10 ms·
If you got into the drivers seat at 0.07 you are doing something wrong. Unless breathalysers detect alcohol when none exists, then I think knowing they are "10
by lifeisstillgood 9y ago
If you got into the drivers seat at 0.07 you are doing something wrong.
Unless breathalysers detect alcohol when none exists, then I think knowing they are "10% eitherway" is a good caution.
- trentmb 9y ago> If you got into the drivers seat at 0.07 you are doing something wrong. Then change the law so .07 instead of .08.
- rascul 9y ago> If you got into the drivers seat at 0.07 you are doing something wrong. Not legally.
- hbnyc 9y agoHow can you justify this from a legal standpoint? Personal ethics be damned, we've established that 0.08 is the line. 0.07 is not above or equal to that. You can't say someone is in the wrong because they are close, but not on the other side, of something binary.
- thaumaturgy 9y agoWhat's happening in this thread right now is simply a difference of moral frameworks. On one side, you have people for whom right and wrong is defined by the law: if it's legal, then it's right, and if it's illegal, it's wrong. Therefore as long as people are making decisions that are consistent with law, they are fine. On the other side, you have people for whom right and wrong is a fuzzier judgement of consequences somewhat independent of the law. If it's dangerous but legal, it's still dangerous. If it's illegal and not dangerous, then maybe it shouldn't be enforced by law. It's sadly unlikely that either side is going to find any agreement with the other. I'm firmly in the second camp on this particular issue: I don't care that the law says that anything up to .08 is okay; if you're close enough to .08 that a marginal error in a device could make it illegal, then I wish you weren't driving. Hell, if I'm out, I'll give just about anyone a free ride home, and take them back to their car in the morning, if that's what it takes to keep them from driving "a little bit" drunk.
- dpark 9y ago> What's happening in this thread right now is simply a difference of moral frameworks. That’s not what’s happening at all. No one here is asserting that .08 is some moral boundary. What’s happening is that some people here think that people convicted of criminal acts should be guilty of those acts as defined in the law. Other people think that pretty close is enough to declare someone guilty of a crime. .08 is the legal boundary. If you’re driving at .07, you have not broken the law. > I'm firmly in the second camp on this particular issue: I don't care that the law says that anything up to .08 is okay; if you're close enough to .08 that a marginal error in a device could make it illegal, then I wish you weren't driving. That’s lovely but “I wish you weren’t driving” is not the law.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> .08 is the legal boundary. Usually, it's the boundary between “defintiely DUI [or DWI, where these are distinguished] by BAC” and “quite probably DUI by being under the influence, for which BAC may be supporting evidence”. > If you’re driving at .07, you have not broken the law. That's inaccurate.
- dpark 9y ago> Usually, it's the boundary between “defintiely DUI [or DWI, where these are distinguished] by BAC” and “quite probably DUI by being under the influence, for which BAC may be supporting evidence”. 0.08 is the legal boundary for per se influence of alcohol. If you aren’t at 0.08, you must be provably impaired by alcohol which is a different legal test. (0.07 could be supporting evidence, but so could the fact that you were at a bar, even if a BAC test was never administered.) To my understanding, very few DUIs are prosecuted for alcohol DUI with BAC below .08. Even fewer are prosecuted successfully. The BAC of .08 is enshrined in law as the point of “intoxication”, making it difficult to prove the “influence” of alcohol below that level. > That's inaccurate. It’s exactly as accurate as saying you have not broken the law driving at 0.01. You might be guilty of DUI at any BAC theoretically, if you demonstrate impairment.
- DennisP 9y ago
- uhhhhhhh 9y agoFrom a legal standpoint, its 0.08 within the ability to accurately measure BAC. I promise every machine has a margin of error and that is accepted. if you're within the margin of error for measuring equipment that's just part of life. Applies to radar guns, applies to breathalyzers, and every other technical solution to a legal issue.
- jessaustin 9y agoIf the margin of error for a particular device were 0.07, that would seem less acceptable as just part of life?
- unethical_ban 9y agoIf the law says someone must be at 0.08 or above, and the machine margin of error is 0.01, then the machine should have to read 0.09 before someone is penalized.
- sigstoat 9y agothe jury gets to know the the value, and the error, and weight it accordingly, along with the rest of the evidence. also the acceptable error on the GC/FID testing used for blood alcohol is 3-5%, depending on lab, etc. so that's 0.004. if you managed to get the cop's attention at 0.083, and you're drunk enough they bother to arrest you, instead of trying to find someone drunker to spend 2 hours arresting, the DA is still probably going to offer DWAI or less for your 0.083 unless you've got a long history of drunk driving.
- cascom 9y agoThen shouldn’t the margin of error tolerance of the machine be part of the law as well?
- bsder 9y ago> Personal ethics be damned, we've established that 0.08 is the line. 0.07 is not above or equal to that. Quite a few of the laws aren't written that way. A 0.08 is dead to rights guilty--generally a DWI--driving while intoxicated. However you very much can be convicted of DUI--driving under the influence--even if you blow significantly less than 0.08. This is especially true if the police also have you on video doing something stupid or speeding excessively.
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoCan I ask you (and anyone still reading) where they live and how important a car is to getting to, say, the nearest bar? I am trying to understand if this is an economic / urban / rural question or is really about a bright line between legal and illegal
- dpark 9y agoSo you’re okay with getting a speeding ticket for going 36 in a 40? 10% either way, right?
- thaumaturgy 9y agoNo, because 36 in a 40 isn't as likely to kill someone.
- dpark 9y ago.07 isn’t likely to kill anyone either. 0.08 isn’t exactly falling down drunk in the first place and .07 is less.
- thaumaturgy 9y agoIf you can provide some actual data for this, I'd be willing to consider it. The best I can find are some nhtsa stats that include collisions and fatalities for drivers with a .01 to .07 BAC, but it also includes the same stats for drivers with .00 BAC, so it doesn't look like they're identifying impairment as the primary cause of the collision: https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/ViewPublication/811654 https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/ViewPublication/... [pdf] Also, from their appendix: "Drivers are considered to be alcohol-impaired when their BACs are .08 g/dL or higher. Thus, any fatal crash involving a driver with a BAC of .08 or higher is considered to be an alcohol-impaired-driving crash, and fatalities occurring in those crashes are considered to bealcohol-impaired-driving fatalities." Too bad, that makes that particular study sort of useless for arguing the consequences of drunk driving.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dpark 9y agoThis is absurd. By your own admission you have no evidence that even 0.08 is unsafe (impairment is established by definition and not observation in your link) and yet you expect me to prove a negative and show that 0.07 is safe. 0.00 isn’t even safe. People have accidents while driving sober all the time. The reality is that you are deferring to the law when you assume that 0.08 is proven unsafe. And that’s a pretty reasonable assumption. 0.08 was supposed to be established as the level at which essentially everyone demonstrates some level of impairment (whether that’s actually true, I don’t know). But you have no evidence that 0.07 is unsafe. You lack scientific evidence and you also lack the ability to defer to the law. So your belief is arbitrary. You’re essentially saying that .08 is definitely unsafe because the law says so, so 0.07 must be unsafe, too, because it’s close. But this is unreasonable. If the law defines safety then defer to the law. Otherwise the law could be .07 and you’d be making this argument about .06. And so on.