3 ms·
Remind me again why a device paid for with public funds and used to carry out essential public functions of the government should be anything but open source.
by nerdponx 9y ago
Remind me again why a device paid for with public funds and used to carry out essential public functions of the government should be anything but open source.
- sigstoat 9y agothe government buys some of very nearly everything and uses them to carry out essential public functions. you've got to have a better criteria than that.
- logfromblammo 9y agoThe defense in a criminal case has the right to examine witnesses that presented evidence against them. When the witness is a machine, such an examination must necessarily include inspection of the operating protocols, technical specifications, calibration records, and source code. Forcing the defense to ask for it in discovery for every single case seems somewhat counterproductive. If your code is being used to put people in prison, you don't get to keep your trade secrets privilege.
- alistairSH 9y agoIt is counterproductive. It's also a feature of the system. At best (for the accused), thousands of dollars get spend on defense, pumping money into pockets of lawyers. At worst, the accused can't afford this level of defense and the DA gets another notch in their belt.
- jpdb 9y agoBecause the software/IP isn't owned by the government. I'd personally rather the US government pick the best solution, not the most open source one. I would hope the best solution is open source, but the gov't shouldn't be forced to sacrifice quality. However, I can agree that any Software/IP developed via public funds should definitely be open source.
- DennisP 9y agoDefine "best." My definition would be something that's not only accurate in most conditions, but lets the accused mount a meaningful defense. Comprehensive testing by an independent lab gets us partway, if all the results are available to the defense, but it's better if we can both do black box testing and examine the code.
- thatcat 9y agoHow should the public verify the government has chosen the best solution if the design of the solution isn't readily available? Depending on your perspective and definition of best, faulty designs that give more favorable results could deliberately be chosen to increase revenue / crime stats.
- jononor 9y agoTrustworthyness is (or maybe should) be an criteria for things being used to provide data for legal matters. Being able to independently verify the device is critical for this, and open-source makes this easier.
- craftyguy 9y ago> I'd personally rather the US government pick the best solution, not the most open source one. I'd personally rather the US government consider trustworthiness, which is only afforded in open source projects, to be an important criteria for "best solution."