4 ms·
That isn’t so much an argument as a false dichotomy, predicated on a system of agriculture which allows a near 50% rate of wasteage in the West. The alternative
by dbasedweeb 8y ago
That isn’t so much an argument as a false dichotomy, predicated on a system of agriculture which allows a near 50% rate of wasteage in the West. The alternatives include less productive, yet still sufficiently productive methods which do not include carcinogenic compounds.
Edit: Your state of being persuaded is immaterial, because what I said isn’t really controversial. One known alternative to herbacides is tilling, hardly a radical new invention and notably not carcinogenic. As I said up front, it would take more effort to produce crops, but simply by reducing waste you can more than make up for that. The use of ground cover, litter, and other established techniques all allow for large scale farming without herbacides.
There are other alternatives, and adjunct techniques as well, for example:
http://plen.ku.dk/english/news/2015/crops/ http://plen.ku.dk/english/news/2015/crops/
Stop wasting so much food because it isn’t pretty enough, and you can stop truffing carcinogens. That seems fair.
- tptacek 8y agoIt would be a false dichotomy if glyphosate hadn't literally displaced herbicides that were known to be human carcinogens and allowed anyways, but it did, so your logic isn't persuasive.
- sooheon 8y agoAnd what you're proposing is letting perfect be the enemy of the good. No matter how sustainable and green your alternative is, "less productive" anything won't fly in today's world economy. Until we change 8 billion humans' economic motives, maybe we can start with getting the facts straight on one substance.
- tropo 8y agoI like tilling, but it requires lots of diesel fuel and it increases evaporation. The future is probably robotic weed picking. That still requires fuel, but perhaps not as much.
- GW150914 8y agoIs there some reason that EV’s can’t till? If you’re farming there’s lots of sunlight for solar, and nuclear is a good option too.