4 ms·
Just to play along, the book deals with this. They aren't necessarily in unhabitable zones - although some are and basically convert to Mars colonies. As for s
by komali2 9y ago
Just to play along, the book deals with this. They aren't necessarily in unhabitable zones - although some are and basically convert to Mars colonies.
As for specialization, plenty of doctors "went Walkaway," and if you don't have a doctor present, you make do with a life video chat with a whole host of them as a local body performs whatever thing needs doing.
You're not gonna get brain surgery sure, but you can get a leg set.
- pjc50 9y ago> Mars colonies. These of course will have to be the least libertarian-adaptable environments; anywhere where survival is a collective endeavour and one idiot can ruin it for everyone will be extremely rule-bound. Look at the Arctic bases for an example.
- komali2 9y agoNot the book's thesis - by the time the walkaways have started forming communities in harsh enough environments to require environmental suits to go outside, the only ones making their way to these communities are the "already indoctrinated." Earlier in the book, we see what happens to "bad actors." For example, a meritocratic bad actor shows up as a newbie at a bed and breakfast that's at a popular crossroads. After hanging around for a bit, he starts trying to put up leaderboards tracking who's making the most code commits, who's taking out the most trash, who's cooking the most meals, that kind of thing. Other people don't like this because they have evidence of it causing other communities to go sour or outright disintegrate, so they revert his changes. Revert wars go down, huge discussion threads, think like the sort of stuff that caused that weird Node fork years ago. Anyway, he gets frustrated realizing nobody wants things his way, and leaves. He comes back months later with a little troop of like-minded people, uses force to take over the codebase of the Bed and Breakfast, puts up his leaderboards. Some of the original developers turn up, he says they're welcome in because of how much work they'd done. Instead, they pitch a tent outside, and say "tomorrow, we're going to head north, and build a new bed and breakfast up the road." By the morning, nearly the entire population has joined the original group, and the malcontents are abandoned once again. Hence the title of "walkaways." Back to the original point - that very malcontent can be found in the mars-esque base of a poisonous city, but he's now indoctrinated to the walkaway culture. Having seen firsthand "the way," he doesn't "act up." The thesis is pulled from Japan - why is crime so low? Mostly culture, is the common answer. As walkaways of this type don't exist right now, we can only hypothesize how it would actually go down, which is exactly what the author is doing, pulling from examples from hippie communes, communist groups, anarchist groups, wikis, the free software community, hacker groups, and for the converse, what the author calls "zotta-rich" and those living in "default," examples from banana republics, rampant corruption in plutocracies like Russia and the United States, copyright enforcement actions, etc. It really is an interesting book, I highly recommend it.
- walterbell 9y agoThanks for the pointer to this Cory Doctorow book, https://www.npr.org/2017/04/27/523587179/in-walkaway-a-blueprint-for-a-new-weird-but-better-world https://www.npr.org/2017/04/27/523587179/in-walkaway-a-bluep... > By my own (admittedly poor) math, it presents roughly ten thousand new, mind-bending and ground-breaking ideas per page. There are words in here that only otherwise exist in insular pockets of the maker/hacker/open source/thingiverse sub-sub-culture. In terms of its geek heroism, epic, generational scope and high stakes (only the survival of the human race, after all, and possibly the cure for death), the only literary comparison I can make is to Neal Stephenson's hard science disaster masterpiece, Seveneves, but Walkaway is more human. More squishy and close to home.