3 ms·
Do NYC residents look at the subway as something only poor people use? Honest question, I don’t live there. I don’t consider “associating with the poors” to be
by ryandrake 9y ago
Do NYC residents look at the subway as something only poor people use? Honest question, I don’t live there. I don’t consider “associating with the poors” to be an impediment at all.
What stops me from using mass transit (including bus and rail service) is that its schedule in my town is totally inadequate. Stops are not frequent enough, service starts too late in the morning and ends too early at night, and travel time to most destinations is slower than by car. Fix these major problems and I happily use transit.
- marnett 9y agoMost residents of NYC use the subway, at least for long distances - it's simply the cheapest and fastest way for a large majority of routes throughout the city. The socioeconomic spread is large; granted, I'm sure the wealthy with their door-to-door black car service probably think it is still for "the poor."
- zaphoyd 9y agoNot sure about NYC, but there are absolutely people in Chicago and Milwaukee who will call a rideshare (or insist that they pick up/be picked up by family) even though there is a city bus that goes literally directly door to door and the vehicle is sitting there ready to leave in a few minutes. It is depressing. Anecdotally it is much worse in cases where the bus in question passes through areas where non-affluent white people will be getting on and off.
- PhasmaFelis 9y ago> Do NYC residents look at the subway as something only poor people use? Honest question, I don’t live there. I don’t consider “associating with the poors” to be an impediment at all. It varies depending on the size of the city, in my experience. NYC might be the most egalitarian city in America regarding public transit use. Other large cities are similar or slightly less so. In small cities, it's very much considered a low-income thing.
- cimmanom 9y ago> Do NYC residents look at the subway as something only poor people use? No, but subway funding and management is controlled by the state, not the city -- and the majority of residents of the state do not use transit. I get the impression that a lot of people in the state still think of NYC as the crumbling inner city of the 70's: the place where poor people live. The governor is more interested in optics ("Now you can charge your phone on the bus! We replaced the tiles in this subway station!") than restoring service, let alone expansion. He has diverted funds from the subways to, among other things, pretty light shows on bridges and supporting failing upstate ski resorts. With the subways failing, those who can afford to are taking cabs and black cars more and more, which contributes to the traffic congestion crisis. The mayor gets driven everywhere in a black SUV and seems to have never learned that not only to most of his constituents not commute in personal vehicles, the majority don't even own cars. Additionally, the city has a LOT of public buses. In some ways (frequency, coverage), bus service in the city is much better than most of the rest of the country. In other ways, it's unusably bad (mostly, time to get from A to B due to traffic, too-frequent stops, silly winding routes, slow payment/boarding, overcrowding, inufficiently frequent service outside rush hour, bus bunching decreasing apparent/useful service frequency). The NIMBYs and traffic enforcers all seem to believe that bus riders are "not us" (and yes, outside of a few crosstown corridors, bus riders average poorer than subway riders). The result is obstacles to the creation of bus lanes and busways, and utter lack of enforcement of those we do have.