4 ms·
Not necessarily. Big corporations actually depend on the State for their very existence, and leverage corruption, regulatory capture, etc., to grow larger and m
by mindcrime 9y ago
Not necessarily. Big corporations actually depend on the State for their very existence, and leverage corruption, regulatory capture, etc., to grow larger and more powerful than they would naturally.
- rayiner 9y agoThat's a common view, but I don't think the evidence supports it. What "corruption" and "regulatory capture" did Amazon or Google leverage in coming to dominate multiple verticals? Instead, I think technology is the culprit. Technology pushes out the boundary where economies of scale give way to diseconomies of scale. Mom & pops can't compete with Amazon not because Amazon has a few senators in its pocket. They can't do it because Amazon's immense scale (multiple robotic warehouses, in-house shipping and logistics expertise, etc.) makes it impossible to compete on price and quality.
- _jal 9y agoCapture and corruption doesn't help small startups become big[1]. They help big companies stay big. I think you're right that Google and Amazon (and others) leveraged something new - the catalog-sales and cat-video dynamo we call the internet - to get where they are. And I think I'm right that they will increasingly leverage government to stay big now that they are. [1] You might say 'Uber' in response; I'd say the company was corrupt and failed to find sufficient exploitable government levers to succeed in those efforts, because someone else got to those levers first.
- root_axis 9y ago> And I think I'm right that they will increasingly leverage government to stay big now that they are. IMO that's not a convincing argument. Your response to two specific counter-examples is "one day you'll see that those examples actually prove my point instead of yours"
- _jal 9y agoThat's nice. If you'd like to convince me I'm wrong, you'll have to explain why these companies, which are subject to the same pressures as others and hire from the same pool of execs, will behave differently than the rest of the herd of large public firms. If you want to argue they'll lobby, manipulate and bribe less than average among peer-firms, well, that argument could be made. But if you want to argue that there's something special about them that means they won't play all the same games, perhaps start with explaining how Amazon's begging-for-handouts HQ tour is different than the sports stadium scam.
- rayiner 9y ago> If you want to argue they'll lobby, manipulate and bribe less than average among peer-firms, well, that argument could be made. You’re begging the question by assuming that this conduct is what keeps “peer firms” big. That’s the point in dispute. I’d say that there is good reason to believe why that isn’t true. Walmart spent just $7 million on lobbying last year. It’s a company with $500 billion in revenue. Does it make logical sense to infer that the $7 million in lobbying is what keeps the $500 billion spigot flowing? Much smaller competitors could out-lobby Walmart, raising the market price of corruption. Why doesn’t that happen—with hundreds of billions of dollars on the line? People take as a shibboleth that lobbying is corruption and corruption keeps big companies big. But that flies in the face of the actual data.
- _jal 9y agoThis is obviously a pretty pointless back-and-forth. You're attempting to treat lobbying as a binary. Does it make logical sense that Walmart would spend $7M if it didn't feel that investment had a return? Of course large companies are buoyed by other factors. But as congress-critters famously pointed out a while back, Silicon Valley had to learn to lobby. And they did, otherwise Bad Things could happen. Also, > People take as a shibboleth I don't know what tribe you're trying to make me a member of, but, uh, no. > But that flies in the face of the actual data If you're talking about the gap between $7m and $.5T, that dataoid demonstrates nothing other than that multinational retailers operate much larger firms than politicians do. My question stands: how is AZON playing a different game than they various sportball leagues?
- rayiner 9y agoHow about Apple, Microsoft, Walmart, and IBM? Does Apple stay big due to regulatory capture, or because its massive size allows them to create a supply chain nobody else can match?
- bantunes 9y agoOne can consider that status quo as their infancy period. Once they're big enough, they'll be able to exist and thrive without corporate welfare. "Of the world's 100 largest economic entities, 51 are now corporations and 49 are countries." according to http://www.corporations.org/system/top100.html http://www.corporations.org/system/top100.html