dimension of things, but the scale of this dimension set against other dimensions has substantially changed in the last two decades. Before this, there were some things that both (notional) sides were prepared to express some unanimity on. For example: "soviet power plus electricity == socialism" did not actually stop anyone of a more rightist persuasion from investing in electic generation.. did it?
- azernik 9y agoBipartisan consensus is also a political process.
- ggm 9y agoYes. One which is increasingly absent from western electoral democratic process. Oppositional politics is currently the preferred model even though it wedges capital investment in infrastructure. Are you bringing anything to this conversation or just trying to win an argument here?
- azernik 9y agokrl02 made the point that all these things are political processes. You brought up the example of past bipartisan investments as a counterargument; my understanding of your point was "we've had bipartisan consensus on investments before, therefore there wasn't a political process going on around that". I was pointing out that this also is a political process, and that krl02's model of economic decision-making as a political process still stands. Were you trying to make some other point instead?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ggm 9y agoAll these things are political processes, but one is a trend which has swept the world. Oppositional politics has swept the world, and is impeding capital investment in public works, because it reduces to a high-tax/low-tax argument and favours low-tax reductionism, over state capital works. I was trying to make the point that if (like me) you want capital works, and national utility project investment, you don't want oppositional politics, you want the other model. I am not in denial that there is another, or other models. We had more overt bipartisan politics over a number of important things like housing, defence policy, capital works. We have gone to a more oppositional model even though this means less public utility outcomes happen.
- spodek 9y ago> This outcome is in a particularly distorted badly operated market, one where for no very good reasons regulatory power is not being applied . . . You described most energy markets on the planet.
- boyter 9y agoIt’s particularly bad in Australia and South Australia where this battery is was the worst. Australia despite having abundant reserves of coal, gas and uranium as well as excellent solar and wind locations has some of their most expensive electricity prices in the world.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jazoom 9y agoThis is true and it blows my mind. It also makes me sad. We have some really smart and educated people in this country. What's the problem here?
- stephen_g 9y agoMostly the Coalition. Seriously. It’s clear from the AEMO market makeup etc. that almost all the cost increase was attributable to the cost of gas (due to Santos having contracts to export more gas than they had supply for to Japan etc., while the international gas price has fallen. So they are sucking up gas on the domestic market pushing up domestic prices and their liquefication operation is unprofitable anyway). But the Coalition instead chose to use the cost of electricity as a political tool in a bizarre anti-renewables push. Economists have suggested that a large enough gas reservation policy (like WA has) would rectify that. The LNP could legislate it in a few weeks at worst. This would also benefit industrial gas users that have been struggling with big increases. A more minor part (like what this battery is helping to stop) is the privatised generators gaming the market by constraining supply artificially to push up prices at certain high-demand times. Some of this also naturally happens with some of the older coal stations tripping out and falling off for a few hours (I think Liddel is only achieving something like 46% capacity on average or something?).
- acidburnNSA 9y agoGreat and important points, thank you. Regarding pumped storage, I recently discovered some studies pointing out the potentially massive greenhouse impact of certain reservoirs that we must keep in mind. http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0161947 http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal....
- pbreit 9y agoI’m confused. Is it 90% savings vs regular power (awesome) or 90% vs “emergency” power (ok)?
- ggm 9y agoIt's 90% cheaper bids into a frequency stability service. It corrects for drift from 50hz. It doesn't supply power in that sense, it supplies a slightly out of phase AC to refocus the frequency back to where it should be. It does it inside milliseconds of a drift and prevents overreaction by other generators with synchronous power, and can do it more often for less "cost" (synchronous flywheel systems lose most of their power reserve reacting, and have to be recharged over a longer and more costly period. A battery is really ideal for this frequency adjustment service)
- agumonkey 9y agoSo tesla power station acts like a nationwide super cap ?
- tripletao 9y agoIn what sense doesn't it supply power? If demand for power exceeds supply, then the frequency starts to go down. "Maintaining frequency" and "supplying the demanded power" are two different expressions of the same problem.
- goodcanadian 9y agoIf the frequency goes down, the battery supplies power to the grid as you say. If the frequency goes up, the battery absorbs excess power from the grid. On net, it doesn't supply anything.
- paulsutter 9y agoAncillary services like frequency stabilization are the highest ROI application of batteries in the grid and nothing to sneeze at. Without batteries, transmission and especially distribution need to be sized to the highest momentary spikes in demand, and given the long lead time and high costs to upgrade these facilities, batteries are a great solution. They can respond instantly and solve the problem at a very low cost. As for storing power overnight, batteries are on a similar manufacturing learning curve* as photovoltaic, albeit a few years behind. Most people thought PV could never be cost effective, until suddenly it was the cheapest. Batteries too will surprise the doubters. It's just a matter of time before batteries are more cost-effective than pumped hydro. *Moore's law-style cost reductions were first observed in airplane manufacturing in 1936. Cost of manufacturing decreases with the volume produced: http://www.uvm.edu/~pdodds/research/papers/others/1936/wright1936a.pdf http://www.uvm.edu/~pdodds/research/papers/others/1936/wrigh...
- ggm 9y agoThe particularly distorted quality of the Australian energy marketplace, distinct from all the other worldwide markets which I absolutely acknowledge are, in their own terms, equally distorted, but the quality here, is the drop in the FCAS service bid by 90%, for what we have to call better frequency stability: The battery responds faster, and there is significantly less visible perturbation to frequency stability, and it does it 9x cheaper than the prior market driven process. How good is that!
- arbitrary_name 9y agoMandating storage or fcas capability for new developments is not the solution, as it would make such developments more expensive and less appetising to developers. Strengthening the market for those services and working with AEMO to drive the networks or third parties to provide these services is the better option in my opinion. The recent rule changes for 5 minute settlements in the wholesale spot markets will also alter the financial incentives for very fast start generation and drive investment in battery storage, perhaps even in the residential market.
- ggm 9y agoI don't agree that mandated storage or fcas would reduce investment: FCAS capability is mandated in other economies, which are powering ahead with offering it. There are many other sources of cost and risk exposure which outweigh this one. Otherwise, I agree with what you say. Power investment is not 'oh well, I'll put it into fish oil instead' money, these are firms who specialize in this niche and who are looking to invest in this niche. The lack of government commitment to PV and wind is a bigger threat to them than a requirement to spend more capital including storage and frequency supply logic.
- _o_ 9y agoIf I understood correctly, they are using batteries in same manner as pumped storage: https://www.energy.gov/eere/water/pumped-storage-hydropower https://www.energy.gov/eere/water/pumped-storage-hydropower We have a few of those for decades, it is actually quite simple, when there is surplus of el. energy it is used to pump water on a hill and acumulate it there. When you need it, the water is than used to generate el. energy. This is the traditional way of flattening the spikes in el. grid. Now I wonder why the batteries were choosen instead of water, are they cheaper? Does it acumulate more energy on less space than water, it is due to efficiency (there is some loss when you pump water up) or for Austrialia, the water based storage is just not an option (not enough water / hills)?
- icebraining 9y ago(Warning: I have zero expertise on this) Apparently there's an argument about that, since there's a plan to upgrade the Snowy Hydro pumped storage system, but it'll cost $2B and it couldn't be done in 100 days like the Tesla installation. The other advantage seems to be that the battery can respond very quickly (0.14s), so it's still useful to avoid instability in the network.
- zik 9y agoThey're not using it in the same manner as pumped storage. They're using it for millisecond level FCAS response. Turbines can't do that very well.