10 ms·
Varieties of Argumentative Experience
- michaelt 9y ago“When guns are outlawed, only outlaws will have guns.” [...] could be transformed into an argument like “Since it’s possible to get guns illegally with some effort, and criminals need guns to commit their crimes and are comfortable with breaking laws, it might only slightly decrease the number of guns available to criminals. And it might greatly decrease the number of guns available to law-abiding people hoping to defend themselves. So the cost of people not being able to defend themselves might be greater than the benefit of fewer criminals being able to commit crimes.” I think the one-line quote would persuade people more readily than the 10-line quote.
- samthecoy 9y agoYou're right, but that reflects more on human psychology than the quality of the argument. I'd argue the problem with discussion of current events on social media is exactly this - quotes and arguments are selected for psychological potency, and not merit.
- danharaj 9y agoAn argument is not always better just because it's more explicit, that's context dependent. People can deduce the chain of reasoning of the latter from the former, making the former a better argument if everyone is willing to think about each others' positions in good faith. Efficient and effective communication depends on shared understanding.
- DonbunEf7 9y agoThis is because the one-liner is actually (sorry SSC) a valid logical template, relying on assumptions about rule of law to draw a deductive inference. We can see the template itself: "When X is illegal to possess under some jurisdiction's law, then the residents of that jurisdiction will be criminalized by their possession of X, and thus the only possessors of X in the jurisdiction will be criminals." SSC probably doesn't like this one because it's definitional. People like to use "criminal" is a qualitative label for people who they feel have broken the law, but it is in fact definable as a quantitative label for people who have committed acts which are unacceptable as a fact of law.
- mannykannot 9y agoWe don't have to guess why Alexander disapproves the one-liner, as, after presenting the more thoughtful version, he writes: "The original is a gotcha exactly because it doesn’t invite this level of analysis or even seem aware that it’s possible. It’s not saying “calculate the value of these parameters, because I think they work out in a way where this is a pretty strong argument against controlling guns”. It’s saying “gotcha!”."
- mundo 9y ago> I think the one-line quote would persuade people more readily than the 10-line quote. Sure, and "My opponent once made a tweet that could arguably be interpreted as racist" will persuade even more people. But this article is not about persuading people. It's about two people with opposite opinions who recognize that they might be wrong, sharing the evidence that supports those opinions in hopes of learning something. Persuading people is what you do when you already know you're right.
- mannykannot 9y agoThat is one reason why poor arguments are common. If an argument loses its persuasive power when its limitations and tacit assumptions are spelled out, then it wasn't that good an argument to start with.
- justin66 9y ago> I think the one-line quote would persuade people more readily than the 10-line quote. Anyone who is thinking clearly, regardless of their position, can agree with "when guns are outlawed, only outlaws will have guns," as it is simply a tautology. If you hear someone agreeing or disagreeing with the statement, they are really agreeing or disagreeing with a longer, implied argument like the one provided, or else they're confused.
- indescions_2018 9y agoReference to William James' Varieties of Religious Experience. The first meta-narrative to treat religious practise as social phenomenon: http://www.gutenberg.org/files/621/621-h/621-h.html http://www.gutenberg.org/files/621/621-h/621-h.html And it's easy to see the parallel the author makes. Every minute aspect of modern living has become "religion". And there is a very public jockeying amongst a high priest class of prognosticating pundits all vying for influence and attention. But in the most fundamental matters of import beginning with the categorical assumption is essential. Namely, that there exists for any given problem, an optimal answer. It is simply a matter of collecting empirical evidence and making the appropriate analysis. Steven Pinker argues in his most recent book that if there were "no Hitler, there would be no nukes!" It was only the pressing war that goaded formerly peacefully inclined nuclear physicists to construct such technologies. With the resultant problems we now face of non-proliferation, cyber command and control, etc. And the logical extension would then take the form: well the Five Eyes nations or G-7 that represent our democratic allies need to develop the next generation of weaponry. To maintain the balance of power shifted in our favor. And so the policy of "mututally assured annihilation" continues ad infinitum until someone happens on a doomsday apparatus ;) But it is far from optimal. An optimal solution would be something akin to peaceful equilibrium throughout the planet. With space based deterrents against alien attack. But barring an actual concrete threat in that regard. We lack the foresight and will to make it happen. Obviously I believe part of the solution is electing more scientists and rational thinkers in positions of power. Which brings us back to square one. How to effectively communicate and "nudge" an outcome that foments optimal solutions.
- corey_moncure 9y ago> It was only the pressing war that goaded formerly peacefully inclined nuclear physicists to construct such technologies. With the resultant problems we now face of non-proliferation, cyber command and control, etc. But nuclear arms have essentially put an end to total war between developed nations. We've all agreed not to use them in conventional war, and disallowed chemical weapons as well, as those progressed from Lewisite and Mustard gas to terrifying V- and G- agents. In the absence of these technologies, pressing wars would have continued. >An optimal solution would be something akin to peaceful equilibrium throughout the planet. This is based on the notion that war is not necessary to maintain our species in optimal condition, which is an assumption that bears more examination. Why do we have war to begin with? Some species make war, many don't but some do, including us. But why do we do so? Doesn't it serve some beneficial or essential function for us?
- zimablue 9y ago4. If you hold the conversation in private, you’re almost guaranteed to avoid everything below the lower dotted line. Everything below that is a show put on for spectators. This is definitely not true. I think most people have social shaming arguments (another way of putting this is tribalism) so drilled into them that they believe it at a very core level and will socially shame you (in a less aggressive way) when speaking in private because it's core to how they think. "I hate how you're always agreeing/on the side of X"
- rwallace 9y agoThis is unfortunately the case, but an audience still tends to exacerbate the problem. In other words, OP is correct if we change 'almost guaranteed' to something like 'considerably more likely'.
- Matticus_Rex 9y agoI don't usually put myself in a position to have private conversations with that type of person, and I suspect Scott doesn't either, but you're very correct to point this out.
- KirinDave 9y agoAnd if you hold the conversation in private, the more powerful status quo will always have more resources to quash the discussion if they don't come off so well. Which is also, I think, a big plus to lots of SSC readers.
- truculation 9y agoDebate and criticism are defence, it seems to me; their value lies in averting heartache and war. For the purpose of changing the world, the ultimate argument is to create something new and substantial and then make progess with it, giving people somewhere to jump to.
- testando12345 9y agoyou're a piece of shit go fuck yourself haha
- jahaja 9y agoI guess I'm breaking the rules of "good" argumentation described in that article/essay now, but I'm yet to see anyone that links to "slatestarcodex" or similar "rationalist"'ish site, link to an article that is not an absolute massive scientificy sounding wall-of-text. Since this is basically the exact opposite from what I remember reading - correct me if I'm wrong - in "On Writing Well", I've started to assume that their core discussion/argumentation technique is actually a kind of attrition warfare - to tire the opponent out.
- samsolomon 9y agoWhile the writing on Slate Star Codex could be more concise, I do enjoy a lot of the ideas presented. A couple of style changes would have a much larger impact on the reading experience. As is there are about 115 characters per line and a narrow line height. Bumping the paragraph size to 16px and the line height to 1.6 makes the article dramatically less tiresome to read. If you publish long-form content, typography is incredibly important. For long articles like this 65-80 characters per line is the sweet spot.
- jerf 9y agoClassify SSC as philosophical musings, with a vague basis in science. If philosophical musings aren't your thing, and they are not most people's thing, it isn't going to appeal to you. SSC posts are generally "the sausage being made", not a nicely-digested final product such as you might get in a school course. I mean this as neither defense of SSC nor an attack on SSC. It is simply an explanation of what it is, and an observation that you may simply not be in the target audience.
- jahaja 9y agoFair enough. This seems to be a good view of it.
- dnomad 9y agoThe reality is that it's bad science and even worse philosophy. This stuff, like frankly all the rationalist nonsense, suffers from very highly motivated reasoning. The author isn't asking questions he's already decided on the answers and is now looking to justify his ideology. I suspect this is why rationalists are very careful to avoid actual philosophers. Philosophers make short work of this sort of simplistic thinking. People who really want to understand, say, the meta-ethics of modern democracy and debate are much better of reading Plato, Foucault and Rawls. Then you'd understand that sophism cannot be so easily dismissed because it is in fact pee pure sophism to say that certain arguments are "social shaming" and therefore not good arguments. The entire construction here -- the assumption that there is a single right answer to every argument and it can be arrived at if both sides are just reasonable enough and set aside their social biases -- is, as Foucault would show, a highly suspect assertion born of a very privileged position. People who seriously buy in to these sorts of simplistic models are going to have a bad time. Try having a "rational" debate with a Jewish person about whether all Jews should be exterminated. You might dismiss the response as "social shaming" and accuse them off being "triggered" and emotional... but such a victory won't buy you much.
- nerdponx 9y agoThis is a good excerpt for those who don't have time to read this: The Center for Applied Rationality promotes double-cruxing, a specific technique that helps people operationalize arguments. A double-crux is a single subquestion where both sides admit that if they were wrong about the subquestion, they would change their mind. For example, if Alice (gun control opponent) would support gun control if she knew it lowered crime, and Bob (gun control supporter) would oppose gun control if he knew it would make crime worse – then the only thing they have to talk about is crime. They can ignore whether guns are important for resisting tyranny. They can ignore the role of mass shootings. They can ignore whether the NRA spokesman made an offensive comment one time. They just have to focus on crime – and that’s the sort of thing which at least in principle is tractable to studies and statistics and scientific consensus.
- Intermernet 9y agoBut the arguments on both sides would be somewhat crippled by removing the use of stats relating to gun control vs. crime. Your quote may as well replace "gun control" with "religion" and "crime" with "morality". The arguments on both sides become superficial as you've removed the specific causes for each side to argue. You may as well continue this trend until both sides are arguing "good equals good" for differing values of "good". This stuff isn't easily arguable by humans with opinions. Removing the example data that forms the opinions doesn't make the arguments on either side stronger or weaker, it makes the argument as a whole less relevant to society. This is unfortunate because, as you quote, "that’s the sort of thing which at least in principle is tractable to studies and statistics and scientific consensus" Breaking complex issues down to be "tractable to studies" is possible, but most techniques are fraught with errors of over-simplification.
- justinpombrio 9y ago> But the arguments on both sides would be somewhat crippled by removing the use of stats relating to gun control vs. crime. In this case, the double crux was on crime prevention, so after agreeing on the crux they'd be only looking at gun control vs. crime statistics. Did you mean to say something else?
- haZard_OS 9y agoDouglas Walton has been my go-to on these topics for years. For those interested in a more professional presentation of some of the concepts used in this blog post, try this: http://www.dougwalton.ca/papers.htm http://www.dougwalton.ca/papers.htm
- taserian 9y agoThank you for this! I've always wondered if there was anything similar being done. I will say that this is quite a large collection of papers. Do you have any pointers as to which of these papers I should start with as a foundation?
- mundo 9y agoI think this is a useful article. The bit that struck me as most important was the bit about Clarifying - I think many pointless online discussions, including most straw-men, could be rescued by that practice. More specifically, if I were dang for a day, I'd edit the third guideline ("Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.") to add, "When in doubt, try paraphrasing the other side's argument in a way that they would agree with before responding to it."
- joew42k 9y agoIt's no surprise that the internet is full of "meta debate" and "social shaming" - arguing about the terms of debate and who can participate, and not over any core issues. For debates to be productive, all sides need to agree on at least some facts, and come from a place of good faith. Most places online, anyone can walk in and add their comment. They don't need to share any assumptions with the rest of the audience, and they probably aren't invested in having a productive debate anyway. It produces drive-by commenters. Productive debates are more likely to happen in places with 1. Moderation and 2. an invested community. That's what makes HN successful, in my opinion. But we can't turn every comment section into HN. Moderation is expensive. And some sites aren't niche enough to foster a sense of community. So we should probably remove most comment sections. News sites are particularly bad. Anyone can just stop by, leave their shitty opinion, and walk away.
- iandanforth 9y agoThis is why I like code. Sometimes you don't have to argue, you can just make something work. Not arguing is hard. I'm bad at not arguing, but the older I get the more often I repeat, "Can I demonstrate? No? Then don't engage." If something can't be conclusively demonstrated maybe I can spend my time productively in a way that makes me happy and maybe gets a little bit closer to demonstrating something I care about.