7 ms·
Simple answer: No. More nuanced answer: not exactly. Not Capitalism per-se anyway. But clearly you can see an unhealthy degree of commingling of big governme
by mindcrime 9y ago
Simple answer: No.
More nuanced answer: not exactly. Not Capitalism per-se anyway. But clearly you can see an unhealthy degree of commingling of big government and big business, in a way that is damaging to society at large. But to my mind:
a. that's corruption, not capitalism
b. that's an argument against big government, not an argument against capitalism
- ShorsHammer 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
- gameswithgo 9y agoIn the absence of big government, big corporate will become defacto government even more easily.
- misja111 9y agoI guess you mean in the absence of any government. Neither big government nor anarchy is good for democracy, but there is a whole range in between.
- rjbwork 9y agoAlong that logic could we say that absolute private property rights nor the complete absence of exclusive use of capital goods is good for democracy, but that there is a whole range in between? It's not immediately obvious to me that either is true in terms of producing viable societies, but as these are the primary axes which determine how a society is going to function, it seems they ought to both be or neither be.
- erikpukinskis 9y agoYou’re right it’s either/or at a given scale. But if you think in terms of multiscale, the difference between systems stops looking so qualitative and looks more quantitative: Either you have an absolute property law system, and a limited commons forms on top of that through land trusts, etc. Or you have an absolute communist system, and a limited free market forms on top of that, within a system of exceptions and exemptions. Technically you could implement identical 50/50 socialized/private systems in both of those schemes. In practice scale matters so which system runs which scale will affect the outcome. But the long term outcome will inevitably be “the right things are socialized and the right things are privatized”... the two systems each do experiments and make concessions when they lose. They’ll end up being quite the same, although in the short term they are quite different. And we need both to exist to run all the experiments.
- mschuster91 9y agoActually, we see this with the social media giants live in action: they may decide to terminate your account at any time for arbitrary (or none at all) reasons for your whole life, and you have no way of legal recourse. There have been way too many stories alone on HN about people losing e.g. their entire mail archives or Youtube deleting evidence videos of war crimes, to let this situation continue for any longer. Government needs to finally recognize the importance of social media to modern society... after all, telcos are not allowed to arbitrarily cut you off (especially not for life!). Why should social media be treated differently?
- seanp2k2 9y agoTelcos can’t cut you off, but ISPs can. I guess dial up is potentially still an option, but internet access is much more relevant than telephone access in 2018.
- mschuster91 9y ago> Telcos can’t cut you off, but ISPs can. Well, ISPs are replaceable (okay, they will offer different speeds). Get cut off, select another ISP (or mobile data). A telco is not easily replaceable though, as the phone number is your unique handle that often cannot be changed easily (which is why you have the right to keep your number in Europe across providers)...
- xg15 9y ago> Get cut off, select another ISP (or mobile data). Comcast customers would like to have a word with you.
- sli 9y agoYeah, that particular point is technically true, but in reality it is absolutely false. Far too many people simply do not have competing options. ADSL and satellite are not really competing options if your third option is fiber. I'd say it's reasonable these days to expect regular people (especially the 18-34 demo) to actually rely on the speeds you get with fiber. ADSL and satellite, by comparison, are slow as molasses. A number of those folks could probably survive with a mobile data hotspot, but that is really not ideal for a house or apartment.
- baddox 9y agoI don’t think that’s necessarily true. Government is unique because of its “social license” to govern, meaning that the vast majority of people recognize its authority to do things other people or groups cannot do (like make laws, imprison people, or collect taxes). Corporations don’t have that social license, which is why they need to cozy up with government to take advantage of that unique authority.
- kahnpro 9y agoWithout a government they can start to take this authority themselves in much the same way that local warlords do. Gradually by force, because they have power and you don't. A small / weak government can't do anything to stop them.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoSmall != weak. Did the US have a large government in 1900? Certainly not by the standards of today. Yet it was still able to take on Standard Oil.
- monocasa 9y agoCorporations are more than happy to take on that mantle if they are able. You saw that with the East India Company's full army and navy, you saw that with company mining towns that issued their own currency and controlled every aspect of their employees lives, you saw that with the Pinkertons investigating and dispatching extrajudicial punishment, and you see that today with Nestle paramilitaries.
- mindcrime 9y agoNot necessarily. Big corporations actually depend on the State for their very existence, and leverage corruption, regulatory capture, etc., to grow larger and more powerful than they would naturally.
- rayiner 9y agoThat's a common view, but I don't think the evidence supports it. What "corruption" and "regulatory capture" did Amazon or Google leverage in coming to dominate multiple verticals? Instead, I think technology is the culprit. Technology pushes out the boundary where economies of scale give way to diseconomies of scale. Mom & pops can't compete with Amazon not because Amazon has a few senators in its pocket. They can't do it because Amazon's immense scale (multiple robotic warehouses, in-house shipping and logistics expertise, etc.) makes it impossible to compete on price and quality.
- _jal 9y agoCapture and corruption doesn't help small startups become big[1]. They help big companies stay big. I think you're right that Google and Amazon (and others) leveraged something new - the catalog-sales and cat-video dynamo we call the internet - to get where they are. And I think I'm right that they will increasingly leverage government to stay big now that they are. [1] You might say 'Uber' in response; I'd say the company was corrupt and failed to find sufficient exploitable government levers to succeed in those efforts, because someone else got to those levers first.
- root_axis 9y ago> And I think I'm right that they will increasingly leverage government to stay big now that they are. IMO that's not a convincing argument. Your response to two specific counter-examples is "one day you'll see that those examples actually prove my point instead of yours"
- _jal 9y agoThat's nice. If you'd like to convince me I'm wrong, you'll have to explain why these companies, which are subject to the same pressures as others and hire from the same pool of execs, will behave differently than the rest of the herd of large public firms. If you want to argue they'll lobby, manipulate and bribe less than average among peer-firms, well, that argument could be made. But if you want to argue that there's something special about them that means they won't play all the same games, perhaps start with explaining how Amazon's begging-for-handouts HQ tour is different than the sports stadium scam.
- nickik 9y agoWe are not talking about an absence of govenremnt. A small government is perfectly able to regulated what is needed to regulate. It is an absolutle isllusion to believe that only a big government can correctly regulated cooperations. In fact, I would argue there is little corrulation either way, both big and small govenrment sometimes have effective laws. The ability to regulated derives from a monopoly on violence, not control of 50% of the economy.
- jcims 9y agoI think the confusion is conflating size, or maybe more precisely 'scope', with power.
- nickik 9y agoExactly. I think its false to assume that a government that directly taxes 60% of all incomes is more effective law maker then a government who taxes 10% of all income is a flase assumtion.
- brobdingnagians 9y agoAs one of the other posters mentioned, big government _helps_ create big corporations. Even the legal idea of a "corporation" with the corporate veil to protect employees & those who control it from direct liability enables mega-corporations. If we simply eliminated corporate legal entities, we might have more careful business dealings. In the absence of this idea, you'd be free to take legal action against someone who harms you. It is a similar thing with the EPA and FDA, if a corporation meets their requirements, you can't sue them, even if they are polluting your town. It actually _enables_ a legal limit that they can pollute rather than strictly reducing pollution. The most effective anti-littering campaign was the Keep America Beautiful, Crying Indian campaign, not really the EPA. A lot of this has to do with culture, if people aren't okay with big corporations and corruption, then they would do something different. But on a certain level, people don't really care or believe that corporate entities somehow help the economy. Two-hundred years ago, the culture was different and people made things go a bit differently; the culture we have now generally supports corporate and governmental power.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- acdha 9y ago> It is a similar thing with the EPA and FDA, if a corporation meets their requirements, you can't sue them, even if they are polluting your town. Do you have a citation for that? States, cities, and individuals sue all the time. Saying you met the federal standards may be part of the defense but it’s not immunity.
- dragonwriter 9y agoCorporations are creatures of government; big corporate power is big government.
- panarky 9y agoA fish doesn't know it's in water because it never experienced anything else. Can we imagine anything other than the system we live in? I suppose we can imagine small adjustments like higher or lower taxation, more or less regulation, increasing or decreasing subsidies for different groups. But that's like slightly changing the temperature or salinity of the water we're swimming in. It doesn't help us imagine what walking through air would be like.
- ryandrake 9y ago“We live in capitalism. Its power seems inescapable. So did the divine right of kings. Any human power can be resisted and changed by human beings.” - Ursula Le Guin
- tomohawk 9y agoThe trust busters in the early 20th century were not part of a big government. You need an effective government, not a big government to police corruption. As the government has balooned in size, trust busting has become almost non existent. Corruption these days just gets a yawn.
- vollmond 9y ago"Corporatism" and "Crony-capitalism" are more accurate names I've heard for what we have.
- MereInterest 9y ago>b. that's an argument against big government, not an argument against capitalism A government that is not large enough to upset an even playing field will also not be large enough to level an uneven playing field.
- nickik 9y agoFalse. A government power derives from its monopoly of violence not from the size of its budget. There is litte correlation between the size of a govenrment and its ability to regulate.
- xg15 9y agoAre there sources for that claim?
- nickik 9y agoI don't know of any nice rankings on these things but I also can't see why it should be the case. If you have the monopoly of violence you can tell a company to do X and if they don't you can punish them. Of course it depends on the size of your population/market, if you are small, a company can just leave the country rather then comply. However that is equally true for a small country with powerful government.
- AKrumbach 9y agoThis argument seems to subtly imply that the only efficacious means to "level an uneven playing field" is government regulation, and not some other, non-government process such as boycotts. Government regulation is, ultimately, only one item in the civic toolbox of society. If it turns out this is flawed, and will in the long run generate more negative outcomes than positive ones, abandoning the tool does not mean abandoning the final goal. Instead, we must utilize alternate means of achieving the same ends... or accept that corruption as the price of our chosen path.
- quadrangle 9y ago
- aggie 9y ago> a. that's corruption, not capitalism This is the same logic used by people who argue "That's corruption, not socialism." If everywhere there is capitalism, there is corruption, you can't simply wave it away. Edit: I originally asked "How is this argument different from 'that's corruption, not socialism'", which some seemed to interpret as a defense of socialism. I'm just pointing out the flawed logic in both arguments.
- baddox 9y ago> How is this any different from people who argue "That's corruption, not socialism"? It’s not at all different. In fact, state socialism and state capitalism are extremely similar systems.
- hayd 9y agoThe lack of forced labor camps or worse, the existence of a free press which can expose corruption, mean these systems are not extremely similar...
- srean 9y agoWhere may I find this 'free press' that you mention ?
- billbrown 9y agoIf by "state capitalism" you mean the New Deal, Mussolini's fascism, or postwar UK then I'd agree with you entirely.
- maym86 9y agoThis. People supporting capitalism alway seem to argue that any abuses of power and corruption are exceptions. The system is built on competition so without strong regulation it seems inevitable that people will take shortcuts to win.
- knubie 9y agoIt isn't, really. Socialism just seems to be far more susceptible corruption than capitalism does, if historical data is anything to go by.
- TaylorAlexander 9y agoSome have argued, however, that this commingling is caused by the forces of capitalism. Once you have large profits, it makes sense to direct some of them towards altering the laws in your favor. Simultaneously, capitalism seems to encourage the kind of concentration of wealth that will always ensure some capitalists have large profits relative to the norm of society. So in many ways this commingling ends up being inevitable.
- mindcrime 9y agoSome have argued, however, that this commingling is caused by the forces of capitalism True, but personally I remain unconvinced by those arguments. It gets complicated though, because a lot of people (implicitly or explicitly) equate "capitalism" and "corporations". But in reality, capitalism doesn't require corporations and corporations require the State. A capitalist economy without corporations (which break the link between actions and liability for the consequences of those actions) would very likely be a much different thing.
- jerf 9y agoI agree that there is a lot of inevitability in this result. This is often a debate in the implicit context of "we should make the government even stronger, probably socialism or communism", but in those cases instead of two entities who at least sometimes struggle for power, we're just giving up and giving all the power to one entity. So, if the problem is that corporations and governments tend to get too close to each other, what exactly is the nominally-better solution that we're supposed to be comparing against? What if this is already just about the best we could hope for? It does sometimes seem to me that people have this implicit idea of a world in which, basically, nobody has any power, or everybody has the exact same amount to an arbitrary number of decimal places, but even by the standards of Utopianism, that's Utopian. What, exactly, is the goal of this conversation? It'll differ for different people, of course, but it's still a valid exercise. There is a lot of "1. Identify problem. 2. Propose solution. 3. Fail to observe that proposed solution couldn't possibly have solved original problem, even if it worked as designed." (For another example, see the last few mass shootings, and the subsequent proposed "solutions"; without reference to whether or not they would be good idea and whether or not more gun control is good or bad, it was frequently the case that even if the proposed solutions were in place and perfectly, unrealistically functional prior to the incident that the solution still wouldn't have prevented the event, e.g., "more background checks" that the shooter still would have passed, etc.)
- JetSetWilly 9y agoThis is a bit similar to claiming that communism is great, because all the times when it was tried and there were problems weren't real communism. If capitalism tends to inevitably lead to corruption of government and the undermining of democracy etc in the long run, then that's an interesting critique, which can't just be swatted away with "yes but the result isn't capitalism".
- mindcrime 9y agoIf capitalism tends to inevitably lead to corruption of government That's a pretty big if.
- JetSetWilly 9y agoYes it is - but my point is that it is a reasonable discussion to have, and any attempt to avoid even having the discussion by saying "oh it isn't my theoretical pure capitalism" doesn't work.
- s2g 9y agoIt's absolutely true.
- Clubber 9y agoI would argue capitalism (or any economic system really) always corrupts government, it's just a matter of degree. Farmer A gives free goats (or his daughter in marriage) to farmer B who is in charge of allocating newly acquired tribal farmland. Farmer A gets a good, fertile pasture with a stream, farmer Z might get a bunch of rocky hillside.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mpweiher 9y ago> If capitalism tends to inevitably lead to corruption of government Everything tends to lead to corruption of government, in fact most forms of government are the corruption we see as the problem here. The key point of liberal democracy is to put mechanisms in place to prevent this from happening.
- pastor_bob 9y agoSounds like a "No True Capitalism" defense to me. Capitalism, like all other systems, can't exist in a vacuum. You must consider the human factor and the likelihoods it will produce.
- ForRealsies 9y agoI'd take "No True Capitalism" over "No True Communism" any day.
- athenot 9y agoCorruption is just the free market between those who have power but (relatively) no wealth, and those who have wealth but (relatively) no power. It's treating power and influence as just another asset that can be purchased (with wealth).
- rizzom5000 9y agoThose who have power can freely take wealth e.g. taxation but those who have wealth cannot freely take power. Corrupt politicians might treat power as a free market commodity; but that's still corruption and not a market.
- spiralx 9y ago> Corrupt politicians might treat power as a free market commodity; but that's still corruption and not a market. A might treat B as a market commodity, but that's not a market. What does make a market then, if not having commodities in a market?
- quadrangle 9y agoA market is any situation where people come together to trade. There's nothing in the definition that requires it be commodity trading specifically.
- athenot 9y agoYes I'm not defending the market, just calling it out.
- vertexFarm 9y agoI think that to be at all fair we should treat the side-effects of capitalism as capitalism, just as we treat the side-effects of communism as communism. When we see that communist regimes have famines and vast imprisonments and corrupt party leaders stealing from the people, we correctly identify that as one of the realities of communism which stems from the impossibility of making communism work within the confines of human nature. When it's the inevitable effects of capitalism, we deny it. We say, "Oh no, that's not pure capitalism, they aren't practicing real capitalism, they're corrupt." It IS an effect of capitalism in every case. Where else is this coming from? Powerful entities in capitalist societies capture regulatory bodies and political figures and force them to enact policies which are harmful to common people yet benefit their bottom line. It's intellectually dishonest to say that all of a sudden it isn't capitalism so capitalist ideology isn't at fault. We have been driven by capitalist ideology every step of the way up to this, but the instant something bad happens then the definitions suddenly change and capitalism is insulated from harm. Let's not be in denial and say that yes, capitalism per-se is to blame. There comes a point when capitalism is bad for free society and democracy. Does that mean that we have to enact the exact opposite? No. Let's not have a false dichotomy. We need to realize that pure capitalist ideology doesn't work due to human nature in exactly the same way that pure communist ideology doesn't work. We need a strong and effective system to suppress certain parts of the capitalist ideology or we will perish.
- mindcrime 9y agoWhen it's the inevitable effects of capitalism, we deny it I haven't seen any proof that there are any "inevitable" effects of capitalism. Certainly we can't take the existence of these effects that you are referring to as a given.
- haZard_OS 9y agoWould you say that you haven't seen any proof that there are "inevitable" effects of (attempts at) communism?
- vertexFarm 9y agoHave we had any examples of capitalism that didn't produce corruption? I feel like once again you're using different standards for evidence for the two systems. We see the awful effects of communism each and every time and we correctly attribute it to communism. But suddenly there's a need for negative proof with capitalism. We can't be sure because we haven't seen every single permutation where it might be possible. But this systemic corruption exist in each real instance so far. But we don't know if it's strictly "inevitable." Do you see how that is bad reasoning? Do you see how that isn't falsifiable? It also stands to reason that this is inherent in capitalism. If you have complete freedom to purchase anything in the market, can you not see a situation where, without outside control, a successful party will have the opportunity to use capital to seize the system itself and change it to suit their needs above others? It stops being lassis-faire at that point. What about capitalism is meant to prevent that from happening? There's no inherent safeguard to keep it from developing that problem. If you want a good system, you have to look at it honestly. You can't be in denial and keep giving it a benefit of a doubt just to protect the system instead of the people living within it. The system exists for a purpose, not of its own merit. It needs modification in the same way that all systems need modification. Any creation of humankind can be improved, and one of the advantages of our kind is that we have reason and agency to continually improve. The danger lies in ossifying and exalting a system as flawless the way we do with capitalism.
- pishpash 9y agoNo. You're confusing the free market economy (a mechanism) vs. capitalism (a political economical system). Competition leads inevitably to monopoly as the best and the winners prevail and entrench in political power, that's the central contradiction built into capitalism. You can't separate one from the other if you want capitalism. This is the classical Marxist critique.
- mindcrime 9y agoColloquially, "capitalism" and "free market capitalism" are used interchangeably. I understand the strict distinction, but in this context I don't think descending to that level of pedantry is really necessary.
- nickik 9y ago> Competition leads inevitably to monopoly This old marxist critique has been disproved over and over. It has been show that it does not even make sense in marxes own theoretical system. That why marx has no credibilty in economcis, his own theoretical system does not make sense. Marx himself had known this, and that's why he never published the second and third volume of 'Das Kapital'. Engels in a attempted to save Marx bacon made a competition where he asked people if the could find a solution (rather predict what Marxes eventual solution would be) and nobody found on. That is why Marx was obandend by economist in the first place. Since then we have also seen complete destruction of Marxist argument because of empirce, there is no inherent invetable centralisation, rather process that goes in different direction depend on many factors.
- ravenstine 9y agoIt's not even just capitalism. Human behavior itself can be a threat to democracy. Honestly, I don't know what the author is talking about when they say "free market" in the present tense. The U.S. economy and the global economy aren't even close to being a free market.
- malka 9y agoimo, capitalism leads to oligopoly. oligopoly leads to corruption. Capitalism can only ends with corrupted states imo.
- nickik 9y agoThat is just old marxist economics that has been disproven. Economists agree that markets do not automatically lead to oligopoly. This is why Marx has no credibilty in economics. All his predictions turned out to be false not because 'economists are the hand maidens of capital' as leftist like to claim. In fact Marx economics was very popular amoung economist at one point, it was then deconstructed theortically and disproven by evidence.
- s2g 9y agoHow is that not capitalism? Businesses paying government to achieve their ends. It's both, I suppose. That's an argument for checks on capitalism and corruption. Your way is just unchecked harmful capitalism without any government controls.
- ouid 9y agoThis is not at all the effect being discussed. The effect being discussed is laid out quite plainly in the subtitle. I'll just quote it here, and save you the effort of right clicking and selecting open in new tab: "The idea that authoritarianism attracts workers harmed by the free market, which emerged when the Nazis were in power, has been making a comeback." It's a very simple mechanism. Capitalism produces winners and losers. The losers are eventually an angry majority. An angry majority will vote to maximize change.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoOptimistically, I think this is somewhat a self-limiting problem. Capitalism wound up helping workers - sharing far more of the gains with them than in Marx's day. Why? Out of the goodness of capitalists' hearts? Perhaps to some degree, but I think that part of the reason was the challenge of communism. Capitalists wanted to show that capitalism could give workers a better deal than communism, and in doing so, cut much of the ground out from under communism. Why would I want to try to bring about a "communist workers' paradise", if I see that I'm actually better off as a worker under another system? But after the collapse of communism, the capitalists have seemed to suck more of the money out, leaving less for the workers. That leaves the majority the losers, and becoming angrier and angrier. As you say, they're going to vote for change... unless the capitalists wise up. The other problem is, people keep offering them change, and the angry majority votes for them, and the promised change keeps on not showing up. Eventually, the angry majority is going to want to do more than just vote...
- JamesLeonis 9y agoTo your nuanced answer, has there been a time when Capitalism didn't seek to dominate all of it's regulatory bodies? Unions, governments, activists, even other Capitalists as they represent competition. There's a reason leftists call Imperialism the highest form of Capitalism.
- nickik 9y agoOf course they do. Adam Smith already understood this. However, just because any group in society wants to change the rules of society to their benefit, does not make the existance of those groups a bad thing per se. Sometimes people act as if that was unique for capitalist. In fact Unions, Activists, Government burocracies and so on have the exact same insentives, they want to change rules to benefit them. The reason leftists call Imperialism the highest statge of capitalism is because these leftists had a very limited understanding of both history and the reasons behind imperialism. Their theory never made much sense and much modern history has desproved these simplified Leninist notions.
- Stranger43 9y agoThe right is just as bad as history and have mostly manage to erase the economic system Smith wanted abolished, and according to Marx had re-emerged after Smiths dead. Or to put it differently capitalism was never envisioned as a critique of socialism, but as a critique of nationalist mercantilism, which is the same system international socialism was supposed to tackle a century after Capitalism had failed. Though by then Imperialism had replaced mercantilism as the common name for a system where one large property owners competed with each other for world supremacy with little regard for mere renters/workers. Once could argue that capitalism was revived after the two wars to end all wars finally managed to wipe out the old feudal order(at least in Europe) but one could also argue that the european disaster merely reset the clock and gave rise to a new (mostly American) aristocracy which is now finally becoming visible as a aristocracy. For a lot of 3rd world the end of European hegemony after world war 2 was perceived more a handover from one set of foreign owners to a new one, then "freedom and democracy", and the us have toppled more democracies then it helped build, giving some credence to the theory of the US as a mercantilist empire rather then capitalist democracy. In a lot of ways the problem is that few modern politicians(and that economist is in practice often a subclass of politician) dare to leave the confines of circular logic where morality can be a simple matter of good vs evil and history is a consistent narrative going from the bad old times to the brave new world. Which gives rise to an extremely toxic debate culture of fractions yelling general insults of each other, using words that have long since lost any resemblance of coherent meaning.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- balozi 9y ago"Damaging to society" is a a very subjective concept. The segment of society benefiting from said commingling of big government and big business might disagree with the assertion that their role is "damaging" to the broader society.
- levosmetalo 9y agoI listened recently on a radio an interview where the claim was that it's easier to achieve equality in a benevolent dictatorship than in capitalistic democracy. Capitalistic democracy tend to distort to an organization influenced by lobbies and corporations, and in the long run governments have to take that and pay back by allowing monopolies and their clients. In a benevolent dictatorship, corporations can't have a big influence on government. It's clear who is more powerful, and benevolent dictator can actually care more about the actual wellbeing of the people more than some democratically elected government which is just a proxy for big corporates. Pretty dystopian.
- CM30 9y agoTo be fair, it's arguably easier to do anything right if you have a benevolent dicator who knows what's best for society and doesn't care too much about whether people disagree. The problem is finding anyone who's truly 'benevolent' or would stay as such once they've got power. It's the same issue we see with a lot of systems; in everyone was a perfectly rational, decent person who only did what was right they'd be a utopia, but that's never the case.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoIt's also easier to achieve equality in a tyrannical dictatorship. If you aren't part of the (very small) inner circle, you're poor and exploited, just like everybody else. But most of us don't want that kind of equality...
- iel99 9y agoCapitalism as a social framework that “looks” like what we know wasn’t a thing until the mid-1800s 150+ years of “guidance” by experts, stewards of industry, and government making claims of operating roughly along that framework And this is where we are Humans are the problem with every social system they have built. Humans bring it down because humans get sick of propping up the dead past These silly abstractions rely on getting everyone on board and the ones that aren’t are treated as heretics Capitalism has never been about a free flow of capital and information It has since its beginning been inherently about benefiting the owners who, due to HUMAN nature, not government which is used as a straw man, an abstraction away from reality (humans are doing this, not “government”) Our economics, including capitalism are, like Trump, a byproduct of the broader cultural feelings. The words and attitudes flow; might and power bring gains. I will fight to protect them. Capitalism You can wave the math around and I’ll say ok yes they followed the rules of math. But it’s applied to the wrong context Humans are corruptable, emotional first animals. Capitalism manipulates that reality to favor conversation and action in support of owners It’s inherently intended as a framework to control conversation; protect my stuff and way of life It’s another religion. Belief and support of it are rewarded. Anything else and you starve In the land of the free. Ha
- sunshinelackof 9y ago> Humans are the problem with every social system they have built No one will ever be able to look at our network of interactions and create a perfect pattern with a social ideology. But we need a social system so that we can attach to it rules that fulfill our needs like self-preservation or even just hunger and companionship. We could do better for ourselves if we fit the social system to fit these needs and not the other way around.
- jklinger410 9y ago>an unhealthy degree of commingling of big government and big business The nature of Capitalism is always to press for this. Like a liquid, it will find any crack in your Democratic system to permeate. The answer is not no, or even not exactly, the answer is probably always at least a little. Democracy's job is to make it as little as possible. In America it seems we have gone the other direction once you start to dig in. See: political ad season and SuperPACs.
- isaiahg 9y agoI'm having trouble seeing how you made that jump from corruption to big government.
- WalterSear 9y agoIt's a religion :(
- dragonwriter 9y ago> But clearly you can see an unhealthy degree of commingling of big government and big business, in a way that is damaging to society at large. But to my mind: > a. that's corruption, not capitalism I can swear there is a name 19th Century critics came up for the politico-economic system then dominant in the developed West where the State, starting with the system of property rights and extending throughout all of its functions, is organized to serve the interests of and reinforce the power of the owners of the means of production, and it wasn't “corruption” (though that would have been a decent name, too.)
- asntbqjkwbucaa 9y agoWhat you wrote is the stock conservative answer, but I'd encourage you to think more closely about the question. In the US, the "it's big government's fault!!!11" line of thought starts with the slaveholders in the South and their penchant for a lawless aristocracy. It was picked up, especially in the 1940s-1970s, by conservatives opposing the left-leaning segments of society. They played to the Southerners and their longing for the old slave system, and they merged it with a corporatism with fascist tendencies. Both the pro-slavery and corporatist/fascist wings ultimately mean the same thing when they complain about big government: they believe that the government should not infringe the right of the wealthy to wield power absolutely over the rest of society. This is the sense in which Libertarianism and democracy are at odds. Peter Thiel has said the same thing, but he lands on the side of capitalism. Others, like apparently the New Yorker, are asking the same question and presumably land on the side of Democracy. So ultimately the question is: do citizens have a right to influence the laws that govern them? If so, then Libertarianism and laissez-faire capitalism can't be adopted because they explicitly limit the ability of the people to enact laws. Conversely, if laissez-faire capitalism is adopted, then democracy suffers because the wealthy insist that the unwashed masses cannot enact certain laws to protect the majority of people from a tyrannical minority.
- root_axis 9y agoThis is akin to the argument that communism didn't kill millions because it wasn't really communism. The commingling of government and business is how capitalism plays out in practice, it is an inevitable result of ostensibly "laissez-faire" economics.
- sunshinelackof 9y agoPure capitalism can never become reality because it's a philosophy. No philosophy that seeks to organize a potentially infinite number of sentient creatures can be fully implemented. So no, it's not an argument against capitalism, but it is an argument against policy. Most policy in The US uses capitalism as a justification for implementing bad policy that doesn't serve the argued purpose. Arguments like that are based off the premise that capitalism itself is enough of a justification because it's assumed it improves the state of affairs. Even if in most cases that it true it's a faulty place to argue from. Arguments on policy should directly concern how it improves the state of affairs, not how it serves an abstract philosophy. De-regulation and regulation both have their place and need to be addressed case by case. Although as an aside when regulating to protect an industry it's important to match those regulations with regulations to equally protect their customers--something that The US rarely does. Right now we have a lot of lazy and greedy policy-makers who have the power and money to continue business as usual and the last thing we need to worry about is what ideology a solution conforms to and not what the solution actually does.