12 ms·
Interviews vs. auditions
- jpatokal 9y agoTaking control audition style may work if you're a consultant trying to convince a client to hire them, but you had better know their business backwards and forwards, and unless you're in a very well defined space (like their football coaching example), you probably don't. However, if you attempt this at a standard FAANG job interview, it is emphatically not going to work. There's a set of questions you need to work through and attempting to go off script is not going to be appreciated. Pretty much the only exception is leadership roles, particularly when the brief is "we need somebody who can turn around/10x our floundering business".
- fizx 9y agoIt's worthwhile to distinguish between decision-makers and information-gatherers. FAANG interviewers have notoriously little decision-making power, though if you're given a time slot with your potential hiring manager, this approach might be worth a shot.
- closeparen 9y agoA good interviewer wants to stay on their script not because they're a disempowered automaton, but so that they can contextualize your performance relative to others they've given the same questions. Your job on an interview loop is to collect the best signal you can about the candidate's strengths in the assigned topic. You have broad latitude to use your professional judgement in going about that, but what makes your assessment persuasive in a debrief is calibration. An "original" interview may be a useful and necessary cost paid by the employer to train and calibrate a new interviewer, but opinions based on that interview have to be discounted appropriately in actually assessing the candidate. On the other hand, if you're a seasoned interviewer with a long-term favorite question, and report that the candidate's performance is an outlier in either direction, your voice alone could completely change the debrief room's opinion.
- walshemj 9y agoBut Most FANG interviewers don't seem to have any training
- closeparen 9y agoYes. Not all engineers take interviewing seriously, and even fewer actually want to be doing it in the moment. It can be seen as a too-frequent interruption that drags down productivity. This creates pressure to put interviewers in rotation who are not ready (so that more senior people can do their actual jobs) and can lead to a bad time when an otherwise-good interviewer betrays his annoyance at having you appear on his calendar. A disturbing proportion of your success as a candidate depends on luck of the draw.
- walshemj 9y agoThat always struck me as odd given Americas litigious nature. I worked for a big UK company in the past and you had to pass a 2 or 3 day residential course before you where allowed to interview anyone.
- closeparen 9y agoAside from discriminating on protected characteristics, white-collar employment decisions are not really subject to judicial review.
- walshemj 9y agoThey are in labour courts (assuming the USA) and at Tribunals in the UK - and a mistake in procedure is an automatic loss for employer side.
- nikofeyn 9y agowhat is FAANG?
- newnewpdro 9y agoFB AMZN AAPL NFLX GOOG
- pc86 9y agoWow you sure saved a lot of time by not just writing a complete sentence.
- blackoil 9y agoFacebook, Apple, Amazon, Netflix and Google
- k__ 9y ago"audition style may work if you're a consultant trying to convince a client to hire them" That's one of the main reasons I'm self employed. Getting a job is mostly doing dumb interviews, tests and crap. Getting a project is mostly telling the client that I can do it for an amount of money they find okay.
- chatmasta 9y agoAs a consultant you are much more in control of your working relationships than as an employee. A consultant has many clients; an employee only has one employer. That alone provides sufficient leverage to dictate the terms of the role, which is a major advantage of self-employment.
- jaggederest 9y agoI think it's basically the same deal PG is always talking about: Nobody is willing to pay triple for an employee which is actually three times as productive, but a consultant can honestly charge three to five times as much in order to provide equivalent return on investment. I also find that in general, people who won't listen to an employee are excited about collaborating with a consultant - even when you're the same person making the same contributions. I find it pretty frustrating - I have long-term views and I want to make a significant, long term impact on the companies I work for, and being a consultant means it's all about quarterly results. That being said, I'll take sober consideration from day one over "time over grade equals seriousness" any day.
- kelvin0 9y agoTotally agree, as a veteran Software Dev, been consulting for 2 years now. Most customers want some degree of assurance that you can solve their problem and that you also have a track record of proven success (no FizzBuzz BS). The downside is that most customers are also non-technical, so it becomes challenging (for me at least) to explain some concepts which impact the ongoing project. This is where I think building trust within a business relationship is important, and why you should avoid any customers who distrust you and your credentials. Because the bottom line is : if you can't explain all the finer details to someone, but they trust your judgement and ability, everything else becomes much easier.
- raverbashing 9y ago> However, if you attempt this at a standard FAANG job interview, it is emphatically not going to work. Agreed, do you know why? They're looking for yes men. (Ok, maybe not the A later in the alphabet - not sure today) Now if you meet someone "higher up the chain" outside of a formal setting, this might work.
- occamrazor 9y ago> They're looking for yes men. Or maybe they hire thousands each year and want to ensure some consistency in the candidate selection criteria. This could result in hiring more yes-men, but the _intention_ may be different.
- scarface74 9y agoI would die a thousand deaths working in a company like that. How can you possibly build your resume if everything on starts off with, "I worked on a team that did X?" at a small company you can say "I did X, Y, Z".
- capitalsigma 9y agoBelieve it or not, engineering is highly collaborative. If your dream is to work by yourself so that nobody else can take any credit, you might be better off in a different field.
- scarface74 9y agoThere is a wide spectrum between “working by yourself” and working for a large beuracratic company where you’re just a number. I can take credit for leading a lot of initiatives at the companies I’ve worked for without being in management. It’s the difference betweeen working for small companies - or larger companies with a small development shop - and massive companies. I would never know as much as I know about networking, infrastructure, devops, architecture, security, etc. in addition to development if I spent all of my life in a large company.
- 9y ago
- scarface74 9y agoThere are millions of companies out there that are not part of the big big 5. I don’t need to know their business backwards and forward and I probably won’t know enough about their internal pain points until I get there. But I’ve noticed over the years, that most companies that are interested in hiring me, have the same sort of issues when it comes to trying to deliver their product.
- whitexn--g28h 9y agoIt's the big 4 now. See Enron, and Anderson.
- scarface74 9y agoBig 5 was in reference to the technology companies FAANG - Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Netflix, Google. I have no idea why people include Netflix and not Microsoft.
- jogjayr 9y ago> I have no idea why people include Netflix and not Microsoft. Netflix pays outlandishly well - which is why engineers include it on their list of big companies. Leaving that aside Netflix is a giant: $150B market cap as of this writing. The term "FANG" was created by TV stock pundit Jim Cramer to describe tech stocks that have done particularly well over the last 7-8 years[1]. Maybe he felt MSFT's stock performance wasn't that strong or that he couldn't make a catchy acronym if he included it? 1. https://www.thestreet.com/story/13230576/1/what-are-fang-stocks-and-why-does-jim-cramer-love-them.html https://www.thestreet.com/story/13230576/1/what-are-fang-sto...
- scarface74 9y agoI would have thought Microsoft was a has been before Satya Nadella took over so that assessment was fair. He hadn't been the CEO for long in 2015. I guess as an outside developer, I'm looking at things from the perspective of platforms. Netflix isn't a platform that you build on.
- js8 9y ago> However, if you attempt this at a standard FAANG job interview, it is emphatically not going to work. It's kind of "offense is the best defense" method. I haven't done many interviews, but I found a good strategy is to have some questions about the technology the company is using. Then you can both show interest and turn the interview on the head, instead of them asking you technical questions (for which you might not know the answer), you ask technical questions that show you have done some basic research and have basic understanding. I have used a similar strategy on some oral exams at the university. Many people (especially specialists) are not natural examiners, and are delighted to talk about their field with someone who has some understanding of it, regardless of the fact that they should conduct an interview or exam. But then again, it takes a certain type of character to do it (since I am a curious person, it comes somewhat naturally). You can't really fake it, you have to put in some effort of learning about the technology in question in advance.
- toast0 9y agoI've had this happen to me as an interviewer. It seems good at first, but when I eventually bring the interview back into my 'can you design a simple data format, and then use the format you just designed' problem, I usually find the answer is no. I try not to let this bias me when I realize the candidate had led me astray, but it's hard when every candidate that leads me astray can't do my problem.
- Silhouette 9y agoHowever, if you attempt this at a standard FAANG job interview, it is emphatically not going to work. Indeed, but someone willing and able to do this well probably isn't applying to work at Facebook today, they're applying to be co-founder or employee #1 of a business that might be the next Facebook.
- vinceguidry 9y agoYeah, the one thing I kept thinking about when I was reading Ryan's essay was, "yeah this won't work in a real meat grinder, audacity isn't the right choice for every situation." Of course, knowing Ryan, the answer to that situation is going to be, "don't put yourself through a meat grinder."
- whack 9y agoIt also depends heavily on what kind of role you're applying for. If you're applying as a product manager, then sure, present your big audacious vision on how you're going to transform XYZ widget. Even if they don't actually do it, it's a good way to showcase your capabilities. But if you're applying as a software engineer? What exactly are you going to present then? Nobody wants to work with a guy who's never seen the code base, but wants to rewrite the whole thing in Rust.
- ryanbrunner 9y agoYou don't necessarily need to present a vision for the specific things you can do for the company, but you can take the initiative and present why your specific set of skills will be well suited for the company in question. I do agree that you need to be careful with this - many companies will want to put you through "their process", and attempting to take control of the conversation when it's not welcome will tank your chances at a position, but I do think it's worthwhile to try.
- fouc 9y agoWould reframing the developer "technical interview" as an audition instead create better expectations for everyone?
- _pmf_ 9y ago> Would reframing the developer "technical interview" as an audition instead create better expectations for everyone? If companies would frame it as such, I could choose to avoid these companies. So for the candidate, it would have a tangible benefit.
- paulie_a 9y agoYes I would absolutely avoid a company that called it an audition. I am not an actor and should not have to perform for a company... It's basically saying "we want you to jump through even more hoops than you already did" You need to also sell me on why I would want to work at your company. "Audition" is just insanely redicolous
- frostmatthew 9y agoThat's the analogy I use when people complain that whiteboarding doesn't mimic/approximate they day-to-day job. If you're the casting director for a play you're going to have auditions, you're not going to cast people based (solely) on their resume and having a conversation about their acting background. But auditions are very different than an actual performance: there's no audience or costumes or props, the lighting is completely different than what it will be, you're reading from a script, you may be the only person on stage while the other roles are read offstage, you're being accompanied by a piano instead of a full pit orchestra, you're mostly standing in one place instead of moving to established blocking, and so forth. The point of an audition isn't to mirror performance night, it's to get an idea if you're capable of acting/singing/dancing/whatever. Likewise the purpose of whiteboarding isn't to mirror the day-to-day work, it's to get an idea of your problem solving capabilities (some might argue it's also to see if you actually know how to code, but personally I feel that's what the technical phonescreen is for).
- nunya213 9y ago
- hguhghuff 9y agoYou’ll just get knocked back for being tone deaf.
- scarface74 9y agoAnd if you’re looking for a position where you can have a major impact, that tells you a lot about the position.
- baxtr 9y agoWell... this article is merely saying (with many many words) that it’s way better to show up to interviews and important meetings with utmost preparation than unprepared.
- someonenice 9y agoIts more about what you are preparing for. Generally people prepare well on the technical details (algorithms, programming etc..) and solve the problems that are put forward by the interviewer. Here, you prepare well on the real problems faced by the company (say scaling beyond a million user) and then outline the solutions that you have for that.
- fab1an 9y agoI doubt this would work in any more structured interview process for a regular job at a larger company (with the likely expection of VP+ level jobs), but it could be very effective for interviewing at startups, especially when they're small enough for you to be interviewed by one of their founders. A good way to do this is probably not to take charge immediately upon concluding the small talk, but to simply ask whether the interviewer would be interested to set aside some time to see some ideas you had prepared for their business (shows binder)
- spicymaki 9y agoWhile I am not sure this would work in every situation, I appreciate the main thrust of the article: treat the interview as audition, come in prepared to talk about how hiring you will improve the business, differentiate yourself from the other interviewees.
- Ensorceled 9y agoI’ve noticed an increasing number of candidates using this kind of “take control of the interview” approach. It’s reached the point of having candidates talking over top of me during phone screens trying to wrest control of the conversation away. I’ve never hired someone who does this. I’m not interested in how you’re going to rework my team or rewrite our software. Interestingly, when interviewing potential peers or CEOs, I’m kind of expecting them to do this.
- rc_mob 9y agoArticle says to politely take control. Seems like your candidates forgot the polite part of the equation.
- watwut 9y agoTaking control and insisting on it is not polite, unless you the boss. It is pretty bad trait for college in cooperative environment.
- pc86 9y agoI've been out of college for ten years this month and I can still remember those few students who could not get it through their head that class was not a one-on-one conversation between them and the instructor.
- Ensorceled 9y agoMy favourite professor: “I’m glad you found my paper on Chaos Theory interesting but my Numerical Methods class is not the place to discuss it. Please stop interrupting me.”
- davnicwil 9y agoI think that's because it's very hard to get this strategy right. In some interviews, it may not be possible due to the way the interview process is set up, and in particular the magnitude of information asymmetry. I think getting it right hinges on two things: 1) Does the interviewer actually have a concrete objective that you are qualified to help them achieve -- even if they themselves aren't necessarily aware of it or have it top of mind. 2) Can you identify that objective either ahead of time or in the interview process, and in a polite yet direct manner convince them that you can help them achieve it. If neither of these are true, it is bound to come off poorly. Whiteboard/puzzle based 'general intelligence assessment' style interviews don't lend themselves to this. Wishy washy job descriptions don't lend themselves to this. Hiring processes influenced by politics rather than need (i.e. where a manager is disincentivised to hire someone better than they are) don't lend themselves to this. If a majority of candidates who try this strategy with you aren't able to pull it off well, perhaps step back and take a look at your recruitment/interview processes and see if you could actually help the good ones impress you. I'm not saying I've done this right in the past, quite the contrary. For me the ideal interview is me simply describing a problem my team has, and the interviewee educating me on how to solve it and why they are the right person to do so (though usually the fact they are able to do the former implies the latter). I've tried to format interviews more like this over time and I have personally found better results as a consequence.
- spodek 9y agoI teach and coach people to get jobs through performance and it works. Schools teach people to react, take tests, and show how great they are. For a posted opening, you're presenting yourself as a commodity -- a slightly shinier one, you hope. It's based on compliance. Most analytical, geeky types got a lot of schooling. After decades of it, most people have learned that model without awareness of alternatives. If you want to avoid challenges in life and just get a job so you can retire 50 years later with nothing remarkable in between, that strategy works. What Ryan described -- to audition -- is standard in other fields, such as sports, acting, singing, and other active, social, emotional, expressive, performance-based (ASEEP) fields. No actor won an oscar for his or her GPA. No athlete won a championship for being president of a student club. In ASEEP fields, your performance matters. Sadly, many in business continue to think and act on a compliance-based model. Those who start from a performance-based model find and create opportunities to excel. I'll always remember how a client told me he met a guy running a business in a field he wanted to move into. He told me he first got to know the guy to make sure he'd like working with him. He then told him his passions and hobbies in that field, then that he had zero professional experience, and then, as he told me, "I led him to hire me." That's leadership. The guy hired him, saying "I can teach you this field, but I can't teach getting it and you get it." (Incidentally, what he called "getting it" is what I taught him -- you can teach it, just not through a compliance-based model.) So he got paid to learn the new field. Not long after he started new initiatives in that business.
- teddyh 9y ago> I can teach you this field, but I can't teach getting it and you get it. — Man, like the animals, is meant to live together with others like himself. But the meaning of belonging to such a group is found in the comfort of silence and the companionship of solitude. — Is that why you let me enter and taught me? — We taught you, young man, because you already knew. Master Kan and Kwai Chang Caine, Kung Fu, season 1, episode 11, The Praying Mantis Kills
- ironchef 9y ago"If you want to avoid challenges in life and just get a job so you can retire 50 years later with nothing remarkable in between, that strategy works." I find this to be hyperbolic. Compliance and presenting yourself as having more value than the person next you have are not deterministic in "avoiding challenges in life" and not accomplishing anything remarkable. I don't want to run a startup. I want to put my head down and get shit done. Does that mean I don't want challenges in life? No. Does that mean I won't accomplish anything remarkable. No. One should be aware that compliance and process has its place. One could argue that the special ops schools (like BUDS) drills into you that you are but one of many and to be compliant (even thought BUDS itself is an audition) and that you are a commodity. Please tell me that Navy Seals avoid challenges and accomplish nothing remarkable.
- kylnew 9y agoAs an engineer I think this is best interpreted as a recommendation to ask a lot of questions when you are given the chance. Take it as an opportunity to demonstrate a greater understanding and care for the opportunity than just the scope of your role. Ask about culture, about challenges, competitive positioning in the marketplace etc.. I try to ask questions that demonstrate a lot of compassion for team dynamics and business objectives. It’s never led me astray.
- refurb 9y agoAs someone who has interviewed a lot of candidates, I would agree the Q&A is the best place to show this. Most of the stock questions are filters for people who can't do the job - was this person's answer reasonable? Where I've seen candidates shine is when they ask really good questions. Question that indicate they've put some thought into the role. When all I get is "How do you like working here?" or "What's the company culture?" it shows the person is either uninterested in the role or incapable of delivering something beyond "here's what you asked for boss".
- pitt1980 9y agoSeems like the key to making this work is having done the legwork beforehand to know you're making suggestions that won't wind up being tone deaf. That legwork probably looks like having several conversations beforehand with people on the inside beforehand, so you actually have a basis for thinking you know what sort of problems are relevant for the decision makers. On average, that's probably something college students looking for their first jobs aren't well positioned to do (especially if they're looking for their first job through formal recruiting channels at huge corporations). And on average, for people with a few years of professional experience, its a matter of realizing that hanging out at conferences, happy hours, and other informal situations where you're around other similar professionals is low hanging fruit for these sorts of conversations, and recognizing that these situations present these sorts of legwork opportunities is a big advantage. ---------- I said students don't typically do that well, but I don't think that has to be a rule, lots of advice talks about trying to do 'informational interviews'. I think this is sort of what they're getting at, what you want to get out of an informational interview, is to sort of be able to frame the problems a future interviewer might have, and be able to do an interview like this. There's probably a lot of trial and error that goes into getting this right. And also, probably a lot of investment in having conversations where the payoff doesn't seem very obvious. --------- couple book suggestions: 1. http://www.svastralwind.com/uploads/2/7/2/6/2726225/the_2-hour_job_search_-_using_technology_to_get_the_right_job_faster.pdf http://www.svastralwind.com/uploads/2/7/2/6/2726225/the_2-ho... gives a method for setting up informational interviews, good read overall 2. I've suggested this books a couple times, I think its actually really deep when contemplated on Spin Selling by Neil Rackham ------------- Let me do a quick breakdown on why I think Spin Selling is really deep. Its basically a method for asking questions that elicit deeper responses its breaks down all sales questions into 4 categories: SPIN Selling proposes there are four types of questions, thus SPIN stands for : 1) Situation Questions deal with the facts about the buyers existing situation. 2) Problem Questions ask about the buyer's pain and focus the buyer on this pain while clarifying the problem, before asking implication questions. . These give Implied Needs. 3) Implication Questions discuss the effects of the problem, before talking about solutions, and develop the seriousness of the problem to increase the buyer's motivation to change. 4) Need-Payoff Questions get the buyer to tell you about their Explicit Needs and the benefits your solutions offers, rather than forcing you to explain the benefits to the buyer. Getting the buyer to state the benefits has greater impact while sounding a lot less pushy. What these questions do is probe for explicit needs. The quick takeaway, is that sometimes situation and problem questions are sometimes needed to make sure you know what everyone is talking about, but those questions are boring for the person being asked them. The basically amount to giving information to someone who clearing doesn't know as much as they do. What you really want to do, are minimize those question (probably by googling extensively before hand), and ask implications questions and need payoff questions, those are the questions that will lead the listener to consider things they hadn't previously considered. When you start asking those questions, you'll start having conversations where you learn things other people don't know. This is presented in the context of making sales calls, but its actually good advice for a huge range of conversations where what you're trying to determine "what does the other person want?" "why do they want it?"
- crtlaltdel 9y agoAfter a thick paragraph about sports history I gave up, which is 100% my fault. The moment an abstracted "sports metaphor" becomes an actual detailed account of sports figures (players, coaches, teams, etc) my interest in the topic enters a death spiral.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nimbius 9y agoas an engine mechanic, is this sort of game play normal in office jobs? When I've been taken on as an apprentice, its an interview to see my competency...where i stand i guess and what i need to learn. Questions like 'whats the hardest thing' and 'how do you handle grumpy people' are pretty normal. Being hired on full-time, and having to hire another mechanic myself, The questions are pretty cut and dry. Can you stick to a schedule, describe a 4 cycle engine, what a cam profile, give me a reference. Once weve hired someone new, we generally know if shes going to make it or not. we all chip in to help if theyre struggling, but we dont play weird games.
- learc83 9y agoFor some reason people are deathly afraid of hiring the wrong person. So afraid that they'd rather pass on 100 good candidates to avoid hiring one person who doesn't fit. It's particularly bad for programming jobs where they expect candidates to go through up to a half dozen separate interviews. The whole process is just completely broken.
- brookhaven_dude 9y agoThis is basically what a good sales pitch is. Call it audition if you want. A lot of developer jobs are not looking for this kind of drive and skill set though. In fact, I have been told by a former startup employer to not spend so many brain cycles on how to improve the business and just focus on getting the code to work. Many managers feel threatened by such people it seems. So not a good idea if looking for a job. Good template if pitching to investors.
- vinayms 9y agoI only skimmed the article, but whenever I read such material I feel these techniques are suited for jobs banking on charisma instead of knowledge and skill based ones. I am a software engineer. I haven't held too many jobs, and have attended very few interviews. As an interviewee, I always gauged the enthusiasm of the interviewer before 'unleashing my talent'. I have had my share of insipid interviews where the focus was on API specifics instead of ideas and larger pictures. I politely excused myself out of the building mid interview when I realized they needed just a code monkey, albeit with experience. Seizing control would have been a total waste. I have also conducted my share of interviews. The biggest turn off for me is when candidates try too hard to impress, either by listing out insignificant contributions to FOSS they have made, especially when not asked, or wearing their supposed geekiness on their sleeves. The worst are the self declared nerds and geeks, who speak, look and act in a way that covers all the stereotypes floating on the web. Its worse when, out of turn, they bring up a cool thing they 'hacked'. Generally, going beyond job interviews, I think the need for being alpha is ridiculously amusing. I am no psychologist, but it smacks of overcompensation and utter lack of self confidence. I avoid such people in life.
- lainga 9y agoH[acker] and non-H are the U and non-U of the 21st century! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U_and_non-U_English https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U_and_non-U_English
- zerowellies 9y agoIs charisma not valuable in all jobs?
- stronglikedan 9y agoI don't think so. If it's not customer facing and not team focused (e.g, a data entry clerk), then I don't think it would affect ones performance, and thus, not be "valuable" to the job.
- noobhacker 9y agoI think if you give the article a second chance, you'll see that it does not advocate for the self-promotional behavior you dislike. The article doesn't tell us to "listing out insignificant contributions to FOSS they have made, especially when not asked." Rather the article tells us to research about how we can add value to our prospective employers beforehand. Stated in that way, the article's message is quite "boring", but also true.
- mCOLlSVIxp6c 9y agoFurther discussion from Ryan about this topic in a recent EconTalk podcast: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2018/04/ryan_holiday_on_1.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2018/04/ryan_holiday_on_1.h... The part about interviews vs. auditions is around the 49 minute mark. The entire podcast was fascinating. The topic of the podcast is his recent book about Gawker and Peter Thiel and a broader discussion about "conspiracies". edit: separate HN thread for this https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17048391 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17048391
- adolph 9y agoIt was a really good podcast. One of my takeaways is that Holiday does a good job of not "taking sides" even though it is a seductive, socially compelling thing to do. I think that EconTalk and the book deserve their own HN thread.
- trevyn 9y agoIMO, the reason this is rare and stands out is because these types of people tend to already be running their own show, and don’t need to interview or audition.
- imaadrashied 9y agoI don't know if the need to have the entire program written out is most important. The best candidates I've hired show aptitude to ask the right questions and, in return, ask probing questions about what led to our decisions, have we thought of [x], this is how [x] might work, what about [y] competitor or space within our industry, etc... The most memorable interviews I've come out of / been a part of are the ones in which the candidate leaves me thinking or scratching my head about why we're doing what we're doing and whether they'd be a great fit to help us achieve our goals. This is all from a product management perspective so might not be the same across the board.
- falcon620 9y agoI just went through a phone interview with a candidate today who did this. He had pre-shared a 36-page presentation of his career/goals/etc. I spent some time studying this presentation ahead of the interview and thought he was thoughtful and that this indicated an attention to clear communication. Then we started the interview. I told him I had read his presentation in detail and commended him on the homework. He then super-politely asked if he could spend ten minutes to quickly go through it to add some more details, via a shared screen service. "Sure, why not?" 40 minutes later I finally cut him off, two thirds into the presentation. I came away from this thinking he was trying to control the communication, perhaps stearing me away from probing at his weaknesses rather than thinking he was a proactive comminicator. Please don't do this.