3 ms·
I can't help but always be skeptical with these rulings, as if someone's always just being thrown under the bus to protect the higher ranking career military pe
by Waterluvian 9y ago
I can't help but always be skeptical with these rulings, as if someone's always just being thrown under the bus to protect the higher ranking career military persons.
I think about how easy it would be to have a culture of sloppy, poorly trained sailors, and when something goes wrong, whoever is in the chair at the time takes the punishment for that.
Naturally I could be completely wrong about this or other cases. But it's hard to shake that skepticism.
- vertis 9y agoLooks like several higher fleet officers were fired or 'retired early' in the wake of this, so I'm not certain it's just throwing people under the bus. Scant details on what made them 'derelict in their duty'. Was it being negligence or was it mistakes caused by lack of training.
- pdonis 9y ago> Scant details on what made them 'derelict in their duty'. Was it being negligence or was it mistakes caused by lack of training. Both. The article doesn't say that, but from my own experience as a Naval officer, I'm pretty sure. Lack of training means higher ups were also at fault, and that's why they're also being punished. But lack of training does not remove your responsibility if you're the officer on watch. Nothing does. Those who don't like that should not become officers.
- eigenvector 9y agoThe US Navy has released a detailed report[1] on the incident in question. They found that lack of training, poor leadership and fatigue all contributed to the collision. [1] https://news.usni.org/2017/11/01/uss-fitzgerald-uss-john-s-mccain-collision-report https://news.usni.org/2017/11/01/uss-fitzgerald-uss-john-s-m...
- pdonis 9y ago> I can't help but always be skeptical with these rulings, as if someone's always just being thrown under the bus to protect the higher ranking career military persons. Keep a few things in mind: (1) By my count from reading the article, at least four admirals have been fired, and one has retired early. That's pretty much the entire chain of command in the Pacific fleet above the ships that had incidents. I don't know if any of them will face courts martial (I would expect not), but their careers are over, and they're not going out in a good light. (2) The captains of the ships involved are all facing possible courts martial (and I would expect that "possible" will become "actual" within the next few weeks, from the dates given in the article), even though none of them were on the bridge at the time of the incidents. That's standard procedure for a Navy ship: if you're the captain, everything that happens is your responsibility. The executive officer and command master chief of at least one of the ships are also receiving punishment. (The command master chief, btw, is the senior enlisted aboard the ship, whose primary job is to make sure all of the sailors aboard are being properly taken care of by their officers. So it's expected that the CMC will suffer consequences when that doesn't happen.) (3) I understand the whole "culture" thing, but at the end of the day, if you're a military officer, you're in charge, and it's your job to do what's necessary, culture notwithstanding. The officers who were operating those ships did not do their jobs, and sailors died as a result. That deserves punishment regardless of anything else.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dnautics 9y agoI once drove a Lyft for some army officers... IIRC they mentioned the military publishes a running record of all O5s and above that get court martialed and they noted that the navy takes sacking their O5 and O6 seriously, more than the other services.
- harshreality 9y agoWhoever is the officer of the deck at the time is responsible. That's what the position means, if it means anything at all. The sailors could be poorly trained, but the buck has to stop somewhere. How else can a command-structure organization work? At the very least, she'd have to effectively lose her job through loss of confidence in ability to command, even if she weren't court-martialed. Blaming higher leadership (which has also happened in these navy accident cases) in the military has the same problem. They're just products of their environment, too, put there ultimately by a chain of appointments ending with the President, Congress, and ultimately the voters. It's much better to focus on process improvement than on assigning blame. But command-authority organizations like the military don't really work that way, and it's difficult to improve the culture of the military when that culture is shaped by unwise demands — excessive operational demands, fiscal constraints, and directives that end up micro-managing and constraining what commanders do — from above. Even navy admirals have their hands tied in many ways, and they're just trying to do the best they can do with a bad hand.
- pdonis 9y ago> Even navy admirals have their hands tied in many ways, and they're just trying to do the best they can do with a bad hand. Trying, but still failing in this case. Playing a bad hand means you have to put more emphasis on the basics, not less. After all, ultimately military units are for fighting wars, and any war is going to be full of bad hands that you still have to play. A military that can't succeed in that kind of environment is not a military worth having.
- nostrademons 9y agoI'm curious then - how does the culture & process of the military get improved? Wartime, where everything and everyone that's ineffective gets discarded? Defeat, when the whole nation ostensibly being protected goes down?
- hudibras 9y ago>Whoever is the officer of the deck at the time is responsible. That's what the position means, if it means anything at all. The OOD is the very definition of a "You Had ONE Job!" job, and that one job is "Don't run into other ships or the land."
- peteretep 9y agoFrom the article: > The Navy has acknowledged that its forward-deployed 7th Fleet in Japan was stretched too thin – undermanned, overworked and exhausted under an intense operational schedule. To meet the high operational demand, training and ship maintenance were deferred, according to a Navy review.
- stefan_ 9y agoYou can court martial people who have neglected their clearly delineated responsibilities. It's much more difficult to court martial someone for bad command that caused the neglect. Those people are forced out, blacklisted or moved somewhere where they can't damage anything.
- CydeWeys 9y agoA good part of the problem is that they substantially curtailed basic seamanship training: https://www.navytimes.com/news/your-navy/2017/08/27/navy-swos-a-culture-in-crisis/ https://www.navytimes.com/news/your-navy/2017/08/27/navy-swo... You'd think that someone who's being put in charge of helming a billion dollar vessel with over a hundred people onboard would get lots of training for it, but nope, it takes more training to become a cosmetologist in most states than it does to helm a navy ship. Sometimes problems are multifactored and complex, but sometimes they're also just simple. The Navy simply stopped training people in how to steer ships, in a bid to save money and time. Turns out that maybe that training was good for something after all though.