5 ms·
Sounds to me like the reasons he stopped reading HN were: 1) He couldn't stop himself from posting. He had to comment on things even when he had nothing to a
by wccrawford 16y ago
Sounds to me like the reasons he stopped reading HN were:
1) He couldn't stop himself from posting. He had to comment on things even when he had nothing to add. He even admits to commenting solely to gain karma.
2) He couldn't stop himself from reading the things he found pointless. All the flame wars, the arguments, etc.
Just learn to skip all that. Learn to only post when you have something to add. Only read an article when you actually care about the article. Only read the comments when you care both about the article and what others have to say about it.
Learn some self-control.
That, or tell me what the new best tech-news site is. I get a lot more information about new techniques, languages, etc etc here at HN than anywhere else at the moment.
- tel 16y agoIt's a matter of SNR though, isn't it? Sure you can skip things and sure you can edit yourself, but it's also easier (healthier?) to just stay somewhere that, to your own personal comfort, delivers signal and promotes meaningful response. The less I have to bear the burden and sink the energy cost of filtration the more I can put into comprehension, enjoyment, and growth.
- swah 16y agoSometimes I write a comment, but writing makes you think more clearly about the subject, and so I realize it is not very insightful. Then I discard it and feel very proud for saving everyone's time.
- MarkBook 16y agoThat deserves karma!
- abraham 16y agoI'm curious how many people started replying to you but ended up discarding it.
- billswift 16y agoSame here, I discard at least two-thirds of the comments I start.
- robryan 16y agoI think this indicates a higher average quality than other online comments better than most other indicators. In most places the comment would get posted anyway, but here you feel your writing as part of an average standard which is much higher. I know for one that I also pay more attention to use of words and grammar on here that I probably would other places because that is what the standard is, that is what we all like to read and comments not at that standard usually end up down the bottom heavily down voted. You don't see a lot of well written and constructive comments down voted even if they are arguing a alternate and contentious viewpoint.
- wccrawford 16y agoI quite often write out a whole comment pointing out the error of someone's thinking, or just lashing out in general, then realize that I'm not actually adding anything, the person won't listen anyhow, and I'm just wasting my time, others' time, and being negative. So I click 'back' on my browser and it goes away. Since I learned to do that, my time on sites like HN has been much more rewarding.
- rapind 16y agoI couldn't agree more. I still manage to slip in some meaningless and regrettable comments, but fortunately far less then the drivel you never get to see.
- mortenjorck 16y agoI've actually thought that the biggest flaw in HN's interface is that the user's karma is displayed on the home page. I've no doubt it seemed like a good way to encourage and reinforce contribution, but I fear it's enabling to a subtle sort of addiction. Precisely what that addiction is to is perhaps what's hardest to answer. Is it attention? Validation? Some more abstract notion of amassment and score? I've noticed myself looking up into the corner upon return to the site, and have even consciously avoided that gaze pattern at times. It may even come down to such fundamental questions as the existence of altruism. Just as one can ask "are you doing this for someone else, or just because doing things for others makes you feel good?" one can ask at "are you contributing thoughtfully because you want to participate in the community, or because you want to see your karma go up?" If you want to see your karma increase, is it because you want to participate, or the converse? Can the two be functionally separated?
- hammerdr 16y agoI write very few comments. When I do write a comment, I always do the top-right corner check when I come back. To me, its validation that my opinion was well taken by the community (a community that I respect). I'm going to try to avoid that this time :)
- xenophanes 16y agoIf you're not getting down voted a reasonable proportion of the time, you're too timid a thinker (or your comments avoid all controversy and stick to technical matters).
- jamii 16y ago> I get a lot more information about new techniques, languages, etc etc here at HN than anywhere else at the moment. I find much more useful content on reddit these days. HN tends to be full of opinion pieces with very little technical content. These sometimes start interesting discussions but I don't feel that I actually learn anything useful either from the original article or the comments.
- ajscherer 16y agoBeing unable to stop reading or commenting on hn can never possibly be the reason you've successfully stopped reading or commenting on hn can it? He wanted to spend his time reading and discussing articles on hn. His problem was that he was finding it increasingly unrewarding. So he quit. Your last point regarding the best tech-news site is irrelevant. He is replacing hn with "arguing with people in person or via e-mail, reading disagreeable books, and the like."
- billswift 16y agoAnd getting his tech news from his RSS feed.
- 10ren 16y agoA way to implement this is to use the new page. There's little indication of what you "should" read, so you have to make up your own mind, from the title or brief skim. There's no or few comments, so less opportunity for meaningless conflict that is irrelevant to the submission. It is, however, more work. bonus: you have a massively increased influence on what gets to the front page - so, to an extent, you create the HN you want.
- SkyMarshal 16y ago"Just learn to skip all that. Learn to only post when you have something to add. Only read an article when you actually care about the article. Only read the comments when you care both about the article and what others have to say about it." Perfect advice. That pretty much applies to the entire Internet, not just HN.
- points 16y agoOne of the problems with the Karma thing is it's ridiculously simple to gain karma. Unless you're deliberately being stupid. All you have to do is say something you believe will fit in with the groupthink of the community. The first step to salvation is the realization that karma="how much time you waste commenting" rather than how much your comments are valued. I'd like to see a community where there is a limited supply of karma. Or your karma is shown as a percentage of total karma. I think that would produce much better dynamics.