2 ms·
You can accept an axiom for the sake of arguemnt and do some reasoning from it without really agreeing with it. You can evaluate the form of an argument without
by sp332 9y ago
You can accept an axiom for the sake of arguemnt and do some reasoning from it without really agreeing with it. You can evaluate the form of an argument without necessarily thinking that it's true or false.
The Munchhausen trilemma explains why you need axioms at all. If you could put forward an argument that didn't need further support (interrupting the "ad infinitum"), then you wouldn't necessarily agree with the argument but you could at least accept it as a self-contained idea. But we can't even get that far. Proofs that aren't either circular or endless must rest on some other statements that we can't prove.
- clairity 9y agoi believe that point is nicely encapsulated in gödel's incompleteness theorem (which is primarily about number systems, but analogous here nonetheless).