3 ms·
“When guns are outlawed, only outlaws will have guns.” [...] could be transformed into an argument like “Since it’s possible to get guns illegally with so
by michaelt 9y ago
“When guns are outlawed, only outlaws will have guns.”
[...]
could be transformed into an argument like “Since it’s
possible to get guns illegally with some effort, and
criminals need guns to commit their crimes and are
comfortable with breaking laws, it might only slightly
decrease the number of guns available to criminals. And
it might greatly decrease the number of guns available to
law-abiding people hoping to defend themselves. So the
cost of people not being able to defend themselves might
be greater than the benefit of fewer criminals being able
to commit crimes.”
I think the one-line quote would persuade people more readily than the 10-line quote.
- samthecoy 9y agoYou're right, but that reflects more on human psychology than the quality of the argument. I'd argue the problem with discussion of current events on social media is exactly this - quotes and arguments are selected for psychological potency, and not merit.
- danharaj 9y agoAn argument is not always better just because it's more explicit, that's context dependent. People can deduce the chain of reasoning of the latter from the former, making the former a better argument if everyone is willing to think about each others' positions in good faith. Efficient and effective communication depends on shared understanding.
- DonbunEf7 9y agoThis is because the one-liner is actually (sorry SSC) a valid logical template, relying on assumptions about rule of law to draw a deductive inference. We can see the template itself: "When X is illegal to possess under some jurisdiction's law, then the residents of that jurisdiction will be criminalized by their possession of X, and thus the only possessors of X in the jurisdiction will be criminals." SSC probably doesn't like this one because it's definitional. People like to use "criminal" is a qualitative label for people who they feel have broken the law, but it is in fact definable as a quantitative label for people who have committed acts which are unacceptable as a fact of law.
- mannykannot 9y agoWe don't have to guess why Alexander disapproves the one-liner, as, after presenting the more thoughtful version, he writes: "The original is a gotcha exactly because it doesn’t invite this level of analysis or even seem aware that it’s possible. It’s not saying “calculate the value of these parameters, because I think they work out in a way where this is a pretty strong argument against controlling guns”. It’s saying “gotcha!”."
- mundo 9y ago> I think the one-line quote would persuade people more readily than the 10-line quote. Sure, and "My opponent once made a tweet that could arguably be interpreted as racist" will persuade even more people. But this article is not about persuading people. It's about two people with opposite opinions who recognize that they might be wrong, sharing the evidence that supports those opinions in hopes of learning something. Persuading people is what you do when you already know you're right.
- mannykannot 9y agoThat is one reason why poor arguments are common. If an argument loses its persuasive power when its limitations and tacit assumptions are spelled out, then it wasn't that good an argument to start with.
- justin66 9y ago> I think the one-line quote would persuade people more readily than the 10-line quote. Anyone who is thinking clearly, regardless of their position, can agree with "when guns are outlawed, only outlaws will have guns," as it is simply a tautology. If you hear someone agreeing or disagreeing with the statement, they are really agreeing or disagreeing with a longer, implied argument like the one provided, or else they're confused.